A KRR-UKF robust state estimation method for distribution networks

Wěi Zhāng, Shaomei Zhang, Yongchen Zhang, Guang Xu, Huizong MaoFrontiers in Energy Research 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a robust state estimation method for power distribution networks that combines Kernel Ridge Regression (KRR) with an Unscented Kalman Filter (UKF). By integrating a deep learning-based data recovery system (ATT-CNN-GRU) and the OPTICS clustering algorithm, the method maintains high accuracy even in the face of non-Gaussian noise, missing data, and sudden network reconfigurations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

State estimation (SE) is the "brain" of a power system's Energy Management System. It takes raw, often noisy sensor data and calculates the most likely state of the grid (voltages and phase angles). While SE is well-established for high-voltage transmission lines, distribution networks are a different beast. They suffer from low data redundancy, complex non-linearities, and "messy" noise that doesn't follow a neat Gaussian (bell curve) distribution.

Traditional methods like the standard Kalman Filter often fail when the grid's physical model is slightly off or when sensors provide "bad data" due to communication errors. The challenge is creating a system that is both mathematically rigorous enough to handle grid physics and flexible enough to learn from historical data patterns.

Methods

The authors propose a multi-layered architecture to tackle these challenges:

  1. KRR-UKF (The Core Estimator): Instead of relying solely on a complex, hard-to-model grid physics equation, the team used Kernel Ridge Regression. KRR uses the "kernel trick" to map non-linear grid data into a high-dimensional linear space, making it easier to filter out noise. This is then plugged into an Unscented Kalman Filter, which provides a recursive "prediction-correction" loop to refine the state estimates.
  2. ATT-CNN-GRU (The Data Recovery Unit): When sensors fail or report impossible values, the system needs "pseudo-measurements" to fill the gaps. The authors built a hybrid deep learning model:
  3. Attention (ATT): Weights historical data by relevance.
  4. CNN: Extracts spatial features from the grid.
  5. GRU: Captures the time-series patterns of power usage.
  6. OPTICS (The Gatekeeper): To decide when to use the deep learning model, they employed the Ordering Points to Identify the Clustering Structure (OPTICS) algorithm. This identifies outliers (bad data) by looking at how data points cluster together, allowing the system to swap out erroneous sensor readings for predicted ones before they ruin the state estimate.

Datasets

The method was validated using two primary datasets:

  • IEEE 33-bus system: A standard industry benchmark for testing distribution network algorithms.
  • 109-bus system: Real-world operational data from a city in China (August 2020 and 2021), providing a practical "stress test" for the algorithm.
  • Belgian Grid Data (2020-2021): Used specifically to generate realistic load profiles for the simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Data over Models: One of the most significant "aha" moments is that a non-parametric model (KRR) can outperform a rigid physical model in distribution networks because it "learns" the specific noise characteristics and correlations of that specific grid.
  • Parallelism for Speed: Despite the complexity of combining kernels, filters, and deep learning, the authors implemented a parallel computing approach. This kept the execution time in the millisecond range, making it viable for real-time utility operations.
  • Resilience to Change: Most SE methods break when the grid topology changes (e.g., a switch is flipped to reroute power). By simply expanding the KRR training set to include different configurations, this method remained accurate without needing a manual model redesign.

Key Results

The KRR-UKF method consistently outperformed standard Unscented Kalman Filters (UKF) and Gaussian Process-based State Estimation (GP-FSE):

  • Accuracy: In the 109-bus real-world test, the KRR-UKF achieved a Root Mean Squared Error (RMSE) of $3.18 \times 10^{-4}$, significantly better than the standard UKF's $5.41 \times 10^{-2}$.
  • Robustness: When 20-30% of the data was missing or intentionally corrupted with "gross errors," the ATT-CNN-GRU recovery system allowed the filter to maintain an RMSE of roughly $3.4 \times 10^{-5}$, whereas traditional methods saw errors spike.
  • Efficiency: Even with the added deep learning layers, the execution time was approximately 0.29 seconds, well within the requirements for real-time grid monitoring.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors identify two main areas for improvement:

  1. Three-Phase Unbalance: The current model assumes a balanced system. In many real-world distribution networks, the load on the three phases is unequal, which could degrade the performance of this specific KRR implementation.
  2. Data Hunger: The method requires a "considerable volume" of historical operational data to train the KRR and deep learning modules. For new grids or areas with poor record-keeping, this could be a barrier to entry.

Future research will likely focus on adapting this framework for unbalanced three-phase systems and reducing the amount of training data required through transfer learning.

Summary updated

Abstract

State estimation is an integral component of energy management systems. Employing a state estimation methodology that is both accurate and resilient is essential for facilitating informed decision-making processes. However, the complex scenarios (unknown noise, low data redundancy, and reconfiguration) of the distribution network pose new challenges for state estimation. In the context of this study, we introduce a state estimation technique known as the kernel ridge regression and unscented Kalman filter. In normal conditions, the non-linear correlation among data and unknown noise increases the difficulty of modeling the distribution network. Thence, kernel ridge regression is developed to map the data into high-dimensional space that transforms the non-linear problem into linear formulations base on the data rather the complicate grid model, which improves model generalization performance and filters out unknown noises. In addition, with the unique prediction correction mechanism of the Kalman method, the kernel ridge regression-mapped state value can be revised by the measurement, which further enhances model accuracy and robustness. During abnormal operating conditions and taking into account the presence of faulty data within the measurement system, we initiate the use of a long short-term memory network and combined convolutional neural network (CNN) model, referred to as the ATT-CNN-GRU. This model is utilized for the prediction of pseudo-measurements. Subsequently, we use an outlier detection method known as ordering points to identify the clustering structure to effectively identify and substitute erroneous data points. Cases on the IEEE-33 bus system and 109-bus system from a city in China show that the method has superior accuracy and robustness.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023krr,
  author = {Wěi Zhāng and Shaomei Zhang and Yongchen Zhang and Guang Xu and Huizong Mao},
  title = {{A KRR-UKF robust state estimation method for distribution networks}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2023.1295070},
}
Figure