A History of Molecular Chaperone Structures in the Protein Data Bank

Neil Andrew D. Bascos, Samuel J. LandryInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This review traces the structural evolution of major molecular chaperone families (Hsp60, Hsp70, Hsp90, Hsp104) as documented in the Protein Data Bank (PDB). By examining how their structures dictate function, the paper highlights their crucial roles in protein folding, unfolding, and complex assembly, underscoring their "unfoldase" potential.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cells are crowded environments where proteins constantly interact. This density, coupled with cellular stress, can lead to misfolding and aggregation, which are detrimental to cellular function and linked to various diseases. Molecular chaperones, particularly Heat Shock Proteins (Hsps), are essential for preventing these unwanted protein associations, facilitating proper folding, and even disaggregating existing protein clumps. While their functional importance is well-established, understanding how they achieve these diverse tasks at a molecular level requires detailed structural information. This paper addresses the need to consolidate and review the available structural data for key Hsp families in the Protein Data Bank (PDB) to illuminate the structure-function relationships that underpin their chaperone activities.

Methods

This paper is a review article, not an experimental study. The primary "method" employed is a comprehensive survey and analysis of existing structural data for molecular chaperones, specifically focusing on entries within the Protein Data Bank (PDB). The authors searched the PDB using keywords related to different Hsp families (Hsp60, Hsp70, Hsp90, Hsp104) and their homologs. They then analyzed the deposited structures, discussing:

  • Complete structures: Examining the overall architecture of the chaperone complexes.
  • Domain structures: Investigating the individual functional units within these proteins.
  • Interactions with co-chaperones: Understanding how accessory proteins modulate chaperone function.
  • Nucleotide-binding states: Analyzing how ATP/ADP binding influences conformational changes and activity.
  • Substrate binding: Observing how chaperones interact with unfolded or misfolded proteins.

The authors also reference various experimental techniques used to obtain these structures, such as X-ray crystallography and cryo-electron microscopy.

Datasets

The primary dataset utilized in this paper is the Protein Data Bank (PDB). The authors specifically surveyed structures available as of August 2019. They note that the distribution of structures is uneven across different Hsp families, with Hsp90 having the most entries, while Hsp104 and small Hsps have fewer. The paper also references data from the UniProt database for curated information on chaperone families, their functions, and cellular localizations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Unfoldase" as a unifying concept: The paper proposes "unfoldase" as a more encompassing term for the basic function shared by many chaperones, acknowledging that they possess specialized functions beyond simple folding assistance.
  • Structural diversity dictates function: Each Hsp family has evolved distinct structural architectures to perform its specific roles:
  • Hsp60s: Form barrel-like "Anfinsen cages" for sequestering and refolding proteins.
  • Hsp70s: Employ modular "clamps" to bind and protect hydrophobic regions of target proteins, often involving ATP hydrolysis for conformational changes.
  • Hsp90s: Utilize V-shaped, multidomain structures with a "scissor-like" motion to refine receptor proteins, playing a key role in signaling pathways.
  • Hsp104s: Form hexameric rings that act like a "ratchet" to actively unfold and disaggregate protein aggregates.
  • Co-chaperones are critical regulators: The paper emphasizes the indispensable role of co-chaperones (like Hsp40, GrpE, p23, Hop, Cdc37) in modulating Hsp activity, often by influencing nucleotide binding, substrate delivery, and conformational transitions.
  • ATP hydrolysis as a molecular engine: For many Hsp families, the cycle of ATP binding and hydrolysis is central to their mechanism, driving conformational changes that are essential for substrate binding, release, and protein manipulation.
  • PDB as a historical record: The review effectively uses the PDB as a timeline, showing how structural understanding of these complex proteins has progressed from individual domains to complete functional machines.

Key Results

The paper does not present novel experimental results but rather synthesizes existing structural knowledge. Key findings include:

  • Structural basis for diverse functions: The paper details how specific structural features of Hsp60, Hsp70, Hsp90, and Hsp104 (e.g., barrel cages, clamp mechanisms, V-shaped structures, hexameric rings) directly correlate with their roles in protein folding, unfolding, and complex assembly.
  • Mechanistic insights from domain structures: Analysis of individual domains (e.g., ATPase domain, substrate-binding domain) has provided crucial insights into allosteric regulation and nucleotide-dependent conformational changes.
  • Role of co-chaperones elucidated: Structures showing interactions between Hsps and their co-chaperones have revealed how these partners fine-tune chaperone activity, such as facilitating ATP hydrolysis or stabilizing specific conformations.
  • Progress in structural determination: The review highlights the shift from studying isolated domains to obtaining full-length structures, often enabled by advancements in techniques like cryo-electron microscopy, particularly for large complexes like Hsp104.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uneven PDB representation: The authors acknowledge that the PDB has an uneven distribution of structures across different Hsp families and organisms, which can limit comprehensive comparative analysis.
  • Need for further investigation: Specific areas requiring more structural data are identified, such as the detailed mechanisms of cdc37 modulation of Hsp90 function and the complete assembly of RNA polymerase II by Hsp90.
  • Potential for protein engineering: The paper suggests that by understanding the functional features of individual chaperone domains, researchers can build a library of resources for designing novel molecular machines with customizable functions, potentially for applications like improved recombinant protein production.
  • Therapeutic potential: The review touches upon the therapeutic implications of Hsps, particularly Hsp104's role in disaggregating protein aggregates, suggesting their potential as agents against aggregation-based pathologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Thirty years ago a class of proteins was found to prevent the aggregation of Rubisco. These proteins' ability to prevent unwanted associations led to their being called chaperones. These chaperone proteins also increased in expression as a response to heat shock, hence their label as heat shock proteins (Hsps). However, neither label encompasses the breadth of these proteins' functional capabilities. The term "unfoldases" has been proposed, as this basic function is shared by most members of this protein family. Onto this is added specializations that allow the different family members to perform various cellular functions. This current article focuses on the resolved structural bases for these functions. It reviews the currently available molecular structures in the Protein Data Bank for several classes of Hsps (Hsp60, Hsp70, Hsp90, and Hsp104). When possible, it discusses the complete structures for these proteins, and the types of molecular machines to which they have been assigned. The structures of domains and the associated functions are discussed in order to illustrate the rationale for the proposed unfoldase function.
BibTeX
@article{bascos2019history,
  author = {Neil Andrew D. Bascos and Samuel J. Landry},
  title = {{A History of Molecular Chaperone Structures in the Protein Data Bank}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms20246195},
}
Figure