A hybrid 3D/2D field response calculation for liquid argon detectors with PCB based anode plane

S. Martynenko, F. Pietropaolo, B. Viren, X. Qian, H. Chen, S. Gao, W. Gu, J. H. Jo, S. H. Kettell, Ye Li, H. Liu, N. Nayak, B. Yu, H. Yu, C. Zhang, U. Köse, F. Resnati, S. Tufanli, F. Boran, F. DolekJournal of Instrumentation 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "pochoir," a novel software package that efficiently calculates the "field response" for next-generation Liquid Argon Time Projection Chambers (LArTPCs) using PCB-based anodes. By combining precise 3D calculations near electrodes with faster 2D calculations further away, pochoir enables accurate simulations of these detectors, achieving consistency with real data within 5%.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Liquid Argon Time Projection Chambers (LArTPCs) are powerful tools for neutrino detection, offering high spatial precision. A crucial component for simulating and reconstructing events in these detectors is the "field response" (FR) model. This model describes how ionization electrons drifting in an electric field induce currents on anode electrodes. Traditionally, LArTPCs used parallel wire planes, allowing for computationally efficient 2D FR models due to translational symmetry. However, newer designs employ PCB-based anodes with strips and through-holes. These holes break the translational symmetry, making 2D models inaccurate, especially near the electrodes. While full 3D FR calculations are accurate, they are computationally prohibitive for large detector volumes. This paper addresses the need for an accurate and computationally feasible FR model for these new PCB-based anode designs.

Methods

The core of the paper is the introduction of the pochoir software package. It employs a hybrid 3D/2D approach to calculate the field response. The method is based on the Ramo theorem, which relates induced current to charge, velocity, and a "weighting field."

  1. Drift Field Calculation: Solves the Laplace equation for the electric potential in the detector volume.
  2. Weighting Field Calculation: Also solves the Laplace equation, but with boundary conditions specific to the electrode of interest. This is where the novelty lies:
  3. Hybrid 3D/2D Approach: For regions close to the PCB electrodes, a full 3D calculation using the Finite-Difference Method (FDM) is performed to capture the complex fields around the holes and strips.
  4. Far-Field Approximation: For regions further away from the electrodes, where translational symmetry is a better approximation, a computationally cheaper 2D calculation is used. The 3D near-field solution is then embedded into the 2D far-field solution.
  5. Electron Drift and Current Calculation: The drift velocity of electrons is calculated using their mobility and the local electric field. A fourth-order Runge-Kutta algorithm is used to track electron paths, and the induced current is computed using the Ramo theorem.

The FDM is chosen for its simplicity and suitability for parallelization on GPUs, making it feasible for the required grid spacing (0.1 mm) to resolve electrode features.

Datasets

The validation of the pochoir package and its generated FR models was performed using data from the CERN 50-L Vertical Drift (VD) prototype detector. Two types of events were used:

  • $^{39}$Ar Beta Decay Events: These events produce short ionization tracks, acting as near point-like sources. They are used to probe the field response in a localized manner, effectively measuring the FR smeared by drift effects and detector electronics.
  • Cosmic-Ray Muon Tracks: These events produce longer tracks and are used to test the field response's sensitivity to longitudinal and transverse induction effects, as well as variations along the strip.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but utilizes real data from an existing prototype detector.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Breaking Translational Symmetry: The through-holes in PCB anodes fundamentally break the translational symmetry that simplified FR calculations for wire-based detectors. This necessitates a more sophisticated approach.
  • Hybrid 3D/2D Efficiency: The key insight is that while 3D calculations are needed near electrodes, they are computationally expensive for the entire detector. By intelligently combining 3D near-field with 2D far-field solutions, computational cost is significantly reduced without sacrificing accuracy where it matters most.
  • FDM Suitability for PCB Anodes: The regularity of PCB strip designs, despite the holes, makes the FDM a viable and efficient method for 3D field calculations, unlike its prohibitive cost for complex wire geometries.
  • Impact of Hole Size: The study quantifies the small but measurable effect of different hole sizes (2 mm vs. 2.5 mm) on the field response, showing a ~1-3% difference in peak ADC. This highlights the sensitivity of the FR to detector geometry.
  • Longitudinal Variations: The paper investigates variations in the FR along the strip direction due to the hole pattern. While these variations are estimated to be around 7% for reconstructed charge on the induction plane, they are not fully captured by the current 2D averaged model used in the Wire-Cell Toolkit.

