A map of signaling responses in the human airway epithelium

Katherine B. McCauley, Kalki Kukreja, Aron B. Jaffe, Allon M. KleinbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Receptor-mediated signaling plays a central role in tissue regeneration, and it is dysregulated in disease. Here, we build a signaling-response map for a model regenerative human tissue: the airway epithelium. We analyzed the effect of 17 receptor-mediated signaling pathways on organotypic cultures to determine changes in abundance and phenotype of all epithelial cell types. This map recapitulates the gamut of known airway epithelial signaling responses to these pathways. It defines convergent states induced by multiple ligands and diverse, ligand-specific responses in basal-cell and secretory-cell metaplasia. We show that loss of canonical differentiation induced by multiple pathways is associated with cell cycle arrest, but that arrest is not sufficient to block differentiation. Using the signaling-response map, we show that a TGFB1-mediated response underlies specific aberrant cells found in multiple lung diseases and identify interferon responses in COVID-19 patient samples. Thus, we offer a framework enabling systematic evaluation of tissue signaling responses.

Introduction

The human airway epithelium is a dynamic tissue capable of robust regeneration following injury. However, in chronic respiratory diseases such as Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis (IPF), COPD, and COVID-19, this process is often subverted, leading to metaplasia—the emergence of abnormal cell states that compromise lung function. While specific signaling pathways like Notch or IL-13 have been identified as drivers of these changes, the field has lacked a systematic "lookup table" to predict how various extracellular signals dictate specific cellular outcomes. This study presents a comprehensive signaling-response map, systematically connecting 17 receptor-mediated pathways to their exact transcriptomic and phenotypic consequences in the human airway.

Methods

To build this map, researchers utilized an organotypic model of primary human bronchial epithelial cells (hBECs) grown at an air-liquid interface (ALI). To study the regeneration process, they employed a "luminal stripping" technique using calcium depletion to remove mature cells, leaving only the basal stem cells to rebuild the tissue.

During a two-week regeneration window, the cultures were exposed to 17 different signaling agonists, including various interleukins, growth factors (EGF, FGF), and interferons. The resulting cellular states were analyzed using single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-Seq) of over 77,000 cells. Computational analysis via Consensus Non-negative Matrix Factorization (cNMF) allowed for the identification of overlapping "gene programs" rather than rigid clusters, providing a more nuanced view of cellular identity.

Experimental workflow and ligand selection strategy for mapping signaling responses in the human airway epithelium.

Key Results

Plasticity and Metaplasia

The signaling-response map revealed that metaplasia is not a monolithic process. For example, while IL-13, IL-17, and IFNA all drive an increase in goblet cells (secretory metaplasia), they do so through distinct gene programs and affect neighboring cell populations differently.

A striking finding was the extreme plasticity of basal stem cells. While mature luminal cells often retain their identity under stress, basal cells can have their normal transcriptional signature almost entirely erased by signals such as TGFB1 and IFNG, shifting them into entirely new, stable, and often dysfunctional states. The potency of these signals is reflected in the "fraction of control neighbors" analysis, where treatments like IFNG and TGFB1 resulted in cell states most divergent from the untreated control.

Impact of different signaling conditions on the fraction of control-like neighbors, highlighting the potency of signals like IFNG and TGFB1 in altering cell states.

The researchers also addressed the "cell cycle paradox." Many signals that inhibit normal differentiation also induce cell cycle arrest. However, experimental inhibition of the cell cycle alone was insufficient to block differentiation, suggesting that the arrest observed in disease is a consequence of signaling rather than the primary driver of regenerative failure.

Decoding Disease and Clinical Implications

By projecting the signaling-response map onto existing disease atlases, the authors were able to "decode" the origins of aberrant cells found in patients. "Aberrant basaloid" cells characteristic of IPF and COPD were found to be nearly identical to the TGFB1-induced states observed in the lab. In COVID-19 patient samples, the map identified a specific inflammatory fingerprint dominated by IFNA and IFNG responses, distinct from other inflammatory profiles like those driven by IL-13.

Furthermore, signals that caused the most significant loss of basal identity (TGFB1, IFNG, CHIR) were also associated with a measurable loss of epithelial barrier integrity, providing a direct link between signaling-induced metaplasia and tissue dysfunction.

Limitations and Future Work

While this map provides a powerful reference, it currently views the epithelium in isolation. In vivo, these cells interact with a complex milieu of immune cells, fibroblasts, and vascular components. Future research will need to explore the combinatorial effects of these signals—the "soup" of pathways present in chronic disease—to determine how they synergize or antagonize one another in shaping the airway landscape. This framework offers a systematic approach to evaluating tissue signaling, potentially identifying new therapeutic targets to redirect aberrant regeneration toward healthy tissue repair.

Summary updated

Abstract

Receptor-mediated signaling plays a central role in tissue regeneration, and it is dysregulated in disease. Here, we build a signaling-response map for a model regenerative human tissue: the airway epithelium. We analyzed the effect of 17 receptor-mediated signaling pathways on organotypic cultures to determine changes in abundance and phenotype of all epithelial cell types. This map recapitulates the gamut of known airway epithelial signaling responses to these pathways. It defines convergent states induced by multiple ligands and diverse, ligand-specific responses in basal-cell and secretory-cell metaplasia. We show that loss of canonical differentiation induced by multiple pathways is associated with cell cycle arrest, but that arrest is not sufficient to block differentiation. Using the signaling-response map, we show that a TGFB1-mediated response underlies specific aberrant cells found in multiple lung diseases and identify interferon responses in COVID-19 patient samples. Thus, we offer a framework enabling systematic evaluation of tissue signaling responses.
BibTeX
@misc{mccauley2022map,
  author = {Katherine B. McCauley and Kalki Kukreja and Aron B. Jaffe and Allon M. Klein},
  title = {{A map of signaling responses in the human airway epithelium}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.12.21.521460},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure