A literature analysis on 14 cases of allergic shock caused by safflower injection

Zhen‐Gao Sun, Lian Feng, Jun Zhang, Jun Sun, Yongli Guo, Y ZhangAfrican 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper analyzes 14 reported cases of allergic shock from safflower injection, a common traditional Chinese medicine. The findings highlight that older individuals and females are more susceptible, and reactions typically occur rapidly after administration. The study emphasizes the need for increased clinical vigilance to ensure safer use of this widely applied medication.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Safflower injection is a widely used traditional Chinese medicine derived from the safflower plant, primarily for its properties in promoting blood circulation and removing blood stasis. While effective for various conditions, including cardiovascular and gynecological issues, its use has been associated with adverse reactions, with allergic shock being the most severe. The problem this paper addresses is the need for a clearer understanding of the characteristics and risk factors associated with safflower injection-induced allergic shock, to inform clinical practice and improve patient safety. Despite its common use, comprehensive analyses of its adverse events, particularly severe ones like allergic shock, are limited, creating a knowledge gap for healthcare professionals.

Methods

The researchers conducted a literature analysis, specifically a bibliometric study, of domestic medical journals. They searched the CNKI (Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure) database using keywords "safflower injection" and "allergic shock." To ensure the analysis was based on distinct cases, they rejected repeated reports and excluded literature reviews. Ultimately, they identified and analyzed 14 conforming literature reports detailing individual cases of allergic shock. The data extracted and summarized included patient demographics (gender, age), primary diseases, past allergic history, timing of allergic shock onset, usage and dosage of safflower injection, drug combinations, clinical manifestations, and prognosis.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset compiled from 14 published case reports of allergic shock caused by safflower injection, retrieved from the CNKI database. No new datasets were created or introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Age and Gender Predisposition: The study strongly suggests that individuals over 40 years old are at a higher risk of experiencing allergic shock from safflower injection. Furthermore, females appear to be more susceptible than males.
  • Rapid Onset of Reactions: A significant proportion of allergic shock cases occur very quickly after administration, with most reactions happening within 10 minutes, and a substantial number within 30 minutes. This rapid onset necessitates immediate monitoring and intervention.
  • Underreporting of Allergic History: A notable portion of cases had unclear past allergic histories, suggesting either a lack of thorough patient history taking or issues with the reporting of adverse drug reactions (ADRs).
  • Varied Primary Diseases: While safflower injection is used for a range of conditions, the analysis indicates a higher incidence of allergic shock in patients with heart cerebrovascular diseases.
  • Importance of Dilution: The study notes that some cases deviated from recommended dilution solvents, using normal saline instead of glucose injection, which might be a contributing factor to adverse reactions.

Key Results

  • Out of the 14 cases analyzed, 9 were female (64.29%) and 5 were male (35.71%).
  • The majority of cases occurred in individuals aged 41-60 years (50.00%), followed by those aged 18-40 years (35.71%). No cases were reported in individuals under 18.
  • 57.14% of allergic shocks occurred within 10 minutes of drug administration, and 78.57% occurred within 30 minutes.
  • 6 out of 14 cases had no reported allergic history, while only 2 had a known allergic history (to salvia miltiorrhizae injection or penicillin).
  • No patient died after emergency treatment, with most recovering within 30 minutes to 2 hours, and some within a day.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study is based on a limited number of cases (14) and relies on published literature, which may have reporting biases. The data collection was limited, necessitating further observation and verification in clinical settings. The paper suggests that clinical care personnel should pay more attention to the potential for allergic shock with safflower injection, implying a need for enhanced vigilance and potentially improved diagnostic or risk assessment tools. Future work could involve larger, prospective studies to confirm these findings and explore the underlying mechanisms of safflower injection-induced allergic shock.

Summary updated

Abstract

The objective of this paper was to investigate the characteristics and general rules of domestic safflower injection causing allergic shock, to retrieve the medical journals published domestically, and to make statistical analysis on the cases of allergic shock caused by safflower injection. Results showed that the incidence of allergic shock caused by safflower injection in patients above 40 years old was high: females were more than males. It occurred within 30 min after medication, and no patient died after emergency treatment. The study concluded that allergic shock caused by safflower injection is related to many factors, and clinical care personnel should pay more attention to it.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2013literature,
  author = {Zhen‐Gao Sun and Lian Feng and Jun Zhang and Jun Sun and Yongli Guo and Y Zhang},
  title = {{A literature analysis on 14 cases of allergic shock caused by safflower injection}},
  booktitle = {African},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.4314/ajtcam.v10i6.31},
}
Figure