A Holistic Conceptual Framework into Practice-Based on Urban Tourism Toward Sustainable Development in Thailand

Wannipa Koodsela, Dong Huang, Kassara SukpatchSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a holistic conceptual framework for sustainable urban tourism development in Thailand, emphasizing the integration of policies, stakeholder participation, and a balanced approach to economic, social, and environmental factors. It highlights the urgent need for such a framework, particularly in rapidly developing tourist cities like Chiang Mai and Phuket, to address current challenges and ensure long-term sustainability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the complex challenge of developing urban tourism in Thailand in a sustainable manner. While tourism is a significant economic driver, its rapid growth, especially in cities like Chiang Mai and Phuket, has led to issues such as urban sprawl, environmental degradation, and potential loss of cultural identity. Existing development plans often lack a holistic approach, focusing primarily on economic gains without adequately integrating environmental, social, and cultural considerations. Furthermore, the participation of local residents and stakeholders in the planning process has been historically neglected, leading to a disconnect between development strategies and community needs. The authors aim to bridge this gap by proposing a framework that promotes a balanced, inclusive, and sustainable approach to urban tourism development.

Methods

The research employed a mixed-methods approach, combining quantitative and qualitative data collection and analysis.

  • Quantitative Methods: A questionnaire was developed and distributed to 600 citizens in Chiang Mai and Phuket to assess the current capacity and future needs for sustainable urban tourism development. The data was analyzed using SPSS and Microsoft Excel.
  • Qualitative Methods: In-depth, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 15 key stakeholders, including local government officials, academics, citizens, and private sector representatives. A pilot interview was conducted to refine the methodology. Content analysis was used to interpret the data and identify key themes.

The study also involved a literature review to establish the theoretical underpinnings of sustainable urban tourism and analyze existing policies and frameworks.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from:

  • Quantitative Survey: 600 questionnaires administered to citizens in Chiang Mai and Phuket.
  • Qualitative Interviews: In-depth interviews with 15 key stakeholders from various sectors in Chiang Mai and Phuket.
  • Existing Literature: A comprehensive review of academic papers, reports, and policy documents related to urban tourism, sustainable development, and stakeholder participation.

No new benchmarks were introduced; instead, the research focused on analyzing existing conditions and proposing a framework based on empirical data from the case study areas.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Synergy Cooperation" Imperative: Sustainable urban tourism development in Thailand hinges on integrated collaboration among diverse stakeholders – government, private sector, communities, and even tourists themselves. This "synergy cooperation" is crucial for effective planning and management.
  • Beyond Economic Growth: While economic benefits are a primary driver, true sustainability requires a paradigm shift to balance economic gains with the preservation of cultural heritage, environmental integrity, and the quality of life for local residents.
  • Bottom-Up Approach is Key: Top-down policies, while important, are insufficient. A bottom-up approach, incorporating local knowledge, needs, and expectations, is essential for developing plans that are relevant and effective for the community.
  • Urban Identity as a Core Asset: The unique cultural and historical identity of cities like Chiang Mai and Phuket is not just a tourism attraction but a fundamental asset that must be protected and integrated into development strategies.
  • The Urgent Need for a Holistic Framework: The current ad-hoc approach to urban tourism development is insufficient. A structured, holistic framework is urgently needed to guide policy, planning, and implementation towards long-term sustainability.

Key Results

  • High Capacity and Future Expectations: Both Chiang Mai and Phuket demonstrate high current capacity and readiness for urban tourism development, with even higher expectations for the future. Key strengths identified include "urban image and reputation" and "accessibility."
  • Urban Public Transport Gap: A notable exception in current capacity was "urban public transport," which was rated as medium in Chiang Mai and low in Phuket, highlighting a critical area for improvement.
  • Urgent Needs Identified: For Chiang Mai, "urban area development and rehabilitation" was the most urgent need, followed by "Chiang Mai identity" and "urban historic preservation." For Phuket, "Phuket identity" and "urban historic preservation" were paramount.
  • Fundamental Problems: Key problems identified include a lack of standardized planning, directionless strategies, insufficient data sharing, and a focus on past problems rather than future development strategies.
  • Stakeholder Participation is Crucial: The research strongly emphasizes the need for active stakeholder participation throughout the planning process, from problem definition to strategy formulation and implementation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The authors acknowledge that the power structure and administration of the bureaucratic system have not entirely changed, which can hinder progress. There's also a noted lack of comprehensive decentralization for local governments, leading to legal and regulatory limitations. Furthermore, a lack of data, information, and holistic integration of policy formulation and development plans was identified, along with insufficient budget allocation.
  • Future Work: The paper proposes a "sustainable urban tourism development plan-driving framework" to encourage stakeholder participation and guide future research. This framework aims to integrate policy, planning, and practice, emphasizing area-based development and a bottom-up approach. Future research could focus on refining this framework, developing specific indicators for sustainability assessment, and exploring innovative mechanisms for stakeholder engagement and policy implementation.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article is a research output presenting a new step for urban tourism development in Thailand. It focused on how a urban tourism development action plan was made in accordance with the sustainable tourism development policy in Thailand, and the overall effect of urban tourism development plan-making practice on the environment, quality society, local economics, and urban history and culture. This article proposed a holistic conceptual framework of urban tourism development plan-making practices regarding sustainability. It began with a literature review of urban tourism development and stakeholders in urban tourism development planning. The author emphasized the presentation of the outcome from quantitative and qualitative investigations of urban tourism in Chiang Mai and Phuket, two cities, in a case study of Thailand. The result highlighted the capacity of the area and the urgent need, in a five year period, to develop urban tourism towards sustainability by focusing on the fundamental problems of urban development and urban tourism development, as well as the integration of sustainable policies and the stakeholders’ participation in urban tourism development planning. For this reason, a possible sustainable urban tourism development plan-driving framework has been proposed to encourage the existing participation of stakeholders for future research development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{koodsela2019holistic,
  author = {Wannipa Koodsela and Dong Huang and Kassara Sukpatch},
  title = {{A Holistic Conceptual Framework into Practice-Based on Urban Tourism Toward Sustainable Development in Thailand}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11247152},
}
Figure