A Lean Scheduling Framework for Underground Mines Based on Short Interval Control

Hao Wang, Xiaoxia Zhang, Hui Yuan, Zhiguang Wu, Ming ZhouSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a "lean scheduling framework" for underground mines that leverages "short interval control" to achieve near real-time production monitoring and adjustments. By integrating digital twin technology with intelligent scheduling modules, the framework aims to significantly improve mine productivity, transparency, and decision-making in the era of intelligent mining.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The mining industry is rapidly moving towards "intelligent mining," which goes beyond mere automation to encompass intelligent management and decision-making. However, underground mine scheduling faces significant challenges: communication breakdowns, management inefficiencies, and equipment malfunctions can lead to delays and negative impacts on production. Traditional scheduling methods often lack rapid feedback mechanisms, making it difficult to address unforeseen issues promptly. This paper addresses the need for a more agile and responsive scheduling system that can minimize "time wastes" (unplanned delays or interruptions) and enhance overall production efficiency in underground mines.

Methods

The core of this paper is the proposed "lean scheduling framework" built upon the concept of "short interval control." This framework aims to:

  • Shorten the production monitoring and adjustment cycle: Instead of traditional shift-based management, the framework divides operations into shorter intervals, allowing for more frequent progress tracking and immediate corrective actions.
  • Integrate "lean production" principles: The framework explicitly addresses the "seven wastes" (TIMWOOD: Transportation, Inventory, Motion, Waiting, Overproduction, Overprocessing, Defects) common in industrial processes and applies them to mining to minimize inefficiencies.
  • Implement an intelligent scheduling platform: This platform is built using a digital twin framework, incorporating:
  • Intelligent Scheduling Management and Decision-making Module: For control center personnel, handling data collection, optimization, and instruction issuance.
  • Intelligent Scheduling Mobile Terminal Module: For front-line operators and equipment, enabling instruction reception and progress reporting.
  • Integrated Scheduling Control Cockpit Module: A visualization tool for real-time monitoring and analysis.
  • Develop a Decision Support Algorithm Library: This library includes various algorithms for tasks like trackless equipment scheduling, truck-loader matching, path planning, man-machine efficacy evaluation, and hazardous risk prediction. These algorithms leverage machine learning and big data analysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the framework and platform development, with the application described as a case study within a mine, implying real-world operational data was used for demonstration rather than formal dataset training or benchmarking.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Short Interval Control as a Lean Tool: The paper effectively bridges the gap between lean manufacturing principles and underground mining by adapting short interval control as a practical mechanism to identify and eliminate "time wastes."
  • Digital Twin for Enhanced Visibility: The integration of digital twin technology is crucial for creating a virtual replica of the mine, enabling real-time monitoring, data fusion, and a high degree of restoration from the physical to the virtual space, and vice-versa for control.
  • Holistic Framework: The proposed framework is not just about software; it emphasizes the integration of management concepts, hardware architecture, and intelligent algorithms for a comprehensive solution.
  • Addressing the "Human Factor": The "man-machine efficacy algorithm" highlights the importance of evaluating the combined impact of personnel, equipment, and environment on operational efficiency and safety.

Key Results

The paper presents a conceptual framework and a developed platform, demonstrating its effectiveness through a case study. The results indicate that the platform:

  • Enhances Information Transparency: Allows for quick and visual identification of production bottlenecks.
  • Enables Flexible Scheduling: Shortens scheduling cycles and allows for rapid adjustments.
  • Promotes Lean Production: By minimizing idleness and conflicts through better resource allocation.
  • Supports Scientific Decision-Making: Through optimization algorithms and real-time data analysis.
  • Improves Overall Productivity: By minimizing schedule deviations and responding swiftly to events.

While quantitative results are not explicitly detailed with specific metrics (e.g., percentage improvement in efficiency), the qualitative benefits are clearly articulated.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Decision Support Algorithm Library: The current algorithms are considered insufficient for fully intelligent decision-making and require expansion, particularly in areas like image recognition, intelligent warning, and safety management.
  • Resistance to Change: Implementing short interval control requires significant adjustments to existing scheduling modes, and the paper does not propose specific methods for managing this transition or reducing resistance.
  • Short Application Period: The platform was applied for a limited time, making it challenging to conduct a comprehensive quantitative analysis of its technical and economic impact.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Continuously expanding the decision support algorithm library.
  • Developing transition methods for implementing short interval control reform in more mines.
  • Conducting longer-term follow-up practices to quantitatively analyze the revenue value of production scheduling.

Summary updated

Abstract

Production scheduling management is crucial for optimizing mine productivity. With the trend towards intelligent mines, a lean scheduling management mode is required to align with intelligent conditions. This paper proposes a lean scheduling framework, based on short interval control as an effective tool to adapt intelligent scheduling in underground mines. The framework shortens the production monitoring and adjustment cycle to near-real-time, enabling timely corrective measures to minimize schedule deviations and improve overall production efficiency. An intelligent scheduling platform is implemented by adopting the digital twin platform framework, the intelligent scheduling mobile terminal module, and the integrated scheduling control cockpit module. The results indicate that the platform is effective in promoting mine intelligence by providing benefits in information transparency, flexible scheduling, lean production, and scientific decision-making. The proposed framework provides a practical solution for implementing intelligent scheduling in underground mines, contributing to the overall improvement of mine productivity. Overall, this paper provides insights for implementing intelligent scheduling in underground mines.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023lean,
  author = {Hao Wang and Xiaoxia Zhang and Hui Yuan and Zhiguang Wu and Ming Zhou},
  title = {{A Lean Scheduling Framework for Underground Mines Based on Short Interval Control}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15129195},
}
Figure