A Hierarchical Dirichlet Process Model for Joint Part-of-Speech and Morphology Induction

Kairit Sirts, Tanel AlumäeNAACL 2012

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel unsupervised Bayesian model that jointly learns Part-of-Speech (POS) tags and morphological segmentations for words. By integrating these two tasks, the model achieves state-of-the-art results in POS induction and learns the number of tags directly from data, avoiding the need for pre-specified tagsets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional Part-of-Speech (POS) tagging models, especially those using Hidden Markov Models (HMMs), often require the number of possible tags (states) to be known in advance. This is problematic for unsupervised learning, as this information is unavailable, and it imposes an arbitrary constraint on the model. Similarly, unsupervised morphology induction aims to break down words into their meaningful sub-units (morphemes). While previous work has shown that incorporating morphological features can improve POS tagging, these tasks have typically been addressed separately or with significant manual feature engineering. This paper tackles the challenge of jointly learning both POS tags and morphological segmentations in a fully unsupervised manner, hypothesizing that these tasks are interdependent and can benefit from being learned together.

Methods

The core of the proposed model is a Hierarchical Dirichlet Process (HDP) that defines a generative sequence model with an HMM structure. The HDP is particularly well-suited for this task because it allows the number of "topics" or "clusters" (in this case, POS tags and morphological segments) to be inferred from the data, rather than being fixed beforehand.

The model's generative story involves:

  1. Learning the lexicon: For each word type, the model learns its POS tag and morphological segmentation. This is achieved by drawing tag distributions and segment distributions from Dirichlet Processes.
  2. Learning HMM parameters: The model learns transition probabilities between tags (bigram and trigram) and emission probabilities (mapping tags to words) using HDPs.
  3. Generating sequences: Finally, the model generates sequences of tags and words using standard HMM procedures.

A key innovation is the joint modeling of POS induction and morphological segmentation. The model uses a type-based approach, clustering word types into hard clusters. For inference, the authors employ a collapsed Gibbs sampler for tags and a Metropolis-Hastings sampler for segmentations, integrating out the DP measures using the Chinese Restaurant Process (CRP) representation. They also introduce a likelihood scaling heuristic to improve tagging performance, which was found to be crucial.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its model on several datasets:

  • Multext-East corpora: Used for POS induction across multiple languages.
  • CONLL-X Shared Task corpora: Used for POS induction on Dutch, Danish, Swedish, and Portuguese.
  • Morpho Challenge gold segmented wordlists: Used for evaluating morphological segmentation on English, Finnish, and Turkish.
  • Europarl corpus: Used for English and Finnish sentences.
  • Turkish text data from Morpho Challenge 2009: Used for Turkish segmentation.
  • Estonian morphologically annotated corpus: Used for Estonian segmentation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy between POS and Morphology: The paper provides evidence that jointly learning POS tags and morphological segmentations leads to better results than learning them separately, even when gold-standard data for one task is provided to the other. This suggests a strong interdependence between the two tasks.
  • Unsupervised Learning of Tagset Size: The use of Dirichlet Processes (specifically HDPs) allows the model to infer the optimal number of POS tags from the data, eliminating the need for manual specification and making the model truly unsupervised.
  • Likelihood Scaling Heuristic: A simple heuristic to scale emission probabilities significantly improved tagging accuracy, highlighting the importance of balancing different components of the model's likelihood.
  • Surprising Convergence Behavior: The authors observed that while tagging likelihood improved slowly after initial iterations, segmentation likelihood improved dramatically, suggesting that initial random segmentations were poor but the model quickly learned to improve them.

Key Results

  • State-of-the-Art POS Induction: The model achieves state-of-the-art results on POS induction across multiple languages, often matching or exceeding previously published results.
  • Competitive Segmentation: While the model's segmentation performance is good, it does not consistently outperform specialized morphology induction systems like Morfessor. However, the joint learning approach still yields competitive results.
  • Tagset Size: The number of induced tags often closely matches the number of gold-standard tags, validating the model's ability to learn a meaningful tagset size.
  • Semisupervised Experiments: These experiments showed that fully unsupervised joint learning outperformed semisupervised approaches where gold-standard data for one task was provided to the other, reinforcing the benefit of joint learning.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Segmentation Performance: The model's morphological segmentation performance, while good, is not superior to specialized systems. The authors suggest that using segment bigrams instead of unigrams might improve segmentation results.
  • Feature Engineering: The current model intentionally omits features like punctuation and capitalization, which are used by other state-of-the-art POS induction systems. Incorporating these could further boost performance.
  • Multilingual Extensions: The authors suggest extending the model to a truly multilingual setting, similar to prior work, and exploring joint learning of morphological paradigms.
  • Understanding Heuristic Influence: The exact characteristics and influence of the likelihood scaling heuristic on tag distributions require further investigation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{sirts2012hierarchical,
  author = {Kairit Sirts and Tanel Alumäe},
  title = {{A Hierarchical Dirichlet Process Model for Joint Part-of-Speech and Morphology Induction}},
  booktitle = {Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2012},
}

Loading related content...

Figure