A Generic and Flexible Regularization Framework for NeRFs

Thibaud Ehret, Roger Marí, Gabriele FaccioloWACV 2024

TL;DR

This paper introduces DiffNeRF, a novel regularization framework for Neural Radiance Fields (NeRFs) that leverages differential geometry. By applying geometric priors directly to the scene's representation, DiffNeRF significantly improves robustness and accuracy in challenging few-shot rendering scenarios, outperforming existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Neural Radiance Fields (NeRFs) have revolutionized novel view synthesis and 3D scene representation. However, training NeRFs typically requires a large number of input views to achieve high-quality results and accurate geometry. When faced with sparse or inconsistent data, standard NeRF models tend to overfit, leading to unrealistic interpolations and poor geometry estimates. Existing regularization techniques often rely on extrinsic cues or complex, data-hungry approaches. This paper addresses the challenge of making NeRFs more robust and accurate in low-data regimes by proposing a generic and flexible regularization framework grounded in differential geometry.

Methods

The core of DiffNeRF lies in applying differential geometry principles to regularize the NeRF's learned function. Instead of directly regularizing the rendered depth map (as in some prior works), DiffNeRF leverages the fact that NeRFs can represent infinitely differentiable functions. This allows for the direct application of differential operators.

The framework proposes two main types of regularization:

  • Depth Regularization: This involves penalizing the gradients of the rendered depth map. The authors derive a formulation that is compatible with automatic differentiation, making it easy to integrate into existing NeRF training pipelines. They also propose a simplified regularization loss that avoids the need for explicit camera projection matrices by assuming an orthographic projection for regularization purposes.
  • Surface Regularization (Mean and Gaussian Curvature): For models that explicitly learn a surface representation (like Signed Distance Functions - SDFs), DiffNeRF extends to regularizing surface properties. It defines regularization losses based on the mean and Gaussian curvatures of the learned surface, allowing for direct control over surface smoothness and shape.

A key enabler for this approach is modifying the NeRF's MLP to use activation functions like "softplus" (or similar) that result in continuous and infinitely differentiable functions, making differential operators naturally defined.

Datasets

The paper evaluates DiffNeRF on two standard datasets:

  • LLFF (Local Light Field Fusion): A dataset of real-world scenes captured with varying numbers of views.
  • DTU: A dataset of synthetic scenes with controlled lighting and viewpoints, often used for evaluating 3D reconstruction methods.

The authors note that their method is designed for few-shot scenarios, specifically testing with only three input views.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Differential Geometry as a Powerful Prior: The paper demonstrates that differential geometry provides a mathematically sound and elegant way to impose priors on scene geometry and appearance, leading to more robust NeRFs.
  • Direct Regularization of Implicit Functions: By treating the NeRF as a continuous, differentiable function, the framework allows for direct regularization of its properties (like depth or curvature) rather than relying solely on pixel-level losses or indirect cues.
  • Flexibility and Generality: The proposed framework is generic and can be applied to various NeRF-like models and different types of geometric regularization (depth, normals, curvature), making it a versatile tool.
  • Simplified Regularization for Practicality: The introduction of a simplified regularization loss that bypasses the need for explicit camera projection matrices makes the method more practical and easier to implement.
  • Few-Shot Performance Boost: The most significant insight is the dramatic improvement in performance when training with very few views, where traditional NeRFs struggle significantly.

Key Results

  • State-of-the-Art Few-Shot Performance: DiffNeRF consistently outperforms existing methods like RegNeRF on the LLFF dataset when trained with only three views, achieving better PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS scores. For instance, it improves PSNR by up to 1dB over RegNeRF without appearance regularization.
  • Smoother and More Accurate Depth Maps: Qualitative results show that DiffNeRF produces significantly smoother and more regular depth maps compared to RegNeRF, with fewer artifacts.
  • Improved Geometry Reconstruction: The method is shown to reconstruct scene geometry more accurately, recovering finer details in both foreground and background elements.
  • Competitive Computation Speed: Despite requiring gradient computations for regularization, DiffNeRF remains competitive in terms of speed, especially compared to methods that require regularizing unseen views.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: Higher-order regularization, such as normals regularization, can be significantly slower and more memory-intensive.
  • "Floaters" Artifacts: In some cases, particularly on the DTU dataset, the method can produce "floaters" – disconnected groups of points with non-zero density that can obscure parts of the scene. The authors suggest this is related to regularizing without data attachment terms for unseen views.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: The performance is sensitive to the choice of regularization weight and clipping value, requiring careful tuning.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring other differential geometry operators, investigating the impact of different activation functions, and further studying the trade-offs between regularization strength and detail preservation. They also highlight the potential for applying this framework to more complex scenarios like dynamic scenes.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{ehret2024generic,
  author = {Thibaud Ehret and Roger Marí and Gabriele Facciolo},
  title = {{A Generic and Flexible Regularization Framework for NeRFs}},
  booktitle = {IEEE/CVF Winter Conference on Applications of Computer Vision},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure