A global threshold model of enabling conditions for social tipping in pro-environmental behaviours – the role of sea level rise anticipation and climate change concern

E. Keith Smith, Marc Wiedermann, Jonathan F. Donges, Jobst Heitzig, Ricarda WinkelmannEarth 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a network-based model to understand how climate change concern and anticipation of sea level rise (SLR) can create "enabling conditions" for societal tipping towards pro-environmental behaviors. The study finds that many countries already possess sufficient concern, and extended anticipation of SLR can significantly lower the intervention needed to trigger widespread adoption of these behaviors, with the highest potential found in East Asian and Western Pacific Rim countries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The urgent need for climate change mitigation requires rapid societal transformations. Social tipping – where small triggers lead to large, qualitative shifts in behavior – is a promising mechanism for achieving this. However, understanding when and how these tipping points are reached is complex. This paper focuses on identifying the "enabling conditions" that make social tipping more likely, specifically investigating the interplay between public concern about climate change and the anticipation of future sea level rise (SLR) as key drivers for pro-environmental behaviors. The challenge lies in bridging the temporal gap between the long-term nature of SLR impacts and the immediate action needed for mitigation.

Methods

The authors employ a network-based threshold model, building upon Granovetter's model of collective behavior. This model simulates how individual actions can cascade through a social network to induce large-scale shifts. Key aspects include:

  • Network Dynamics: The model assumes individuals are connected in a network, and activation of pro-environmental behavior can spread contagiously.
  • Threshold Activation: Each individual has an activation threshold; if a certain proportion of their neighbors are active, they become active too.
  • Enabling Conditions: The model quantifies "enabling conditions" through two primary factors:
  • Climate Change Concern: Represented by the "potentially active population share" (p), derived from social survey data. Higher concern means a larger potential pool of individuals ready to act.
  • Anticipation of SLR: This is operationalized by considering the time horizon (T) over which individuals anticipate SLR impacts, linked to their proximity to coastlines and projected SLR levels.
  • Tipping Potential: The model calculates a "tipping potential" for each country, representing the likelihood of transitioning to a state of widespread pro-environmental behavior. This is analyzed across three regimes: uncritical (no tipping), critical (tipping possible with intervention), and tipped (system is in the pro-environmental state).
  • Monte Carlo Simulations: To account for uncertainties in network structures and parameters, the authors use Monte Carlo simulations to estimate tipping potentials and intervention sizes.

Datasets

The study utilizes several datasets:

  • Future Sea Level Rise Projections: Data from the MAGICC climate model v2.0, specifically for the RCP8.5 scenario, to estimate SLR until 2300.
  • Global Elevation and Population Data: SRTM30 near-global digital elevation data and gridded population data from the Socioeconomic Data and Applications Center (SEDAC) to estimate population exposure to SLR.
  • Cross-National Social Survey Data: Pooled data from six recent cross-national social survey programs (International Public Opinion on Climate Change, International Social Survey Programme, European Social Survey, PEW Global Attitudes Survey, Eurobarometer, and Life in Transition Survey) to estimate country-specific levels of climate change concern. Data from 66 countries with access to the sea were used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Concern is Already High Enough: In many countries, the level of climate change concern is already sufficient to create an "enabling condition" for social tipping. This suggests that the groundwork for societal transformation is already laid.
  • Anticipation Bridges the Temporal Gap: The anticipation of future SLR, particularly over longer time horizons, is crucial for lowering the intervention size needed to trigger social tipping. This is because it makes the long-term risks more salient and personal.
  • Complementary Roles of Concern and Anticipation: Climate change concern and anticipation of SLR work together. Concern makes the system more susceptible to interventions, while anticipation of SLR can act as a powerful trigger, effectively reducing the "kick" needed to initiate change.
  • Regional Clustering of Tipping Potential: The study identifies three distinct classes of countries based on their tipping potential, highlighting significant regional differences. The highest potential for social tipping is found in countries with high SLR exposure and high climate change concern, particularly in the Western Pacific Rim and East Asia.
  • Event-Induced vs. Bifurcation-Induced Tipping: The model distinguishes between tipping triggered by external events (event-induced) and tipping that occurs as a system parameter crosses a critical threshold (bifurcation-induced). While bifurcation-induced tipping is less likely on its own, it becomes more probable in regions with high SLR vulnerability and concern.

Key Results

  • Three Tipping Classes: The analysis categorizes countries into three classes:
  • Class I (High Total & Bifurcation Tipping Potential): Primarily Indo-Pacific countries (Indonesia, Japan, Vietnam, China) with high concern and SLR exposure, where interventions or extended anticipation can trigger tipping.
  • Class II (High Total, Low Bifurcation Tipping Potential): Countries in South America, Africa, and the Indian Ocean rim, with high concern but lower SLR exposure. Event-induced tipping is more likely here.
  • Class III (Low Total & Bifurcation Tipping Potential): North America and Europe, with lower concern and less SLR exposure, requiring larger interventions.
  • Intervention Size Reduction: For countries with higher concern and longer anticipation time horizons, the required intervention size to initiate social tipping decreases significantly, sometimes reaching zero for Japan and parts of China.
  • SLR as a Driver: While SLR alone might not be enough for bifurcation-induced tipping, its anticipation, combined with existing concern, creates a pathway for significant societal shifts towards pro-environmental behaviors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The model is a simplified representation of complex social dynamics. It assumes a straightforward conversion of SLR projections into "certainly active" populations and does not explicitly model costs associated with behavioral change.
  • Data Proxies: Climate change concern is used as a proxy for awareness of SLR risks, which may not perfectly align. Country-level data also masks within-country heterogeneities.
  • Focus on SLR: The model primarily focuses on SLR as the instigating factor, acknowledging that other climate impacts and external factors can also trigger tipping.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest future work should explore:
  • Global conditions that instigate social tipping.
  • Unique mechanisms in country- or region-specific case studies.
  • The role of short-term shocks (extreme events, political mobilization).
  • Identifying diverse circumstances for different social tipping elements.
  • Investigating deliberate interventions by policymakers and climate actors to foster positive social tipping.

Summary updated

Abstract

Effective climate change mitigation necessitates swift societal transformations. Positive social tipping processes, where small triggers initiate qualitative systemic shifts, are potential key mechanisms towards instigating the desired emissions mitigation. A necessary foundation for societal tipping processes is the creation of enabling conditions. Here, we assess future sea level rise estimates and social survey data within the framework of a network-based threshold model to exemplify the enabling conditions for tipping processes. We find that in many countries, the level of climate change concern is already sufficient, suggesting the enabling conditions and opportunities for social activation already exist. Further, drawing upon the interrelation between climate change concern and anticipation of future sea level rise, we report three qualitative classes of tipping potential that are regionally clustered, with the greatest potential for tipping in western Pacific Rim and East Asian countries. These findings propose a transformative pathway where climate change concern increases the social tipping potential, while extended anticipation time horizons can trigger the system towards an alternative trajectory of larger social activation for climate change mitigation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{smith2025global,
  author = {E. Keith Smith and Marc Wiedermann and Jonathan F. Donges and Jobst Heitzig and Ricarda Winkelmann},
  title = {{A global threshold model of enabling conditions for social tipping in pro-environmental behaviours – the role of sea level rise anticipation and climate change concern}},
  booktitle = {Earth},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.5194/esd-16-545-2025},
}
Figure