A High Burden of Cerebral white Matter Lesion: Evidences from 9 Asian Cities

Bonnie Lam, Brian Yiu, Encarnita Ampil, Christopher Chen, Yustiani Dikot, Jacqueline C. Dominguez, Patel Vishal Ganeshbhai, Saima Hilal, Nagaendran Kandiah, SangYun Kim, Jun‐Young Lee, Paulus Anam Ong, Vorapun Senanarong, Kam Tat Leung, Huali Wang, Yuan‐Han Yang, Tingting Yong, Faheem Arshad, Suvarna Alladi, Samuel Yeung Shan Wong, Ho Ko, Alexander Yuk Lun Lau, Vincent MokResearch 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Age-related white matter lesion (WML) is considered a manifestation of sporadic cerebral small vessel disease and an important pathological substrate for dementia. Asia is notable for its large population with a looming dementia epidemic. Yet, the burden of WML and its associated risk factors across different Asian societies are unknown.

Methods: Subjects from 9 Asian cities (Bangkok, Bandung, Beijing, Bengaluru, Hong Kong, Kaohsiung, Manila, Seoul, and Singapore) were recruited (n = 5,701) and classified into i) stroke/transient ischemic attack (TIA), ii) Alzheimer’s disease (AD)/mild cognitive impairment (MCI), or iii) control groups. Data on vascular risk factors and cognitive performance were collected. The severity of WML was visually rated on MRI or CT.

Results: The prevalence of moderate-to-severe WML was the highest in subjects with stroke/TIA (43.3%). Bandung, Indonesia showed the highest prevalence of WML, adjusted for age, sex, education and disease groups. Hypertension and hyperlipidemia were significant risk factors for WML, and WML was negatively associated with MMSE in all groups.

Conclusions: WML is highly prevalent in Asia and is associated with increasing age, hypertension, hyperlipidemia and worse cognitive performance. Concerted efforts to prevent WML will alleviate the huge dementia burden in the rapidly aging Asian societies.

Introduction

As Asia’s population ages, it faces a "dementia epidemic," with cases expected to triple by 2050. A key player in this crisis is Cerebral Small Vessel Disease (CSVD), which often manifests on brain scans as white matter lesions (WML)—scarring or damage to the "cabling" of the brain. While WMLs are known to increase the risk of stroke and cognitive decline, a clear, standardized picture of this burden across diverse Asian societies has been lacking. Previous studies were often small or localized, using inconsistent rating scales. This study provides the first large-scale, multi-center evidence of WML prevalence and its associated risk factors across nine major Asian urban populations.

Methods

The AWARE (Asian White mAtteR lEsion) study recruited 5,701 subjects from nine cities: Bangkok, Bandung, Beijing, Bengaluru, Hong Kong, Kaohsiung, Manila, Seoul, and Singapore. Participants were categorized into three groups:

  1. Stroke/TIA: Patients who had experienced a stroke or transient ischemic attack.
  2. AD/MCI: Patients with Alzheimer’s Disease or Mild Cognitive Impairment.
  3. Controls: Functionally independent adults without dementia or stroke.

The team used a standardized approach to rate the severity of WMLs on MRI or CT scans using the Fazekas scale (ranging from 0 to 3). To ensure consistency, the rating process was centralized, with Hong Kong serving as the lead rater for quality control. This approach allowed for a robust comparison across different geographical and ethnic populations, including regions like Indonesia and the Philippines where such data was previously limited.

Results

The study revealed a staggering prevalence of "silent" brain changes across all cohorts. Notably, even in the "healthy" control group, 36.7% of participants exhibited moderate-to-severe WML (Fazekas grades 2 and 3). This suggests that significant brain damage often precedes clinical symptoms of stroke or dementia.

Table 1: Demographic and clinical characteristics of the study population across Stroke/TIA, AD/MCI, and Control groups.

Key Findings:

  • Prevalence by Group: Moderate-to-severe WML was found in 43.3% of the Stroke/TIA group, 38.2% of the AD/MCI group, and 36.7% of controls.
  • Age and Risk Factors: WML prevalence increased sharply with age. In the control group, prevalence rose from 8.3% in those under 60 to 65.2% in those over 81. Hypertension and hyperlipidemia were the most consistent predictors of WML severity, with hypertension increasing the odds of severe WML by 80% (OR 1.80).
  • Cognitive Impact: Across all groups, the presence of moderate-to-severe WML was associated with approximately a 2-point lower score on the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE), indicating a significant gap in cognitive performance.
  • Regional Variation: Significant differences were observed between cities. Bandung, Indonesia, showed the highest prevalence (88.9% in the stroke group), likely due to high rates of untreated hypertension in that cohort.

Discussion and Conclusion

The AWARE study highlights that WML is not merely a byproduct of aging but is strongly driven by modifiable vascular risk factors, particularly hypertension. The high prevalence in asymptomatic controls underscores the need for early intervention.

Limitations

The study faced challenges regarding imaging consistency, as some centers used CT scans which are less sensitive than MRI. Additionally, the clinic-based recruitment may introduce sampling bias compared to community-based studies. The cross-sectional design also means that while strong associations were found, causality cannot be definitively proven.

Conclusion

WML is highly prevalent in Asia and is a major contributor to cognitive decline. Concerted efforts to manage hypertension and hyperlipidemia in mid-life could effectively slow the progression of WML and alleviate the looming dementia burden in rapidly aging Asian societies. Future longitudinal studies are needed to track lesion progression and the impact of aggressive blood pressure management.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Age-related white matter lesion (WML) is considered a manifestation of sporadic cerebral small vessel disease and an important pathological substrate for dementia. Asia is notable for its large population with a looming dementia epidemic. Yet, the burden of WML and its associated risk factors across different Asian societies are unknown. Methods Subjects from 9 Asian cities (Bangkok, Bandung, Beijing, Bengaluru, Hong Kong, Kaohsiung, Manila, Seoul, and Singapore) were recruited ( n = 5,701) and classified into i) stroke/transient ischemic attack (TIA), ii) Alzheimer’s disease (AD)/mild cognitive impairment (MCI), or iii) control groups. Data on vascular risk factors and cognitive performance were collected. The severity of WML was visually rated on MRI or CT. Results The prevalence of moderate-to-severe WML was the highest in subjects with stroke/TIA (43.3 % ). Bandang Indonesia showed the highest prevalence of WML, adjusted for age, sex, education and disease groups. Hypertension and hyperlipidemia were significant risk factors for WML, and WML was negatively associated with MMSE in all groups. Conclusions WML is highly prevalent in Asia and is associated with increasing age, hypertension, hyperlipidemia and worse cognitive performance. Concerted efforts to prevent WML will alleviate the huge dementia burden in the rapidly aging Asian societies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lam2020high,
  author = {Bonnie Lam and Brian Yiu and Encarnita Ampil and Christopher Chen and Yustiani Dikot and Jacqueline C. Dominguez and Patel Vishal Ganeshbhai and Saima Hilal and Nagaendran Kandiah and SangYun Kim and Jun‐Young Lee and Paulus Anam Ong and Vorapun Senanarong and Kam Tat Leung and Huali Wang and Yuan‐Han Yang and Tingting Yong and Faheem Arshad and Suvarna Alladi and Samuel Yeung Shan Wong and Ho Ko and Alexander Yuk Lun Lau and Vincent Mok},
  title = {{A High Burden of Cerebral white Matter Lesion: Evidences from 9 Asian Cities}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-124194/v1},
}
Figure