A holistic sustainability framework for remanufacturing under uncertainty

Chunting Liu, Yanyan Yang, Xiufeng LiuJournal of Manufacturing Systems 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for assessing sustainability in remanufacturing operations, specifically designed to handle inherent uncertainties. By integrating economic, environmental, and social factors with a flexible weighting system and employing stochastic optimization, it offers a robust tool for decision-making in complex remanufacturing environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The remanufacturing industry is growing, driven by sustainability goals. However, existing sustainability assessment frameworks often fall short. They tend to focus on single aspects (like carbon emissions) rather than a holistic view, and crucially, they struggle to account for the significant uncertainties present in remanufacturing. These uncertainties arise from the variable quantity and quality of returned products, fluctuating market demand, and unpredictable supply chains. This lack of a comprehensive and adaptable approach hinders effective decision-making for companies aiming to balance economic viability with environmental and social responsibility.

Methods

The core of this paper is a holistic sustainability assessment framework for remanufacturing. Key methodological contributions include:

  • Integration of Three Pillars: The framework explicitly combines economic, environmental, and social sustainability indicators into a single assessment function.
  • Flexible Weighting Scheme: Recognizing that different organizations have different priorities, the framework allows for customizable weights for each sustainability dimension. These weights can be determined through methods like stakeholder surveys or expert opinions.
  • Stochastic Optimization: To tackle the inherent uncertainties in remanufacturing (e.g., in the supply of returned products), the paper employs two-stage stochastic programming with recourse. This allows for "here-and-now" decisions (like initial production levels) and "wait-and-see" decisions (adjustments made after uncertainty is revealed).
  • Mathematical Formulation: The paper provides a detailed mathematical formulation, including objective functions and constraints, to optimize the expected value of the sustainability assessment function.
  • Solution Strategies: Two algorithmic approaches are proposed for solving the optimization problem: Benders Decomposition and Sample Average Approximation (SAA). These offer different trade-offs in terms of computational efficiency and solution characteristics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The case studies utilize industry data, publicly available reports, and expert interviews to derive parameter values.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Uncertainty is a Major Hurdle: The paper strongly emphasizes that ignoring uncertainty in remanufacturing leads to suboptimal and potentially unsustainable decisions.
  • Holistic View is Crucial: A balanced consideration of economic, environmental, and social factors is essential for true sustainability, and the framework provides a way to achieve this.
  • Flexibility is Key: The ability to adjust sustainability indicator weights is vital, as organizational priorities and external pressures change.
  • Trade-offs are Inevitable: The case studies demonstrate that there are often trade-offs between different sustainability objectives, and the framework helps quantify these.
  • Algorithm Choice Matters: The choice between Benders Decomposition and SAA can lead to different strategic recommendations, highlighting the need to consider computational resources and desired risk appetite.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates the framework's utility through three case studies in consumer electronics, automotive, and industrial machinery remanufacturing.

  • Acme Electronics (Consumer Electronics): Under low uncertainty, a balanced approach between new and remanufactured products was favored. As uncertainty increased, the optimal strategy shifted, with Benders Decomposition suggesting a more conservative approach to mitigate risks, while SAA leaned towards a more profit-driven strategy.
  • AutoReman Inc. (Automotive): Similar to Acme, Benders Decomposition showed adaptive strategies based on uncertainty levels, prioritizing economic resilience under high uncertainty. SAA, however, recommended a more risk-averse strategy, potentially prioritizing profit over environmental factors.
  • MachineryRenew Corp. (Industrial Machinery): The case highlighted that SAA could prioritize economic considerations significantly, potentially at the expense of environmental and social goals, especially under high uncertainty.
  • Sensitivity Analysis:
    • Increasing the weight of environmental indicators generally decreased the overall objective value, indicating a trade-off with economic factors.
  • The framework showed relative robustness to changes in the standard deviation of the uncertain parameter (β), but was more sensitive to changes in its mean.
  • Increasing emission limits allowed for higher production levels, demonstrating the framework's adaptability to regulatory changes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumed Probability Distribution: The framework assumes a known probability distribution for the uncertain parameter (β). Future work could explore data-driven uncertainty quantification methods, including machine learning, for more accurate estimations.
  • Single-Period Model: The current model focuses on a single-period decision-making process. Extending it to multi-period planning horizons and dynamic decision-making under evolving uncertainties would provide more comprehensive long-term insights.
  • Multiple Uncertain Parameters: The current analysis primarily focuses on one uncertain parameter. Future research could incorporate multiple uncertain parameters and their correlations for a more realistic representation.
  • Integration with Other Tools: The authors suggest integrating the framework with complementary decision support tools like Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) to further enhance its comprehensiveness.
  • Empirical Validation: More extensive empirical studies and industry collaborations are recommended to further validate the framework's effectiveness and identify areas for refinement.

Summary updated

Abstract

The manufacturing and remanufacturing sectors are increasingly embracing sustainability as a critical aspect of their operations. However, existing sustainability frameworks often fall short of capturing the multifaceted nature of sustainability and addressing uncertainties. To address these limitations, this paper proposes a novel holistic sustainability assessment framework specifically tailored for remanufacturing systems. By integrating economic, environmental, and social dimensions, the framework provides a comprehensive approach to decision-making under uncertainty. The framework incorporates a flexible weighting scheme, allowing customization based on organizational priorities, and addresses uncertainties through stochastic optimization techniques. The applicability and effectiveness of the framework are demonstrated through case studies in diverse industries, including consumer electronics, automotive, and industrial machinery remanufacturing. Sensitivity analyses provide insights into the robustness of the framework and the impact of varying sustainability indicator weights, uncertain parameter distributions, and environmental regulations. The proposed framework offers a valuable tool for remanufacturing companies, enhancing their sustainability performance and navigating the complexities of uncertain operating environments. • Proposes a novel holistic sustainability assessment framework tailored for remanufacturing. • Introduces a flexible scheme for customizing sustainability factor weights. • Employs stochastic optimization techniques to address uncertainties. • Demonstrates the framework’s applicability and effectiveness through diverse industry case studies.
BibTeX
@article{liu2024holistic,
  author = {Chunting Liu and Yanyan Yang and Xiufeng Liu},
  title = {{A holistic sustainability framework for remanufacturing under uncertainty}},
  journal = {Journal of Manufacturing Systems},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jmsy.2024.08.020},
}
Figure