Abstract: After years of taking a trial-and-error approach to managing a moderate-size academic research group, I settled on using a set of online tools and protocols that seem effective, require relatively little effort to use and maintain, and are inexpensive. This paper discusses this approach to communication, project management, document and code management, and logistics. It is my hope that other researchers, especially new faculty and research scientists, might find this set of tools and protocols useful when determining how to manage their own research group. This paper is targeted toward research groups based in mathematics and engineering, although faculty in other disciplines may find inspiration in some of these ideas.
Introduction
Most PhD and postdoctoral programs are designed to produce excellent researchers, but they rarely provide formal training in management. When a researcher transitions into a faculty role, they are suddenly tasked with coordinating multiple projects, tracking the progress of a dozen students, managing shared hardware, and ensuring that institutional knowledge—such as code and paper drafts—does not vanish when a student graduates.
Traditional project management software is often too "heavy" for the fluid, creative nature of academic research. Conversely, relying solely on email and ad-hoc folder structures leads to "information silos," where the Principal Investigator (PI) lacks a clear bird’s-eye view of the lab's status. This paper presents a "Goldilocks" solution: a curated stack of online tools and social protocols that are lightweight enough for busy students to adopt, yet robust enough to maintain organizational continuity.
The Management Stack
The core of this approach is a specific combination of Software as a Service (SaaS) tools, chosen to minimize the "maintenance tax" on the PI’s time while maximizing visibility across the group.
1. Communication: Slack
To eliminate the clutter of email threads, all research-related discussions are moved to Slack. By using project-specific channels, discussions remain searchable and organized by topic. This ensures that the PI can jump into a specific project context without sifting through unrelated administrative messages.
2. Visual Dashboard: Trello
Trello serves as the lab’s central nervous system. The author utilizes four distinct types of boards:
- Overview Board: A high-level view of every project in the lab, color-coded by status (e.g., green for submitted, red for rejected/under revision, blue for new ideas).
- Project-Specific Boards: Detailed to-do lists and milestones for individual research efforts.
- Resources Board: A simple checkout system for shared computational servers or hardware.
- Contacts Board: A directory for group members and collaborators.
3. Code and Document Vault: GitHub
All code and LaTeX source files are centralized within a single GitHub Organization. This ensures version control and prevents data loss. By keeping everything in one organization, the PI retains ownership and access to all research outputs, even after students depart.
4. Collaborative Writing: Overleaf
Overleaf is used for real-time collaborative paper writing. Crucially, the author recommends linking Overleaf projects to GitHub repositories. This provides a "master" backup of the source files and allows for more complex versioning when necessary.
Social Protocols and Policies
Tools alone cannot manage a group; they must be supported by clear social protocols. The author utilizes three internal policy documents to define expectations:
- Core Hours: Defining core working hours (e.g., 10 AM – 4 PM) ensures that team members are available for spontaneous collaboration.
- The 4-Point Slack Update: Before every 1-on-1 meeting, students are required to post a brief summary to Slack covering: (1) recent goals, (2) actual accomplishments, (3) the meeting agenda, and (4) planned next steps. This serves as a running log of the student's progress and makes face-to-face time significantly more productive.
- Standardized Best Practices: A "Best Practices for Writing" document enforces specific LaTeX macros and BibTeX conventions. This standardization ensures that a paper started by one student can be easily updated or extended by another years later.
Key Insights
- Visibility Prevents Duplication: Public Trello boards allow junior members to see senior members' workflows, fostering collaboration and preventing redundant efforts.
- Avoid "Local" Solutions: The author explicitly warns against locally hosted wikis or SVN servers. The administrative overhead of maintaining local infrastructure is a significant drain on a PI’s time compared to modern SaaS tools.
- Scalability: While designed for a 10–15 person lab, this system has successfully scaled to manage 25-person project-driven robotics courses.
Limitations and Future Work
Despite its successes, the system has areas for improvement. Trello currently lacks an automated local backup feature, requiring manual exports. Reference management remains a challenge; while the lab currently shares URLs on Slack and maintains a shared BibTeX file on GitHub, a more integrated, cost-effective solution for large groups is still desired. Finally, the "sign-up hurdle"—where new members must create accounts for multiple services—remains a minor friction point during onboarding.
Conclusion
By adopting a standardized stack of Slack, Trello, GitHub, and Overleaf, research groups can significantly reduce administrative overhead. This lightweight approach ensures that the PI and students can focus on their primary goal: conducting high-quality research.
Summary updated