A Heteroassociative Learning Model Robust to Interference

Randa Kassab, Frédéric Alexandre2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel neural network model inspired by the hippocampus that enhances heteroassociative learning by incorporating "associated valence cells." This architecture significantly improves robustness against interference, a common problem in associative memory models, leading to more accurate recall and learning, especially in complex scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional associative memory models, like the Hopfield and Willshaw networks, excel at storing and retrieving patterns as stable states. However, they suffer from a critical weakness: "catastrophic interference." This occurs when the network is trained on too many patterns or patterns that are too similar, leading to corrupted memories or the inability to distinguish between them. This is particularly problematic in heteroassociative learning, where distinct types of information (e.g., sensory input and emotional valence) need to be reliably linked. The paper addresses this by proposing a biologically inspired mechanism to mitigate this interference, aiming for more robust and accurate heteroassociative learning.

Methods

The proposed model builds upon the classical binary Willshaw network for associative memory. It features two autoassociative networks (one for exteroceptive/sensory input and one for interoceptive/valence input) that are heteroassociatively linked through a layer of intermediate "valence cells." The key innovation is the introduction of "associated valence cells" organized into groups. These groups are designed to detect and resolve interference when conflicting valences are associated with similar sensory inputs.

Specifically, when the model detects a potential conflict (a mismatch between expected and actual valence), these associated cells can become active. They then inhibit previously active valence cells, effectively orthogonalizing the conflicting associations and allowing for new, correct associations to be learned. This mechanism is inspired by observed heterogeneities in the hippocampus. The model also incorporates a novelty-detection mechanism that triggers learning when new or significantly different inputs are encountered.

Datasets

The paper does not use pre-defined datasets in the traditional sense. Instead, it generates synthetic input patterns for its simulations.

  • Exteroceptive inputs: Random 150-element binary patterns with 6 active elements.
  • Interoceptive inputs: 3 binary cells representing positive, negative, and neutral valence states.

These synthetic inputs are used to create controlled training and testing scenarios to evaluate the model's performance under various interference conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Associated Valence Cells as Interference Resolvers: The core insight is that a dedicated mechanism (the associated valence cells) can actively detect and resolve interference in heteroassociative learning, rather than simply suffering from it.
  • Biological Inspiration for Robustness: The model's architecture, inspired by hippocampal heterogeneities, demonstrates how biological structures can provide solutions to computational challenges like interference.
  • Valence Overload is a Key Challenge: The paper highlights "valence overload" – associating similar sensory inputs with different valences – as a critical form of interference that traditional models struggle with.
  • Improved Recall with Partial Cues: The model's robustness extends to scenarios where recall is attempted with incomplete sensory information, suggesting its learned associations are more stable.
  • Reversal Learning Capability: The model shows an ability to adapt to changing associations, a crucial aspect of learning and memory that is often difficult for simpler associative models.

Key Results

  • Reduced Prediction Errors: The proposed model with associated valence cells significantly reduced valence prediction errors compared to a reduced model without these cells, especially when a large number of patterns were stored (e.g., ~17% error vs. ~30% error at N=100).
  • Effective Interference Detection: The model successfully detected interfering associations, leading to improved performance. For instance, after a second training block, the full model achieved near-perfect valence prediction, while the reduced model continued to make errors.
  • Robustness to Partial Cues: Even with up to 3 out of 6 active exteroceptive cues removed, the model maintained high accuracy in valence prediction, demonstrating strong pattern completion capabilities.
  • Rapid Adaptation in Reversal Learning: In discrimination and cue-context reversal learning tasks, the model quickly adapted to new valence assignments, whereas the reduced model struggled to unlearn old associations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Input Patterns: The paper acknowledges that the input patterns used in simulations are simplified (e.g., sparse exteroceptive patterns, fixed valence representation). Future work could explore more complex and realistic input data.
  • Pattern Overload Not Addressed: The experiments specifically avoided "pattern overload" (interference within autoassociative memories) by using sufficiently separated input patterns. A more comprehensive model would need to address both types of interference.
  • Biological Fidelity: While inspired by biology, the model is a computational abstraction. Further validation against a wider range of biological data and phenomena is suggested.
  • Information Processing Applications: The authors suggest that further exploration of this model's mechanisms could lead to more robust machine learning systems, particularly those that combine different memory processes for enhanced performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Best Paper Award
BibTeX
@misc{kassab2015heteroassociative,
  author = {Randa Kassab and Frédéric Alexandre},
  title = {{A Heteroassociative Learning Model Robust to Interference}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.5220/0005606800490057},
}
Figure