TL;DR
This paper addresses the critical issue of inconsistent terminology surrounding "interpretable AI" across technical and social sciences. The authors propose a unified global taxonomy and definitions to foster clearer communication, enabling better regulation and development of ethical AI.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The rapid advancement and widespread adoption of Artificial Intelligence (AI), particularly machine learning (ML) and deep learning (DL) models, have led to a growing demand for interpretability. However, the field suffers from a lack of standardized terminology, with terms like "interpretable," "explainable," and "transparent" often used interchangeably. This inconsistency creates confusion, hinders interdisciplinary collaboration, and complicates the development of regulations for ethical and reliable AI. The paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a unified taxonomy that can be understood and utilized by both technical developers and social scientists.
Methods
The core of this paper's methodology is a multidisciplinary approach involving a round-table discussion with 18 experts from eight different disciplines (including AI development, social sciences, law, ethics, and healthcare). This collaborative effort aimed to gather diverse perspectives on the terminology of interpretable AI. The authors then analyzed the etymology of key terms, reviewed existing definitions from the literature (presented in Tables 1, 2, and 3), and synthesized these findings into a proposed global taxonomy (Table 4). They also developed a framework for classifying interpretability techniques based on scope, model-agnosticism, and explanation type (Tables 5 and 6). Finally, they illustrated the application of their taxonomy through a case study in the medical domain.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "Tower of Babel" of AI Interpretability: The paper vividly illustrates how the same terms (e.g., "transparent," "interpretable") carry different meanings across disciplines, leading to significant misunderstandings. For instance, legal definitions of transparency often emphasize the receiver's understanding, while technical definitions focus on objective system properties.
- Beyond Technical Definitions: The authors emphasize that a truly global taxonomy must integrate perspectives from social sciences, law, and ethics, not just technical ML definitions. This is crucial for developing AI that is not only functional but also trustworthy and ethically sound.
- Etymology as a Guide: Analyzing the historical roots of terms like "interpretability" and "explainability" provides valuable context and helps clarify their nuanced meanings, moving beyond simplistic or interchangeable usage.
- A Unified Definition is Crucial: The paper proposes a core definition of interpretability: "the capability of assigning meaning to an instance by a translation that does not change its original validity." This forms the basis for a multidisciplinary definition of interpretable AI.
- Interpretability is a Social Contract: In social science contexts, interpretability is framed as a crucial element in building trust between humans and AI systems, fostering a "social contract."
Key Results
The paper's primary result is the proposed global taxonomy of interpretable AI, which provides unified definitions for key terms across technical and social sciences. This taxonomy aims to:
- Harmonize terminology: Facilitate clearer communication among lawyers, philosophers, developers, physicians, and sociologists.
- Enhance AI development: Support the creation of ethical and reliable AI systems by providing a common language for discussion and regulation.
- Demonstrate versatility: Show how the taxonomy can be applied across various domains, as illustrated by the medical case study.
The paper also presents classifications of interpretability techniques (Tables 5 and 6) based on scope (global vs. local) and model-agnosticism, offering a structured way to understand different approaches.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge that their proposed taxonomy is a "first solid step" and that further research is needed to achieve a global consensus. They highlight the ongoing challenge of reconciling complex deep learning models with legal requirements for explainability, particularly regarding human legibility. Future work should focus on:
- Refining the taxonomy: Continuously adapting and expanding the taxonomy as the field of AI interpretability evolves.
- Developing practical tools: Creating interpretability tools that are not only technically sound but also understandable and useful to a broad audience, including non-experts.
- Addressing the "transparency fallacy": Recognizing that sometimes users want the AI decision to not occur rather than just an explanation for it.
- Exploring human-AI collaboration: Investigating how humans and AI systems can work together effectively in providing and understanding interpretations, especially in high-stakes domains like healthcare.
- Bridging the gap: Further research is needed to define how effective human-machine cooperation can be established, requiring a strong foundation for collaboration between scientists and humanists.
Summary updated