A High-Precision Current-Mode Bandgap Reference with Nonlinear Temperature Compensation

Zhizhi Chen, Qian Wang, Xi Li, Sannian Song, Houpeng Chen, Zhitang SongMicromachines 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel high-precision current-mode bandgap reference (BGR) circuit that significantly improves temperature stability by introducing a high-order nonlinear compensation technique. The proposed design achieves an impressive temperature coefficient (TC) of approximately 3.78 ppm/°C over a wide temperature range (-50°C to 120°C), making it suitable for demanding integrated circuit applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bandgap reference (BGR) circuits are fundamental building blocks in integrated circuits, providing stable voltage or current references that are crucial for the proper functioning of analog, digital, and mixed-signal systems. However, a major challenge in BGR design is maintaining a stable output over a wide range of temperatures. Conventional BGR circuits often rely on first-order temperature compensation, which can only correct for the primary temperature-dependent components, leaving residual high-order "nonlinear" temperature errors. These errors can degrade the accuracy and reliability of the entire system, especially as integrated circuits operate at lower voltages and require higher precision. This paper aims to address this limitation by developing a BGR circuit with advanced, high-order temperature compensation to minimize these nonlinear errors.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper lies in its approach to compensating for high-order temperature nonlinearities in current-mode BGR circuits. The authors start by modifying the theoretical equation describing the nonlinear current in the bipolar junction transistor (BJT) used for compensation. They then propose two key solutions to mitigate the high-order terms:

  1. Branch Division: The nonlinear compensation BJT (NLCBJT) branch is split into two sub-branches. This division effectively reduces the coefficient of the nonlinear temperature compensation current.
  2. Nonlinear Current Injection: The nonlinear current is then strategically injected into these two branches. This injection further refines the compensation, aiming to eliminate the temperature coefficient of the current flowing into the NLCBJT.

The proposed circuit builds upon existing high-order compensation techniques but introduces a more refined method for handling the nonlinear terms. The design was implemented and simulated using the SMIC 55 nm CMOS process.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on simulations of the designed circuit.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High-order nonlinearities are a critical bottleneck: The paper highlights that even with existing compensation techniques, residual high-order temperature terms in BJTs significantly impact BGR accuracy.
  • Splitting and injecting nonlinear currents is key: The proposed two-stage compensation strategy—dividing the NLCBJT branch and then injecting the nonlinear current—is shown to be highly effective in suppressing these higher-order errors.
  • Current-mode BGRs offer advantages for low-voltage operation: The paper emphasizes the suitability of current-mode BGRs for modern low-voltage ICs, where voltage-mode references might struggle.
  • Comprehensive simulation validates the approach: The extensive simulations, including temperature sweeps and Monte Carlo analysis across process corners, provide strong evidence for the effectiveness of the proposed compensation scheme.

Key Results

The proposed high-precision current-mode BGR circuit demonstrates significant performance improvements:

  • Exceptional Temperature Stability: The output reference current exhibits a very low temperature coefficient (TC) of approximately 3.78 ppm/°C over a wide temperature range of -50°C to 120°C. This is a substantial improvement over many existing designs.
  • Reduced Current Variation: The variations in the currents flowing into the NLCBJTs were drastically reduced from 148.41 nA to as low as 7.4 nA in the final proposed circuit.
  • Compact Layout: The BGR layout occupies a small area of 0.044 mm².
  • Low Quiescent Current: The circuit consumes a quiescent current of 42.13 µA.
  • Good Power Supply Rejection: The post-layout simulation shows a power supply rejection ratio (PSR) of -63.1 dB at 100 Hz.
  • Stable Frequency Response: AC analysis indicates a stable operation with a phase margin greater than 76.63 degrees and a gain margin of 16.64 dB.
  • Fast Transient Response: The circuit reaches its normal operating state in approximately 0.14 ms after a supply voltage step.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Trimming for Extreme Corners: While the proposed design significantly reduces temperature variations, the paper notes that for extreme process corners (e.g., "ss" and "fs"), trimming might still be beneficial to achieve the highest accuracy. The authors suggest a three-bit trimming scheme but do not provide detailed implementation steps.
  • Comparison with Prior Art: The paper includes a comprehensive comparison table (Table 2) showing that its TC is superior over a wider temperature range compared to many previous works, and it offers advantages in layout area, current consumption, and PSR. However, it acknowledges that some prior works might achieve a better FOM due to specific parameter optimizations (e.g., very low IQ in Ref. [10]).
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that further optimization of trimming strategies could enhance performance even further, especially for applications demanding absolute perfection across all process variations. The focus on current-mode BGRs also points towards continued exploration in this domain for low-voltage applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

A high-precision current-mode bandgap reference (BGR) circuit with a high-order temperature compensation is presented in this paper. In order to achieve a high-precision BGR circuit, the equation of the nonlinear current has been modified and the high-order term of the current flowing into the nonlinear compensation bipolar junction transistor (NLCBJT) is compensated further. According to the modified equation, two solutions are designed to improve the output accuracy of BGR circuits. The first solution is to divide the NLCBJT branch into two branches to reduce the coefficient of the nonlinear temperature compensation current. The second solution is to inject the nonlinear current into the two branches based on the first one to further eliminate the temperature coefficient (TC) of the current flowing into the NLCBJT. The proposed BGR circuit has been designed using the Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corporation (SMIC) 55 nm CMOS process. The simulation results show that the variations in currents flowing into NLCBJTs improved from 148.41 nA to 69.35 nA and 7.4 nA, respectively, the TC of the output reference current of the proposed circuit is approximately 3.78 ppm/°C at a temperature range of -50 °C to 120 °C with a supply voltage of 3.3 V, the quiescent current consumption of the entire BGR circuit is 42.13 μA, and the size of the BGR layout is 0.044 mm<sup>2</sup>, leading to the development of a high-precision BGR circuit.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2023high,
  author = {Zhizhi Chen and Qian Wang and Xi Li and Sannian Song and Houpeng Chen and Zhitang Song},
  title = {{A High-Precision Current-Mode Bandgap Reference with Nonlinear Temperature Compensation}},
  booktitle = {Micromachines},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/mi14071420},
}
Figure