A human case of Dioctophyma renale (giant kidney worm) accompanied by renal cancer and a retrospective study of dioctophymiasis

Fengkun Yang, Weizhe Zhang, Baiyan Gong, Lan Yao, Aiqin Liu, Hong LingParasite 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a rare human case of Dioctophyma renale (giant kidney worm) co-occurring with renal cancer and provides the first retrospective analysis of human dioctophymiasis. By reviewing 37 documented cases, the study aims to improve the recognition and diagnosis of this often-misunderstood parasitic infection, highlighting its geographical distribution, clinical manifestations, and potential risk factors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dioctophyma renale infection, or dioctophymiasis, is a rare parasitic disease in humans. Its rarity, coupled with nonspecific clinical symptoms that can mimic other conditions like nephritis, makes it easily overlooked or misdiagnosed by clinicians. This diagnostic challenge can lead to delayed or incorrect treatment. The paper addresses this by presenting a unique case of a human infected with the giant kidney worm alongside renal cancer, and then undertaking a comprehensive retrospective study to consolidate existing knowledge on human dioctophymiasis. This effort aims to provide a clearer picture of the disease's epidemiology and clinical presentation, thereby aiding in its better recognition and management.

Methods

The study employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Case Presentation: A detailed report of a specific human case of Dioctophyma renale infection complicated by renal cancer.
  2. Retrospective Study: A systematic literature search was conducted using keywords like "Dioctophyma renale" and "giant kidney worm" in combination with "humans." This search targeted major databases: PubMed (for English-language papers) and three Chinese databases (CNKI, Wanfangdata, and Qikan.cqvip.com) for Chinese-language papers. The search covered all available years up to October 2018. Papers were screened for relevance, and duplicate or non-human cases were excluded. Additional relevant papers were identified by reviewing the reference lists of the selected articles. Key epidemiological and clinical information was extracted from 32 eligible papers, describing a total of 37 human cases of dioctophymiasis, including the presented case.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new datasets. Instead, it synthesized data from existing published literature. The "dataset" for the retrospective analysis comprised 37 documented human cases of dioctophymiasis compiled from 32 peer-reviewed articles found across PubMed and three Chinese databases.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Diagnostic Elusiveness: The nonspecific symptoms of dioctophymiasis mean it's easily missed. Loin pain and hematuria are common but can point to many other renal issues.
  • Geographical Hotspots: While distributed globally, China emerges as a significant hotspot for human cases, potentially linked to local dietary habits and environmental factors.
  • Dietary Link: A substantial proportion of infected individuals (nearly half) had a history of consuming raw or undercooked fish or frogs, strongly suggesting this as a primary transmission route.
  • Kidney Predominance: The vast majority of infections target the kidneys, though ectopic cases in subcutaneous tissue are also documented.
  • Co-occurrence with Cancer: The presented case highlights the potential, though not fully understood, co-occurrence of D. renale infection with renal cancer, raising questions about chronic inflammation and malignancy.
  • First Retrospective Analysis: This study marks the first attempt to systematically review and analyze human cases of dioctophymiasis, providing a foundational dataset for future research and clinical guidance.

Key Results

The retrospective analysis of 37 human cases revealed:

  • Geographical Distribution: Cases were reported in 10 countries, with China accounting for the highest number (22 cases).
  • Demographics: The majority of cases occurred in adults (91.9%), with a mean age of 41.95 years. Males were slightly more affected globally (59.5%) than females.
  • Location of Parasitism: Kidneys were involved in 83.8% of cases. Ectopic cases were predominantly found in subcutaneous tissue (83.3% of ectopic cases).
  • Risk Factors: 45.9% of individuals reported a history of eating raw or undercooked fish or frogs. One case in China was linked to drinking unboiled water.
  • Clinical Manifestations: The most common symptoms were loin pain (59.5%) and hematuria (59.5%).
  • Diagnosis: Diagnosis was consistently made based on the morphological characteristics of eggs or adult worms found in urine or tissue sections.
  • Treatment: No strictly defined therapeutic approach exists. Surgical removal and anti-helminthic drugs like ivermectin and albendazole have shown some success.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Rarity and Reporting Bias: The rarity of the disease means that many cases might go unreported or undiagnosed, potentially skewing the epidemiological data.
  • Data Heterogeneity: The retrospective nature of the study means that the quality and completeness of data varied across the included case reports.
  • Unclear Cancer Link: While a case of co-occurrence with renal cancer is presented, the direct causal relationship or predisposition remains unclear and requires further investigation.

Future Work:

  • Strengthening Public Awareness: Educating the public about the risks associated with consuming raw or undercooked aquatic animals and unboiled water is crucial for prevention.
  • Diagnostic Improvement: Developing more sensitive diagnostic tools beyond morphological identification could aid in earlier detection.
  • Therapeutic Standardization: Further research is needed to establish standardized and effective treatment protocols for human dioctophymiasis.
  • Investigating Cancer Association: More research is warranted to explore any potential link between chronic parasitic infections like dioctophymiasis and the development of renal cell carcinoma.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to the rarity of human cases and the nonspecific clinical symptoms of dioctophymiasis, Dioctophyma renale infection is not well recognized and is easily neglected or misdiagnosed. Recently, we diagnosed a human case of dioctophymiasis accompanied by renal cancer. To enhance the understanding of human dioctophymiasis, this case is presented here, and a retrospective study of this disease was conducted based on relevant papers screened from PubMed and three Chinese databases. In the end, 32 papers describing 37 human cases of dioctophymiasis were assessed. These cases were distributed in ten countries of Asia, Europe, North America and Oceania, with the highest number in China (n = 22). The majority of the cases occurred in adults (91.9%, 34/37) and involved the kidneys (83.8%, 31/37). Ectopic parasitism mainly occurred in subcutaneous tissue (83.3%, 5/6). A proportion of 45.9% (17/37) of individuals had a history of eating raw or undercooked fish or frogs. The main clinical manifestations of human dioctophymiasis were loin pain (59.5%) and hematuria (59.5%). All the cases were diagnosed based on the morphological characteristics of eggs or adults in urine or tissue sections. Currently, there is no strictly defined therapeutic approach. This is the first retrospective analysis of human cases of dioctophymiasis. These review data will deepen our understanding of dioctophymiasis and help avoid misdiagnosis in clinical practice.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2019human,
  author = {Fengkun Yang and Weizhe Zhang and Baiyan Gong and Lan Yao and Aiqin Liu and Hong Ling},
  title = {{A human case of <i>Dioctophyma renale</i> (giant kidney worm) accompanied by renal cancer and a retrospective study of dioctophymiasis}},
  booktitle = {Parasite},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1051/parasite/2019023},
}
Figure