A longitudinal evaluation of improvements in treatment plan quality for lung cancer with volumetric modulated arc therapy

Wenlong Xia, Zhiqiang Liu, Lingling Yan, Fei Han, Zhihui Hu, Yuan Tian, Weijie Cui, Wenting Ren, Chenlei Guo, Junjie Miao, Jianrong DaiJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the number of optimization steps impacts treatment plan quality for lung cancer patients undergoing Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy (VMAT). They found that while more optimizations generally improve organ-at-risk (OAR) sparing, significant gains plateau after three optimization cycles, suggesting a potential sweet spot for efficiency and quality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing high-quality radiotherapy treatment plans, especially for complex techniques like VMAT, is a time-consuming and iterative process. Planners adjust numerous parameters to achieve optimal dose coverage for the tumor while minimizing dose to surrounding healthy tissues (Organs at Risk - OARs). The challenge lies in determining how many of these iterative optimization steps are truly necessary to achieve a clinically acceptable plan without wasting valuable planning time. Over-optimization can lead to diminishing returns, while insufficient optimization might result in suboptimal treatment. This paper aims to quantify the relationship between the number of VMAT plan optimizations and the resulting plan quality, providing insights into an efficient planning workflow.

Methods

The researchers developed a standardized planning strategy for VMAT lung cancer treatment plans. This strategy involved creating a technique script to ensure consistency in initial planning steps and a systematic data collection process. They analyzed 40 lung cancer patient plans, divided into two groups: one with a single target volume (PTV) and another with two target volumes (PTV and PGTV, for simultaneous integrated boost).

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Standardized Planning: A technique script was used to automate initial setup, reducing variability introduced by different planners' experience.
  • Longitudinal Evaluation: Plans were evaluated after each optimization step (Opt1, Opt2, Opt3, Opt4) to track changes in dosimetric parameters.
  • Plan Quality Metric (PQM): A novel PQM was defined, incorporating clinical constraints for target volumes and OARs. This metric allowed for a quantitative assessment of plan quality across different optimization stages.
  • Statistical Analysis: Paired t-tests were used to compare the differences in dosimetric parameters and PQM values between successive optimization steps.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 40 lung cancer patient treatment plans that had previously undergone conventional fractionated radiotherapy (CFRT). These plans were re-optimized using VMAT. The dataset was divided into two groups:

  • Group 1: 20 plans with a single Planning Target Volume (PTV).
  • Group 2: 20 plans with both a Planning Gross Tumor Volume (PGTV) and a PTV.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather uses existing clinical data to evaluate a planning process.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Diminishing Returns: The most significant improvements in OAR sparing and overall plan quality occur within the first three optimization cycles. Beyond this point, further optimizations yield only marginal benefits.
  • OAR Sparing vs. Target Coverage: While more optimizations consistently improve OAR sparing, their impact on target dose coverage and homogeneity is less pronounced.
  • Efficiency vs. Quality Trade-off: The findings suggest that for VMAT lung cancer plans, aiming for more than three optimizations might not be the most efficient use of planning time, as the quality gains become negligible.
  • Standardization is Key: The use of a standardized planning script and process was crucial for obtaining comparable data and drawing meaningful conclusions about the optimization process itself.

Key Results

  • Planning Time: The median planning time was approximately 1 hour (68.6 min for single PTV, 62.0 min for PTV and PGTV).
  • Number of Optimizations: The median number of optimizations per plan was 4 for both groups.
  • OAR Improvement: Significant improvements in OAR sparing (e.g., lung V5, V20, Dmean; heart V30, V40; spinal cord Dmax) were observed between Opt1 and Opt3.
  • Target Volume Metrics: While CI and HI showed initial improvements, they did not consistently improve beyond Opt2 and, in some cases, slightly worsened by Opt4.
  • PQM Scores: PQM values showed significant increases from Opt1 to Opt3, indicating improved plan quality, but the improvement between Opt3 and Opt4 was not statistically significant.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Planner Variability: Although a planning script was used, the study involved nine planners from a single institute. Different institutes might employ varying planning strategies and TPS, potentially leading to different results.
  • Data Collection Interference: The manual copying of plan data after each optimization might have slightly influenced the planners' workflow and the number of optimizations performed. The authors suggest developing scripts to automate data collection for a more seamless process.
  • Limited Scope: The study focused on lung cancer VMAT plans. The findings might not be directly generalizable to other cancer sites or radiotherapy techniques.

Future work could involve:

  • Investigating the impact of different VMAT planning strategies and TPS.
  • Developing automated data collection and PQM scoring within the planning system to further streamline the workflow.
  • Exploring the optimal number of optimizations for other tumor sites and treatment modalities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Increasing the number of optimizations was associated with significantly improved sparing of OARs with slight effects on the dose coverage and homogeneity of target volume. Generally, based on the designed planning strategy, there was no significant improvement of the plan quality for more than three optimizations.
BibTeX
@article{xia2020longitudinal,
  author = {Wenlong Xia and Zhiqiang Liu and Lingling Yan and Fei Han and Zhihui Hu and Yuan Tian and Weijie Cui and Wenting Ren and Chenlei Guo and Junjie Miao and Jianrong Dai},
  title = {{A longitudinal evaluation of improvements in treatment plan quality for lung cancer with volumetric modulated arc therapy}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1002/acm2.12863},
}
Figure