A joint time-frequency analysis of resting-state functional connectivity reveals novel patterns of connectivity shared between or unique to schizophrenia patients and healthy controls

Maziar Yaesoubi, Robyn L. Miller, Juan Bustillo, Kelvin O. Lim, Jatin G. Vaidya, Vince D. CalhounNeuroImage 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method to analyze brain connectivity by simultaneously considering both time and frequency, revealing unique patterns in schizophrenia patients compared to healthy controls. This "spectro-temporal" approach uncovers subtle differences in how brain networks communicate that are missed by traditional methods, offering new insights into the neurobiological underpinnings of schizophrenia.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how different brain regions communicate is crucial for studying neurological and psychiatric disorders. Resting-state functional connectivity (rs-fMRI) is a popular tool for this, but it often treats connectivity as either static over time or averaged across all frequencies. However, research suggests that brain connectivity is both dynamic (changing over time) and frequency-specific (different frequencies of brain activity might reflect different processes). Traditional methods struggle to capture these intertwined dynamics. Schizophrenia, a complex disorder characterized by thought and cognitive disturbances, is widely believed to involve "dysconnectivity." This paper aims to address the gap in understanding schizophrenia's connectivity by developing and applying a method that can simultaneously analyze connectivity across both time and frequency, hypothesizing that this combined approach will reveal more nuanced differences between patients and healthy individuals than methods that analyze these aspects separately.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper lies in its joint time-frequency analysis of resting-state functional connectivity.

  1. Network Identification: They first used group spatial independent component analysis (gsICA) to identify functionally meaningful brain networks from the fMRI data. This is a standard data-driven approach for segmenting brain activity into distinct networks.
  2. Time-Frequency Decomposition: For each identified network's time-course, they applied a wavelet decomposition using complex Morlet wavelets. This process breaks down the signal into its constituent frequencies over time, creating a time-frequency representation for each network.
  3. Wavelet Transform Coherence (WTC): To measure the dependence between pairs of these time-frequency representations, they employed WTC. WTC provides a complex-valued measure where the magnitude indicates the strength of connectivity at a specific time and frequency, and the phase indicates the temporal lag (or lead) at which maximum correlation occurs. This is a key novel aspect, as it captures "dynamic coherence" in the spectro-temporal domain.
  4. State Estimation: The WTC measures for all pairs of networks, across all time points and frequencies, were then concatenated. This high-dimensional data was clustered using k-means clustering (with k=5) to identify distinct "spectro-temporal connectivity states." These states represent recurring patterns of connectivity across time and frequency.
  5. Group Comparison: They then compared these states between healthy controls (HC) and schizophrenia patients (SZ) by analyzing:
  6. Group-specific states: Identifying states unique to each group.
  7. Shared states: Identifying states common to both groups.
  8. Amplitude and Phase Differences: Comparing the magnitude and phase of dynamic coherence within shared states.
  9. Occupancy Rates and Dwell Times: Analyzing how often subjects entered and stayed in specific states.

Datasets

The study utilized resting-state fMRI data from:

  • 163 healthy controls (46 females, average age 36.9)
  • 151 patients diagnosed with schizophrenia (37 females, average age 37.8)

The data was collected in accordance with the internal review boards of the corresponding institutes, and informed consent was obtained from all participants. Details on image acquisition and pre-processing are provided in the supplementary material.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Connectivity is Spectro-Temporal: The most significant idea is that brain connectivity isn't just dynamic or frequency-specific; it's intrinsically spectro-temporal. Analyzing these dimensions jointly reveals patterns that are obscured when treated separately.
  • Schizophrenia's Unique Connectivity Signatures: The spectro-temporal domain allows for the identification of connectivity patterns that are not only different between schizophrenia patients and healthy controls but are also unique to this combined analysis.
  • Lagged Dependencies Matter: The phase information from WTC is crucial for identifying "lagged dependence," meaning how signals from different brain regions are temporally offset. This aspect of connectivity appears to be differentially expressed in schizophrenia.
  • Dynamic States Reveal Group Differences: By clustering connectivity patterns into distinct states, the researchers found that schizophrenia patients and healthy controls not only occupy these states differently (occupancy rates) but also tend to stay in them for different durations (dwell times).