Key Results

  • The pochoir package provides a fast and precise hybrid 3D/2D field response calculation.
  • Simulations using the pochoir-generated FR models show consistency with real data from the CERN 50-L prototype detector within 5% in central values.
  • The effect of hole size on the field response was reproduced in simulations, showing a ~3-5% difference for the middle strip.
  • Variations in the field response along the strip orientation due to the hole pattern were estimated to cause up to a ~7% variation in reconstructed charge on the induction plane. While not definitively observed in the current data comparison, this effect is noted as important for future, more advanced reconstruction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • 2D Averaging for Simulation: The current implementation for the Wire-Cell Toolkit simulation uses a 2D FR model obtained by averaging over the strip direction. This averaging might lose some information, leading to potential inaccuracies smaller than the observed ~7% variation.
  • Hole Size Differences: The simulation primarily uses a 2.5 mm hole size model, while the real data contains a mix of 2 mm and 2.5 mm holes. This difference contributes to some discrepancies observed in the data-simulation comparison.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future advancements in reconstruction, particularly those employing deep neural networks, might be able to resolve the subtle position-dependent variations along the strip. Further development of full 3D detector simulation approaches or methods to incorporate these longitudinal variations into the simulation are also suggested, acknowledging the significant computational and software development costs involved.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Liquid Argon Time Projection Chamber (LArTPC) technology is commonly utilized in neutrino detector designs. It enables detailed reconstruction of neutrino events with high spatial precision and low energy threshold. Its field response (FR) model describes the time-dependent electric currents induced in the anode-plane electrodes when ionization electrons drift nearby. An accurate and precise FR is a crucial input to LArTPC detector simulations and charge reconstruction. Established LArTPC designs have been based on parallel wire planes. It allows accurate and computationally economic two-dimensional (2D) FR models utilizing the translational symmetry along the direction of the wires. Recently, novel LArTPC designs utilize electrodes formed on printed circuit board (PCB) in the shape of strips with through holes. The translational symmetry is no longer a good approximation near the electrodes and a new FR calculation that employs regions with three dimensions (3D) has been developed. Extending the 2D models to 3D would be computationally expensive. Fortuitously, the nature of strips with through holes allows for a computationally economic approach based on the finite-difference method (FDM). In this paper, we present a new software package pochoir that calculates LArTPC field response for these new strip-based anode designs. This package combines 3D calculations in the volume near the electrodes with 2D far-field solutions to achieve fast and precise field response computation. We apply the resulting FR to simulate and reconstruct samples of cosmic-ray muons and 39 Ar decays from a Vertical Drift (VD) detector prototype operated at CERN. We find the difference between real and simulated data within 5%. Current state-of-the-art LArTPC software requires a 2D FR which we provide by averaging over one dimension and estimate that variations lost in this average are smaller than 7%.
BibTeX
@article{martynenko2023hybrid,
  author = {S. Martynenko and F. Pietropaolo and B. Viren and X. Qian and H. Chen and S. Gao and W. Gu and J. H. Jo and S. H. Kettell and Ye Li and H. Liu and N. Nayak and B. Yu and H. Yu and C. Zhang and U. Köse and F. Resnati and S. Tufanli and F. Boran and F. Dolek},
  title = {{A hybrid 3D/2D field response calculation for liquid argon detectors with PCB based anode plane}},
  journal = {Journal of Instrumentation},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1088/1748-0221/18/04/p04033},
}
Figure