A global map of orientation tuning in mouse visual cortex

Paul G. Fahey, Taliah Muhammad, Cameron Smith, Emmanouil Froudarakis, Erick Cobos, Jiakun Fu, Edgar Y. Walker, Dimitri Yatsenko, Fabian H. Sinz, Jacob Reimer, Andreas S. ToliasbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

Abstract

In primates and most carnivores, neurons in primary visual cortex are spatially organized by their functional properties. For example, neurons with similar orientation preferences are grouped together in iso-orientation domains that smoothly vary over the cortical sheet. In rodents, on the other hand, neurons with different orientation preferences are thought to be spatially intermingled, a feature which has been termed “salt-and-pepper” organization. The apparent absence of any systematic structure in orientation tuning has been considered a defining feature of the rodent visual system for more than a decade. Here, we revisited this question using new techniques for wide-field two-photon calcium imaging that enabled us to collect nearly complete population tuning preferences in layers 2-4 across a large fraction of the mouse visual hierarchy. Examining the orientation tuning of these hundreds of thousands of neurons, we found a global map spanning multiple visual cortical areas in which orientation bias was organized around a single pinwheel centered in V1. This pattern was consistent across animals and cortical depth. The existence of this global organization in rodents has implications for our understanding of visual processing and the principles governing the ontogeny and phylogeny of the visual cortex of mammals.

Introduction

For over a decade, neuroscientists believed the mouse visual cortex was a "salt-and-pepper" mess, lacking the organized orientation maps found in primates. In the visual cortex of primates and carnivores (like cats), neurons are organized into "iso-orientation domains"—neat neighborhoods where nearby cells all prefer the same line angles. In contrast, the rodent brain has long been described as having a shuffled organization where neurons with completely different preferences are intermingled at random. This apparent lack of structure was considered a fundamental divide in mammalian visual processing. However, by looking at the "big picture"—imaging nearly the entire visual hierarchy at once—researchers have discovered a global structure that was previously invisible at the local scale.

Methods

The research team utilized cutting-edge techniques to bridge the gap between single-cell resolution and large-scale mapping. Using a specialized "mesoscope," they performed wide-field two-photon calcium imaging across a massive $1800 \times 1800 \times 350 \mu m^3$ volume. This allowed them to record from tens of thousands of neurons across V1 and five surrounding higher visual areas (HVAs) simultaneously.

Imaging volume and stimulus characterization

To characterize the neurons, they presented mice with "pink noise" stimuli—dynamic, oriented textures—and monitored neuronal firing via GCaMP6s fluorescent sensors. To find the "hidden" map, they calculated local orientation bias within $50 \times 50 \mu m$ bins. While individual neighboring neurons might disagree (the salt-and-pepper effect), the average preference of the population in those bins revealed a clear, smooth gradient.

Key Insights and Results

The most striking discovery is that orientation bias is organized around a single "pinwheel" center located in V1. Orientation preferences rotate systematically around this point, and this map is not confined to V1; the gradients of orientation preference flow seamlessly across the borders into higher visual areas (AM, PM, RL, AL, and LM), suggesting a unified global architecture for the entire visual cortex.

Summary of global orientation tuning and spatial organization

Key findings include:

  • Local Noise, Global Order: The "salt-and-pepper" model is locally accurate, but this diversity exists on top of a consistent global bias. It is akin to a pointillist painting: random dots up close, but a clear image from a distance.
  • Columnar Consistency: The map was consistent across different cortical depths (Layers 2-4), indicating that this global bias is a fundamental feature of the cortical column in mice.
  • Orientation Motifs: Researchers found a predictable pattern: vertical preferences in the superior visual field, horizontal in the temporal field, and oblique in the inferonasal field.

Discussion and Future Work

While the study proves the map exists, it leaves major questions open regarding its origin (ontogeny) and function. It is unclear if this map is hard-wired during development or "learned" from visual experience, such as the specific patterns of optic flow a mouse experiences while running. Future research will be necessary to determine if this global map is a product of nature, nurture, or a sophisticated mix of both, and how it aids the mouse in tasks like detecting predators or calculating heading.

Summary updated

Abstract

In primates and most carnivores, neurons in primary visual cortex are spatially organized by their functional properties. For example, neurons with similar orientation preferences are grouped together in iso-orientation domains that smoothly vary over the cortical sheet. In rodents, on the other hand, neurons with different orientation preferences are thought to be spatially intermingled, a feature which has been termed “salt-and-pepper” organization. The apparent absence of any systematic structure in orientation tuning has been considered a defining feature of the rodent visual system for more than a decade, with broad implications for brain development, visual processing, and comparative neurophysiology. Here, we revisited this question using new techniques for wide-field two-photon calcium imaging that enabled us to collect nearly complete population tuning preferences in layers 2-4 across a large fraction of the mouse visual hierarchy. Examining the orientation tuning of these hundreds of thousands of neurons, we found a global map spanning multiple visual cortical areas in which orientation bias was organized around a single pinwheel centered in V1. This pattern was consistent across animals and cortical depth. The existence of this global organization in rodents has implications for our understanding of visual processing and the principles governing the ontogeny and phylogeny of the visual cortex of mammals.
BibTeX
@misc{fahey2019global,
  author = {Paul G. Fahey and Taliah Muhammad and Cameron Smith and Emmanouil Froudarakis and Erick Cobos and Jiakun Fu and Edgar Y. Walker and Dimitri Yatsenko and Fabian H. Sinz and Jacob Reimer and Andreas S. Tolias},
  title = {{A global map of orientation tuning in mouse visual cortex}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/745323},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure