A Hybrid VLC-RF Portable Phasor Measurement Unit for Deep Tunnels

Ismael Soto, Rafael Nilson Rodrigues, G. A. Massuyama, Fabián Seguel, Pablo Palacios Játiva, César A. Azurdia-Meza, Nicolas KrommenackerSensors 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel hybrid Visible Light Communication (VLC) and Radio Frequency (RF) system for portable Phasor Measurement Units (PMUs) designed for deep underground tunnels. It addresses the critical challenge of GPS denial in these environments by using VLC for precise time and location synchronization, and an RF uplink for transmitting power system data, offering a more robust and cost-effective solution than existing commercial PMUs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Electrical power systems in deep underground environments, such as mines, present unique challenges for monitoring and control. Phasor Measurement Units (PMUs) are essential for assessing the dynamic performance of power grids, but they traditionally rely on Global Positioning System (GPS) for accurate time synchronization and location data. However, GPS signals cannot penetrate deep underground, rendering standard PMUs ineffective in these "GPS-denied" environments. This lack of reliable data hinders the ability to monitor power quality, detect faults, and ensure the efficient and safe operation of mining machinery and infrastructure. The paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a hybrid system that leverages the strengths of VLC and RF technologies to provide PMUs with the necessary time and location information in these challenging settings.

Methods

The proposed solution is a hybrid VLC-RF system. For downlink communication, Visible Light Communication (VLC) is employed. This involves using Light-Emitting Diodes (LEDs) to transmit data, including Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) and precise positioning information, to the PMUs. VLC is chosen for its ability to provide high accuracy positioning and its potential for low-cost implementation by utilizing existing lighting infrastructure. The PMUs then use this information to synchronize their measurements.

For uplink communication, a Radio Frequency (RF) link is used. Once the PMU acquires electrical power system measurements, along with its synchronized time stamp and estimated position, this data is transmitted to a central monitoring station via an RF uplink. The paper specifically focuses on using the Ultra High Frequency (UHF) band for this RF communication, as it offers a good balance of coverage and attenuation characteristics in underground tunnels.

Several positioning algorithms are evaluated for the VLC system:

  • Cell of Origin (COO): A simple method that estimates the PMU's location as the centroid of the VLC cell it's connected to.
  • Convex Position Estimation (CPE): An algorithm that uses connectivity information to define a minimum bounding rectangle for the PMU's location.
  • Centroid: This method treats VLC nodes as point masses and calculates the PMU's position based on the weighted average of connected anchor nodes.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention or introduce new datasets for training. Instead, it relies on laboratory-scale experimental measurements and computer simulations to validate the proposed system's performance. The experimental measurements were conducted at the Federal Institute of Santa Catarina (IFSC) in Brazil, and at the University of Santiago de Chile (USACH) campuses in Santiago and Iquique, as well as at the Universidad Tecnológica Metropolitana (UTEM) in Santiago. These real-world measurements serve as the primary basis for evaluating the system's effectiveness.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • VLC as a GPS Alternative: The core insight is the successful application of VLC for providing precise time and location data to PMUs in GPS-denied underground environments. This overcomes a significant hurdle in deploying advanced power system monitoring in such locations.
  • Hybrid System Synergy: The combination of VLC for precise downlink synchronization and RF for robust uplink data transmission creates a synergistic system that leverages the strengths of both technologies. VLC excels at localized, high-accuracy positioning, while RF provides the necessary range for data transmission out of the tunnel.
  • Centroid Algorithm's Practicality: For low-density VLC networks, the Centroid algorithm emerges as a preferred positioning method due to its favorable balance of computational complexity and accuracy, making it suitable for resource-constrained PMU devices.
  • Feasibility in Real-World Scenarios: The experimental validation in both Brazil and Chile, and comparisons with commercial PMUs, demonstrate the practical feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed hybrid VLC-RF PMU system.

Key Results

  • Accurate Time and Position: The system successfully delivers UTC time stamps and accurate positioning information to PMUs within the tunnel, enabling synchronized measurements.
  • High-Accuracy Frequency Estimation: The PMU prototype demonstrated accurate frequency estimation, with errors less than 0.02 Hz for steady-state signals and less than 0.030% for frequency ramps.
  • Comparable Performance to Commercial PMUs: Experimental comparisons showed that the proposed PMU prototype's frequency measurements were very similar to those of commercial PMUs, with frequency differences typically below 0.01 Hz.
  • Effective Positioning Methods: The Centroid algorithm showed promising results, outperforming COO in accuracy and CPE in computational complexity for low-density VLC scenarios.
  • UHF RF Uplink Performance: The UHF RF uplink demonstrated sufficient coverage for transmitting data from PMUs within the tunnel to a central monitoring station.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low LED Infrastructure Density: The paper acknowledges that the proposed methods are particularly suited for scenarios with low LED infrastructure density. In environments with higher density, other positioning algorithms might be considered.
  • Tunnel Complexity: While the study was conducted in laboratory settings and real tunnels, the authors suggest that further studies might be needed to address more complex tunnel geometries and environmental factors.
  • Scalability: The paper mentions that the communication protocol, with its current protection levels, might limit the number of PMUs to around 750. For larger deployments, studies with higher altitude and faster satellites for the VSAT link might be necessary.
  • Mobile PMUs: The current protocol is designed for static or semi-static PMUs. For truly mobile PMUs, the communication protocol might require additional headers and parity checks for enhanced data protection.
  • Future work could involve optimizing the RF communication for higher data rates and exploring more advanced VLC positioning algorithms for denser deployments. Further investigation into the long-term reliability and maintenance of such systems in harsh underground environments would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this manuscript we propose a hybrid Visible Light Communication and Radio Frequency (VLC-RF) scheme for the implementation of a portable Phaser Measurement Unit (PMU) for deep underground tunnels. Through computer simulations and laboratory measurements we are capable of providing Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) to the PMUs, as well as high accuracy positioning in a Global Positioning System (GPS) denied environment. The estimated PMU position, time stamp, and electrical power system measurements are sent to a central monitoring station using a radio frequency uplink with a data rate of hundreds of Kbps. Simulations and experimental measurements show that the proposed scheme can be used to control a large number of VLC-RF PMU devices inside a tunnel. The tests demonstrate the viability of the hybrid prototype, which will improve performance compared to commercial PMUs that lack these features.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{soto2020hybrid,
  author = {Ismael Soto and Rafael Nilson Rodrigues and G. A. Massuyama and Fabián Seguel and Pablo Palacios Játiva and César A. Azurdia-Meza and Nicolas Krommenacker},
  title = {{A Hybrid VLC-RF Portable Phasor Measurement Unit for Deep Tunnels}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20030790},
}

Loading related content...

Figure