TL;DR
This paper tackles the problem of unwanted second harmonic current (SHC) in two-stage DC-AC converters, a common issue in applications like aircraft power systems. The authors propose a novel "hybrid" control strategy that combines a notch filter and a virtual impedance to effectively suppress SHC while maintaining fast dynamic response, outperforming existing methods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Single-phase AC power systems inherently have a pulsating output power at twice the fundamental frequency. In a two-stage DC-AC converter system (where a DC-DC converter feeds a DC-AC inverter), this pulsating power creates a "second harmonic current" (SHC) that flows back into the front-end DC-DC converter. This SHC can lead to increased stress on components, reduced efficiency, and ripple in the intermediate DC bus voltage. While methods exist to mitigate SHC in PWM-controlled converters, frequency-modulated LLC resonant converters, which are favored for their high efficiency and soft-switching capabilities, lack specific solutions due to the complexities of frequency modulation. Existing approaches for LLC converters often involve bulky passive components, complex active filters, or lead to trade-offs in dynamic performance. This paper aims to provide an effective and efficient SHC mitigation strategy specifically for frequency-modulated LLC converters in two-stage single-phase inverter applications.
Methods
The core of the proposed solution is a hybrid SHC mitigation strategy that combines two techniques:
- Notch Filter-Based SHC Mitigation Strategy (NFS): A notch filter is integrated into the voltage control loop of the front-end LLC converter. This filter is specifically designed to attenuate the converter's open-loop gain at twice the fundamental frequency (2fN). By doing so, it redirects the SHC to the DC bus capacitor rather than allowing it to flow through the power semiconductors. This approach preserves the converter's loop gain at other frequencies, ensuring good transient response.
- Virtual Impedance-Based SHC Mitigation Strategy (VI): A series virtual impedance is introduced at the output of the rectifier bridge. This virtual impedance is designed to have a high impedance specifically at 2fN, while presenting a low impedance at other frequencies. This selective impedance shaping further increases the converter's output impedance at the problematic frequency, effectively blocking SHC penetration.
The hybrid strategy combines these two methods. By simultaneously reducing the open-loop gain at 2fN (via the notch filter) and increasing the output impedance at 2fN (via the virtual impedance), the strategy significantly amplifies the closed-loop output impedance of the LLC converter at 2fN, leading to optimal SHC suppression. The paper also details the design process for these components, including impedance analysis and controller parameter selection, and addresses stability concerns by introducing a damping resistor in the virtual impedance path.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and experimental validation using a developed prototype.
Key Insights and Ideas
- SHC Propagation Mechanism: The paper clearly explains how SHC propagates through the converter's output impedance and the DC bus capacitor, highlighting the critical role of impedance characteristics at 2fN.
- LLC Converter Specific Challenges: It identifies the unique difficulties in mitigating SHC in frequency-modulated LLC converters compared to PWM converters, emphasizing the need for tailored solutions.
- Synergistic Hybrid Approach: The key insight is that combining a gain-reduction strategy (notch filter) with an impedance-increase strategy (virtual impedance) at the specific SHC frequency (2fN) yields a synergistic effect, achieving superior SHC suppression and dynamic performance.
- Frequency Selectivity is Crucial: The success of both the notch filter and the virtual impedance relies on their precise frequency selectivity, targeting only the problematic 2fN without negatively impacting other operating frequencies.
- Trade-off Management: The paper demonstrates how the hybrid strategy effectively manages the typical trade-off between SHC suppression and dynamic performance degradation seen in other methods.
Key Results
- Significant SHC Reduction: The proposed hybrid strategy reduced the second harmonic current content in the converter's input current to 1.75%.
- Comparison to Other Methods:
- Open-loop: 30% SHC
- Closed-loop (without SHC mitigation): 70% SHC
- Notch Filter (NF) only: 37% SHC
- Virtual Impedance (VI) only: 5.2% SHC
- Robust Dynamic Performance: Experimental results showed minimal overshoot and undershoot during load transients, with rapid settling times, indicating excellent dynamic characteristics.
- Frequency Variation Tolerance: The controller demonstrated robustness against AC frequency variations, with only a slight degradation in mitigation performance (THD increasing from 2.18% to 2.52% at 49.5 Hz).
Limitations and Future Work
- Filter Bandwidth Trade-off: While the notch filter and bandpass filter for virtual impedance offer excellent frequency selectivity, there's a trade-off: increasing filter bandwidth improves frequency adaptation but can slightly reduce peak mitigation performance. The paper mentions this as a point for future consideration.
- Digital Delay and Parasitic Parameters: The slight mismatch between designed and measured SHC levels (e.g., 5.2% vs. 5% target for VI) is attributed to the digital delay of the controller and parasitic parameters of the LLC converter. Further optimization could address these.
- Experimental Prototype: The study was validated on a specific 28V DC to 220V/50Hz AC inverter prototype. Future work could explore the applicability of this strategy to a wider range of power levels and voltage/frequency requirements.
- Component Stress: While SHC is reduced, the paper could further analyze the impact of the proposed strategy on other component stresses (e.g., switching losses) under various operating conditions.
Summary updated