A High-Pressure Bi-Directional Cycloid Rotor Flowmeter

Shuo Liu, Fan Ding, Chuan Ding, Zaipeng Man2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel high-pressure, bi-directional cycloid rotor flowmeter designed for industrial automation. The device achieves high accuracy (±0.5% relative error) and low pressure loss (3 bar at 100 L/min) by utilizing a unique cycloid rotor design and advanced sensor integration, offering a promising alternative to existing positive displacement flowmeters.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate flow rate measurement is crucial in industrial automation, particularly in custody transfer and hydraulic control systems. Positive displacement (PD) flowmeters are favored for their accuracy and robustness. However, existing PD meter designs like oval gear flowmeters can have high pressure losses, while profile-shifted gear flowmeters, though offering better noise and pressure loss characteristics, have small displacements leading to high rotor speeds and potential bearing wear. Helical screw rotors offer low pulsation and pressure loss but demand high machining precision, increasing cost and risk of rotor seizure. This paper addresses the need for a PD flowmeter that combines the advantages of low pressure loss, high accuracy, and robustness, while also being bi-directional and capable of handling high pressures.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the use of internal and external cycloid rotors. The internal rotor's curve is an equidistant curtate epicycloid, with the external rotor curve as its conjugate. This design allows for large displacements with fewer teeth, which in turn reduces rotor speed and pressure loss. The paper details the mathematical modeling of these cycloid curves, establishing parametric equations to describe their geometry.

For measurement, the flowmeter incorporates Hall sensors integrated into the top cover, working in conjunction with permanent magnets embedded in the external rotor. Four pairs of magnets are distributed around the rotor, providing four pulses per rotation, thus enabling a quarter-displacement resolution. The phase difference between two Hall sensors is used to determine the flow direction, allowing for bi-directional measurement.

The displacement calculation is based on the conservation of energy equation for the internal rotor, considering the torque applied by the fluid. The instantaneous flow through a single chamber and the total instantaneous flow for the entire flowmeter are derived. The accumulated flow is then calculated by integrating the instantaneous flow over a rotation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the design, fabrication, and experimental testing of a prototype flowmeter.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cycloid Rotor Advantage: The use of cycloid rotors, particularly with large eccentricity and few teeth, offers a significant advantage in achieving large displacements, which directly translates to lower rotor speeds and reduced pressure loss compared to other PD meter designs.
  • Bi-directional Measurement: The clever integration of two phase-shifted Hall sensors allows for easy determination of flow direction, making the flowmeter inherently bi-directional without complex mechanical additions.
  • Simplified Design: The cycloid rotor meshing without auxiliary gears simplifies the flowmeter's structure, reducing component count and potentially manufacturing costs.
  • Accuracy and Pressure Loss Trade-off: The paper demonstrates that this cycloid design effectively balances high accuracy (±0.5% relative error) with low pressure loss (3 bar at 100 L/min), outperforming some existing technologies.
  • Internal Leakage as Primary Error Source: Experimental results suggest that internal leakage, influenced by clearance width, viscosity, and differential pressure, is the dominant factor contributing to errors, rather than reading uncertainty.

Key Results

  • A prototype high-pressure (up to 31.5 MPa), bi-directional cycloid rotor flowmeter was fabricated.
  • The flowmeter achieved a measuring range of 1–100 L/min with relative errors of less than ±0.5%.
  • The pressure loss at a flow rate of 100 L/min was approximately 3 bar, which is significantly lower than that of a comparable PD meter with profile-shifted gears.
  • The Hall sensor system successfully provided square wave outputs corresponding to rotor rotation, with phase differences indicating flow direction.
  • The relative reading uncertainty was found to be less than 0.17% at a 95% confidence level.
  • Experimental results showed that the real discharge coefficients were slightly larger than the theoretical value and varied with pressure and flow rate, with relative errors between ±0.45%.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that internal leakage is a primary source of error. They suggest that further improvements in machining accuracy could significantly reduce this leakage, leading to higher measurement accuracy and a larger measurement range with even less pressure loss. Future work could focus on optimizing the clearance between rotors and covers to minimize leakage while maintaining smooth operation. Additionally, exploring different cycloid curve parameters could further enhance performance characteristics.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{liu2014high,
  author = {Shuo Liu and Fan Ding and Chuan Ding and Zaipeng Man},
  title = {{A High-Pressure Bi-Directional Cycloid Rotor Flowmeter}},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3390/s140815480},
}
Figure