A heterotic standard model

Volker Braun, Yang‐Hui He, Burt A. Ovrut, Tony PantevPhysics 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a significant step towards a realistic particle physics model from string theory. The authors construct specific "vacua" (stable configurations) of the heterotic superstring that yield a gauge group and particle content remarkably similar to the Standard Model, crucially without the problematic "exotic matter" often found in such constructions. This work offers a potential solution to long-standing issues like nucleon decay suppression and provides a concrete realization of a long-sought goal in theoretical physics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, physicists have sought to unify all fundamental forces and particles within a single theoretical framework, with string theory being a leading candidate. A key challenge has been to derive the observed Standard Model of particle physics from string theory in a way that is both mathematically consistent and phenomenologically viable. Specifically, the heterotic string theory, a promising framework, has faced difficulties in producing "realistic" vacua. These vacua often contain "exotic matter" – particles not observed in our universe – or fail to reproduce the correct gauge groups and particle families. Furthermore, the suppression of nucleon decay, a process predicted by some Grand Unified Theories but not observed, has been a persistent puzzle. This paper tackles the problem of constructing realistic N=1 supersymmetric vacua within the heterotic string theory that not only match the Standard Model's gauge group and particle content but also address these specific challenges.

Methods

The authors employ a sophisticated combination of mathematical techniques from geometry and theoretical physics. Their approach involves:

  • Calabi-Yau Threefolds and Instantons: They utilize specific types of geometric spaces called Calabi-Yau threefolds, which are crucial for compactifying the extra dimensions of string theory. They focus on those with a fundamental group of $Z_3 \times Z_3$. A key innovation is the construction of $SU(4)$ gauge instantons on these manifolds. Instantons are non-perturbative effects in quantum field theory that can break symmetries and generate gauge groups.
  • "Splitting" Multiplets: A novel method for "splitting" multiplets (groups of particles predicted by supersymmetry) is used. This technique is essential for precisely tailoring the particle content of the resulting Standard Model.
  • Bundle Extensions and Cohomology: They construct stable, holomorphic vector bundles on the Calabi-Yau manifolds. The properties of these bundles, particularly their cohomology (related to the number of independent solutions to certain equations), are used to determine the particle spectrum and gauge groups.
  • Wilson Lines: The introduction of Wilson lines is used to further break the gauge symmetry of the string theory down to the Standard Model gauge group.
  • Anomaly Cancellation: A fundamental requirement in string theory is anomaly cancellation, ensuring the theory is mathematically consistent. This is enforced by relating the observable and hidden sectors of the theory.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This paper is a theoretical construction and does not rely on experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Realistic Vacua Without Exotic Matter: The most striking result is the construction of vacua where the observable sector (the particles we observe) contains no exotic matter. This is a significant achievement, as many previous attempts were plagued by such unwanted particles.
  • Natural Suppression of Nucleon Decay: The emergence of a gauged $U(1)_{B-L}$ symmetry (related to baryon and lepton number) that is spontaneously broken at or above the electroweak scale is a crucial finding. This symmetry naturally suppresses the rate of nucleon decay, a long-standing problem in phenomenological string theory.
  • Two Higgs-Higgs Conjugate Pairs: The presence of two Higgs-Higgs conjugate pairs, rather than the single pair in the Standard Model, is an interesting feature. This could have implications for electroweak symmetry breaking and particle interactions.
  • Minimal and Rare Vacua: The authors emphasize that these vacua are minimal and rare, suggesting they might be particularly significant for understanding the low-energy physics of the universe.
  • Connection to Standard Model: The derived gauge group $SU(3)_C \times SU(2)_L \times U(1)_Y \times U(1)_{B-L}$ and the three families of quarks and leptons, each with a right-handed neutrino, closely mirror the Standard Model, with the addition of the $U(1)_{B-L}$ symmetry.

Key Results

The paper successfully demonstrates the existence of N=1 supersymmetric vacua from the heterotic string theory with the following properties:

  • Observable Sector:
    • Gauge group: $SU(3)_C \times SU(2)_L \times U(1)_Y \times U(1)_{B-L}$.
  • Particle content: Three families of quarks and leptons, each with an additional right-handed neutrino.
  • Higgs sector: Two Higgs-Higgs conjugate pairs.
  • Moduli: A small number of uncharged vector bundle moduli.
  • Exotic Matter: None.
  • Hidden Sector (Strong Coupling):
    • Gauge group: $E_7 \times U(6)$.
  • Moduli: A small number of vector bundle moduli.
  • Matter: None.
  • Hidden Sector (Weak Coupling):
    • Gauge group: $Spin(12)$.
  • Moduli: A small number of vector bundle moduli.
  • Matter: Two matter field multiplets in the 12 of $Spin(12)$ (considered exotic in this context).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that a complete proof of the stability of the constructed vector bundles is technically involved and has not been fully carried out. They also note that in the weak coupling case, the hidden sector contains exotic matter.

Future work could involve:

  • Detailed Phenomenological Analysis: Exploring the experimental implications of the two Higgs-Higgs conjugate pairs and the $U(1)_{B-L}$ symmetry, particularly concerning flavor-changing neutral currents and electroweak symmetry breaking.
  • Further Exploration of Hidden Sector: Investigating the implications of the hidden sector gauge groups and matter content for supersymmetry breaking and cosmology.
  • Constructing More Complex Vacua: Extending the methods to construct a wider range of realistic vacua and to explore scenarios with different numbers of generations or gauge groups.
  • Completing Stability Proofs: Rigorously proving the stability of the constructed bundles to solidify the theoretical foundation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Within the context of the E8×E8 heterotic superstring compactified on a smooth Calabi–Yau threefold with an SU(4) gauge instanton, we show the existence of simple, realistic N=1 supersymmetric vacua that are compatible with low-energy particle physics. The observable sector of these vacua has gauge group SU(3)C×SU(2)L×U(1)Y×U(1)B–L, three families of quarks and leptons, each with an additional right-handed neutrino, two Higgs–Higgs conjugate pairs, a small number of uncharged moduli and no exotic matter. The hidden sector contains non-Abelian gauge fields and moduli. In the strong coupling case there is no exotic matter, whereas for weak coupling there are a small number of additional matter multiplets in the hidden sector. The construction exploits a mechanism for “splitting” multiplets. The minimal nature and rarity of these vacua suggest the possible theoretical and experimental relevance of spontaneously broken U(1)B–L gauge symmetry and two Higgs–Higgs conjugate pairs. The U(1)B–L symmetry helps to naturally suppress the rate of nucleon decay.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{braun2005heterotic,
  author = {Volker Braun and Yang‐Hui He and Burt A. Ovrut and Tony Pantev},
  title = {{A heterotic standard model}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2005.05.007},
}
Figure