A logical treatment of special relativity, with and without faster-than-light observers

Benjamin HoffmanarXiv 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

This research provides a rigorous, first-order logic (FOL) foundation for special relativity. By stripping the theory down to its barest logical components, we explore the fundamental reasons for the light-speed limit and demonstrate how the theory can be mathematically extended to include faster-than-light (FTL) observers. Most students learn special relativity through the Lorentz transformations—mathematical "recipes" for translating coordinates between moving frames. However, this approach often obscures the underlying logical assumptions. This work tackles this by building an axiomatic system from scratch to see if the entirety of special relativity can be derived from a handful of empirically verifiable statements.

The SimpleRel Framework

The core methodology employs Model Theory, a branch of mathematical logic that deals with the relationship between formal languages and their interpretations. The system, SimpleRel, is built using a two-sorted first-order language with only two primitive predicates:

  • $aT\alpha$: Observer $a$ transmits signal $\alpha$.
  • $bR\beta$: Observer $b$ receives signal $\beta$.

From these primitives, complex physical concepts like "events," "simultaneity," "betweenness," and "equidistance" are defined. The central achievement is a representation theorem proving that any model satisfying these axioms is mathematically isomorphic to standard Minkowski spacetime.

Spacetime diagram illustrating the worldlines of different observers ($a, b, c, d$) within the SimpleRel framework.

As illustrated in the figure above, the logical axioms allow for the reconstruction of geometric worldlines. Here, $a$ represents a stationary observer (aligned with the time axis), while $b, c,$ and $d$ represent observers moving at constant velocities. This visual representation bridges the gap between abstract signal logic and the familiar geometry of spacetime.

Key Insights: Isotropy and the Speed Limit

A striking result of this logical treatment is that the "Slower-Than-Light" (STL) requirement is not an independent postulate. Instead, it is a theorem derived from the assumption of spatial isotropy—the idea that space looks the same in all directions. If the universe is perfectly symmetrical in its directions, FTL observers are logically forbidden within the standard framework.

Furthermore, the SimpleRel system is shown to be "decidable," meaning there is an algorithmic path to determine the truth or falsehood of any statement within this logical universe. This provides a formal proof for standard physical intuitions and ensures the completeness of the axiomatic set.

Breaking the Speed Limit: SimpleRelFTL

To allow for FTL observers, the author identifies the "Strong Isotropy" and "Uniformity" axioms as the constraints enforcing the light-speed limit. By weakening these specific axioms, a new system, SimpleRelFTL, is created. This expanded framework consistently incorporates "tachyonic" observers without collapsing into logical contradiction.

The paper demonstrates that FTL observers are not inherently "illogical." By relaxing specific geometric constraints, one can maintain a consistent version of relativity where some observers perceive "timelike" intervals as "spacelike" and vice versa. This mapping ensures that the abstract logic still aligns with a coherent (albeit expanded) geometric representation of Minkowski space.

Limitations and Future Work

While the thesis provides a robust kinematic foundation, it focuses on the geometry of motion rather than the dynamics (mass, energy, and force) of FTL particles, where causality violations typically arise. Additionally, while the framework operates in three dimensions, the full physical implications of 3D FTL travel remain a complex frontier. Future work could involve proposing specific experiments to test the validity of the signal-based primitives under extreme conditions, moving from mathematical proof to empirical verification.

Summary updated

Abstract

There are three goals of this thesis. First: to present a concise yet accessible description of basic mathematical logic and model theory. Second: to develop an axiomatization of special relativity using only two undefined predicates. Ideally, these axioms should be empirically verifiable and supported by a large body of evidence. Finally: to weaken this axiomatization so as to allow for the existence of faster-than-light observers, which are normally excluded from the theory of special relativity. The modifications to the axiom system should be as slight as possible, and should be motivated by the question: what features of the original axiom system preclude the existence of faster-than-light observers?
BibTeX
@misc{hoffman2013logical,
  author = {Benjamin Hoffman},
  title = {{A logical treatment of special relativity, with and without faster-than-light observers}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1306.6004},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1306.6004},
}
Figure