A longitudinal study of how mindsets influence motivation: Focusing on the interpretation of in-class feedback

Michael Huang, Akiko Fukuda, Yuka Ozaki2025 · DOI

This longitudinal study from researchers at Toyo University explores the psychological "filters" students use to process teacher feedback. By tracking university students over nine weeks, the authors demonstrate that a student’s pre-existing mindset (growth vs. fixed) significantly dictates whether a teacher’s praise or critique translates into actual learning motivation.

TL;DR

It’s not just what a teacher says, but how a student’s mindset "translates" that feedback. This study finds that growth-oriented interpretations of feedback significantly boost motivation, particularly for students who already hold a growth mindset, while cultural factors in Japan may buffer the negative impacts of fixed-mindset feedback.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In educational psychology, the "mindset" theory (pioneered by Carol Dweck) suggests that people either view intelligence as malleable (growth mindset) or innate (fixed mindset). While previous research has shown that teacher feedback influences student motivation, most of these studies were scenario-based—asking students how they would feel in a hypothetical situation.

This paper addresses the gap between laboratory scenarios and real-world classroom dynamics. It investigates how students’ natural, day-to-day interpretations of feedback in an actual English language course fluctuate over time and how those interpretations interact with their underlying mindset to drive (or dampen) their desire to study.

Methods

The researchers employed a longitudinal research design using the Experience Sampling Method (ESM) via smartphones.

  • Duration: 9 weeks.
  • Frequency: Students completed surveys immediately following each weekly English class.
  • Statistical Approach: The team used Multilevel Regression Analysis. This is a robust method for "nested" data, allowing researchers to distinguish between between-person differences (e.g., Student A generally has a higher growth mindset than Student B) and within-person fluctuations (e.g., Student A felt more motivated this week than they did last week).
  • Variables: They measured mindset as a baseline, then tracked weekly interpretations of feedback (growth-oriented vs. fixed-oriented), perceived teacher expectations, and after-class motivation.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset collected at a private university in Tokyo:

  • Participants: 25 undergraduate students (initially 49, narrowed down based on survey completion consistency).
  • Observations: 135 total cases/data points across the 9-week period.
  • Scales: Mindsets were measured using an 8-item scale adapted from Ichimura & Ida (2018), which assesses beliefs about the malleability of intelligence on a 6-point Likert scale.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Interpretation Filter: The same feedback (e.g., "Well done!") can be a double-edged sword. A student with a growth-oriented interpretation hears, "You're improving; keep going." A student with a fixed-oriented interpretation hears, "You've reached your natural limit of 'good'."
  • The Synergy of Growth: The most significant finding was an interaction effect. A growth-oriented interpretation of feedback didn't just help everyone equally; it was a "force multiplier" for students who already possessed a strong growth mindset.
  • Cultural Buffering: Interestingly, "fixed-oriented" interpretations (believing the teacher thinks their ability is unlikely to improve) did not significantly undermine motivation. The authors suggest this might be due to Japanese cultural values that emphasize diligence and effort regardless of innate talent, potentially shielding students from the demotivating effects of a fixed mindset.

Key Results

  • Hypothesis A-1 (Supported): Growth-oriented interpretations of feedback significantly increased learning motivation ($p < .001$).
  • Hypothesis A-2 (Supported): This effect was much stronger for students with a high growth mindset ($B = 0.856, p < .001$) compared to those with a lower growth mindset ($B = 0.301, p = .058$).
  • Fixed Mindset Hypotheses (Not Supported): Fixed-oriented interpretations and their interaction with a fixed mindset did not show statistically significant negative effects on motivation in this specific sample.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: With only 25 students and 135 observations, the study is relatively small, which may limit the generalizability of the findings.
  • Single Instructor: All data came from classes taught by one instructor. Future work should include multiple teachers to see how a teacher’s own mindset influences the feedback loop.
  • Subjective vs. Objective: The study relied on self-reported motivation. The authors suggest that future research should incorporate behavioral data, such as actual hours spent studying outside of class.
  • Cultural Context: Given the unexpected results regarding fixed mindsets, the researchers recommend cross-cultural studies to see if these "filters" operate differently in Western vs. East Asian educational settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

This research explored how a growth/fixed mindset influences learning motivation, particularly focusing on students’ interpretations of in-class feedback. A nine-week longitudinal study was conducted at a private university in Tokyo, in which a sample of 25 students completed a set of questions after each English class, giving a dataset of 135 cases. The students reported how they interpreted the feedback from a teacher during the lesson and how much they were motivated to invest more time and effort on English learning. Multilevel regression analysis revealed (a) a growth-oriented interpretation of the teacher’s in-class feedback increased students’ learning motivation, and (b) the above effect was stronger among the students with a more marked growth mindset. In summary, the current study confirmed that students’ learning motivation may be affected by their interpretations of teachers’ in-class feedback, especially when they have a growth mindset and their interpretation is in accordance with their mindset. The benefit of endorsing longitudinal data collection to investigate in-class interactions between teachers and students in real educational settings is discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2025longitudinal,
  author = {Michael Huang and Akiko Fukuda and Yuka Ozaki},
  title = {{A longitudinal study of how mindsets influence motivation: Focusing on the interpretation of in-class feedback}},
  booktitle = {THE},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.2130/jjesp.2513},
}
Figure