Key Results

  • Novel Connectivity Patterns: The study identified spectrally localized (mostly mid-range frequencies) modular dynamic connectivity patterns in schizophrenia where sensory-motor networks were anti-correlated with visual, auditory, and sub-cortical networks. They also found evidence of lagged dependence between default-mode and sensory networks in schizophrenia. These findings are unique to the spectro-temporal domain.
  • Shared and Unique States: They identified connectivity states that were shared between groups and states that were unique to each. For example, the most commonly occurring state (state 1) was shared and had a high-frequency profile. However, differences emerged in states with mid-range frequency profiles.
  • Amplitude and Phase Differences: Comparisons of maximally correlated states revealed significant differences in both the amplitude (strength) and phase (lag) of dynamic coherence between network pairs in schizophrenia patients and healthy controls.
  • Differential State Occupancy: Schizophrenia patients showed a greater tendency to occupy state 1 (low global coherence, higher frequency profile) and state 2 (negative DMN-to-other coherence, high global coherence, lower frequency profile). Healthy controls tended to occupy state 3 (high coherence between sensory networks) and state 5 (highly modularized coherence structure).
  • Overall Weaker Connectivity in SZ: Across states, healthy controls generally exhibited stronger overall connectivity compared to schizophrenia patients, as evidenced by amplitude distributions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of Dynamic Coherence: The authors acknowledge that dynamic coherence, as used in this study, cannot measure dependence across frequencies (i.e., cross-frequency connectivity).
  • Clustering Method: While k-means clustering was effective, they suggest that other summarization approaches with different underlying assumptions could potentially complement the identified states.
  • Future Directions:
    • Investigating cross-frequency connectivity using similar frameworks, potentially leveraging phase information from dynamic coherence.
  • Exploring alternative clustering methods to further refine the summarization of dynamic coherence estimations.
  • The authors suggest that their findings provide a foundation for further research into the spectro-temporal dynamics of brain connectivity in psychiatric disorders.

Summary updated

Abstract

Functional connectivity of the resting-state (RS) brain is a vehicle to study brain dysconnectivity aspects of diseases such as schizophrenia and bipolar. Methods that are developed to measure functional connectivity are based on the underlying hypotheses regarding the actual nature of RS-connectivity including evidence of temporally dynamic versus static RS-connectivity and evidence of frequency-specific versus hemodynamically-driven connectivity over a wide frequency range. This study is derived by these observations of variation of RS-connectivity in temporal and frequency domains and evaluates such characteristics of RS-connectivity in clinical population and jointly in temporal and frequency domains (the <i>spectro-temporal domain</i>). We base this study on the hypothesis that by studying functional connectivity of schizophrenia patients and comparing it to the one of healthy controls in the spectro-temporal domain we might be able to make new observations regarding the differences and similarities between diseased and healthy brain connectivity and such observations could be obscured by studies which investigate such characteristics separately. Interestingly, our results include, but are not limited to, a spectrally localized (mostly mid-range frequencies) modular dynamic connectivity pattern in which sensory motor networks are anti-correlated with visual, auditory and sub-cortical networks in schizophrenia, as well as evidence of lagged dependence between default-mode and sensory networks in schizophrenia. These observations are unique to the proposed augmented domain of connectivity analysis. We conclude this study by arguing not only resting-state connectivity has structured spectro-temporal variability, but also that studying properties of connectivity in this joint domain reveals distinctive group-based differences and similarities between clinical and healthy populations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yaesoubi2017joint,
  author = {Maziar Yaesoubi and Robyn L. Miller and Juan Bustillo and Kelvin O. Lim and Jatin G. Vaidya and Vince D. Calhoun},
  title = {{A joint time-frequency analysis of resting-state functional connectivity reveals novel patterns of connectivity shared between or unique to schizophrenia patients and healthy controls}},
  booktitle = {NeuroImage},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1016/j.nicl.2017.06.023},
}
Figure