A hierarchical, retinotopic proto-organization of the primate visual system at birth

Michael J. Arcaro, Margaret S. LivingstoneeLife 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

Newborn primate visual systems, as young as 10 days old, already exhibit a surprisingly mature hierarchical and retinotopic organization, mirroring adult structures. This "proto-organization" suggests that the fundamental scaffolding for visual processing is established prenatally, providing a foundation for later experience-dependent development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The development of the visual system is a complex process. While we know that adult primates have a highly organized visual cortex with distinct areas arranged in hierarchical pathways (dorsal and ventral streams), the question of when this organization emerges has been a significant one. Specifically, researchers wanted to know if this intricate structure is innate or if it develops primarily through visual experience after birth. This paper aims to pinpoint the earliest stages of this organization, asking to what extent a newborn's visual system resembles the adult's, and whether this organization is present at birth.

Methods

The researchers employed functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) in neonatal macaques. A key challenge was that newborns are not adept at fixating on visual stimuli, making traditional retinotopic mapping difficult. To overcome this, they relied heavily on seed-based correlation analysis during resting-state periods (when the monkeys were awake but not viewing stimuli) and also analyzed visually evoked responses when possible.

  • Resting-state fMRI: By examining patterns of correlated neural activity between different brain regions during rest, they could infer functional connectivity and organization. This is a powerful technique for studying brain organization in states where active task performance is challenging.
  • Across-hemisphere correlations: A crucial aspect was analyzing correlations between homologous regions in the left and right hemispheres. This approach helps to identify functionally distinct areas and their organization, as callosal connections (connecting the two hemispheres) are known to link functionally related areas.
  • Areal correlation profile analysis: This advanced technique compared the pattern of correlations of a seed area with all other areas (within-hemisphere) to the correlation pattern of individual voxels with all other areas (across-hemisphere). This allowed for a more spatially specific identification of functional areas.
  • Independent Component Analysis (ICA): Used to identify functionally related networks within the brain.
  • Retinotopic mapping (in older juveniles): Performed later in development (when monkeys could fixate) to establish a baseline for comparison with the neonatal data.

Datasets

The study utilized fMRI data from four infant/juvenile Macaca mulatta monkeys. Data was collected at different ages: <18 days, ~110 days, ~123 days, and >1.5 years. The older data (>1.5 years) was used for establishing mature retinotopic maps and for comparison with the neonatal findings. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Innate Organization: The most striking finding is that the visual system is not a blank slate at birth. A significant degree of hierarchical and retinotopic organization is already present, suggesting a strong genetic blueprint.
  • Proto-organization: This early organization acts as a "proto-organization," a foundational structure that guides subsequent development and specialization based on visual experience.
  • Dorsal and Ventral Streams at Birth: The study clearly delineated the beginnings of the dorsal (where/how) and ventral (what) visual processing streams, mirroring the adult organization.
  • Retinotopy Precedes Category Selectivity: Even in areas like the inferotemporal (IT) cortex, which in adults are specialized for recognizing objects like faces, retinotopic organization (mapping of visual space) was present before any signs of category-specific responses emerged. This implies that the spatial layout of visual information is a prerequisite for learning to recognize specific objects.
  • Low-Level Feature Selectivity is Early: Beyond retinotopy, basic feature tuning (like spatial frequency and curvature) also showed an organization that correlated with retinotopic maps, suggesting that the building blocks for more complex visual perception are in place early on.

Key Results

  • Hierarchical and Retinotopic Organization: Resting-state fMRI revealed significant correlations between visual areas, indicating arealization and a hierarchical structure similar to adults, present as early as 10 days postnatal.
  • Dorsal/Ventral Pathway Segregation: Multidimensional scaling and clustering analyses of correlation patterns clearly separated visual cortical areas into dorsal and ventral groups, consistent with adult organization.
  • Retinotopic Maps in Early Visual Cortex: Correlation patterns in neonates predicted retinotopic maps measured later in life, with a mean absolute deviation of only 2.2° across retinotopic areas.
  • Early IT Cortex Organization: Retinotopic organization in IT cortex was observed in neonates, with foveal biases in regions that would later become face-selective patches. This organization was present months before face-selective clusters emerged.
  • Spatial Frequency and Curvature Tuning: In slightly older infants (~110-186 days), spatial frequency and curvature tuning showed correlations with eccentricity, suggesting that basic feature selectivity is also organized early and linked to retinotopy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Immature Visual System: The authors acknowledge that while the organization is present, the visual system is still anatomically and functionally immature in many ways. For example, visually evoked responses were weak in very young neonates, potentially due to low arousal or metabolic differences.
  • Correlation vs. Direct Activation: Much of the study relies on correlation analysis during rest, which infers functional connectivity. While powerful, it's not the same as observing direct visually evoked activation in all cases, especially in the youngest subjects.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that this innate proto-architecture serves as a "scaffolding" for subsequent experience-dependent specialization. Future research could explore how visual experience refines these early maps, how molecular cues and activity-dependent sorting establish these initial structures prenatally, and whether similar principles apply to other sensory systems and broader cortical organization. The study also highlights the need to understand the precise mechanisms by which these early maps are established.

Summary updated

Abstract

The adult primate visual system comprises a series of hierarchically organized areas. Each cortical area contains a topographic map of visual space, with different areas extracting different kinds of information from the retinal input. Here we asked to what extent the newborn visual system resembles the adult organization. We find that hierarchical, topographic organization is present at birth and therefore constitutes a proto-organization for the entire primate visual system. Even within inferior temporal cortex, this proto-organization was already present, prior to the emergence of category selectivity (e.g., faces or scenes). We propose that this topographic organization provides the scaffolding for the subsequent development of visual cortex that commences at the onset of visual experience.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{arcaro2017hierarchical,
  author = {Michael J. Arcaro and Margaret S. Livingstone},
  title = {{A hierarchical, retinotopic proto-organization of the primate visual system at birth}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.26196},
}
Figure