Abstract
In the light of exponentially increasing video content, video summarization has attracted a lot of attention recently due to its ability to optimize time and storage. Characteristics of a good summary of a video depend on the particular domain under question. We propose a novel framework for domain specific video summarization. Given a video of a particular domain, our system can produce a summary based on what is important for that domain in addition to possessing other desired characteristics like representativeness, coverage, diversity etc. as suitable to that domain. Past related work has focused either on using supervised approaches for ranking the snippets to produce summary or on using unsupervised approaches of generating the summary as a subset of snippets with the above characteristics. We look at the joint problem of learning domain specific importance of segments as well as the desired summary characteristic for that domain. Our studies show that the more efficient way of incorporating domain specific relevances into a summary is by obtaining ratings of shots as opposed to binary inclusion/exclusion information. We also argue that ratings can be seen as unified representation of all possible ground truth summaries of a video, taking us one step closer in dealing with challenges associated with multiple ground truth summaries of a video. We also propose a novel evaluation measure which is more naturally suited in assessing the quality of video summary for the task at hand than F1 like measures. It leverages the ratings information and is richer in appropriately modeling desirable and undesirable characteristics of a summary. Lastly, we release a gold standard dataset for furthering research in domain specific video summarization, which to our knowledge is the first dataset with long videos across several domains with rating annotations.
Introduction
Video summarization is essential for managing the deluge of modern video data, but "importance" is subjective and highly dependent on the domain. A surveillance video summary needs to highlight outliers (unusual movement), while a sports summary needs to capture specific high-action events like goals or wickets. Existing approaches often struggle with domain agnosticism—treating all videos the same—and the "ground truth paradox," where binary inclusion/exclusion labels fail to capture the multiple valid ways a video can be summarized.
Proposed Framework
We treat summarization as a subset selection problem, modeling the utility of a summary using a weighted mixture of different mathematical functions:
- Modular Functions: Capture the "importance" of individual snippets based on domain-specific features (e.g., detecting a ball or a crowd cheer).
- Submodular Functions: Ensure global characteristics like diversity (avoiding redundancy), coverage (representing the entire timeline), and representativeness.
- Supermodular Functions: Specifically used to ensure continuity, preventing the summary from feeling like a series of disconnected blinks.
Instead of binary labels, we utilize ratings-based supervision. Annotators rate segments on a scale, providing a dense signal that naturally handles multiple ground truths. We use a max-margin structured learning framework to learn the optimal weights for these functions for each specific domain.
Dataset and Evaluation
We introduced a new "gold standard" dataset featuring five domains: Birthday, Cricket, Soccer, Entry-Exit (surveillance), and Office (surveillance). Unlike standard datasets with short clips, our benchmark includes videos totaling hundreds of minutes with detailed rating annotations. To evaluate performance, we proposed a custom measure ($S_V$) that rewards high-rated segments, penalizes negative-rated ones, and accounts for redundancy, offering a more realistic assessment than standard F1 scores.
Results and Discussion
Our "Full" mixture model consistently outperformed several baselines, including Random, Uniform, and individual modular/submodular components. As shown in the performance table below, the Full model achieved the lowest ScoreLoss across all tested domains.
Key insights from our experiments include:
- Joint Modeling: Learning importance and summary characteristics together is significantly more effective than optimizing them in isolation.
- Domain Gap: Models are highly specialized; a model trained on "Birthday" videos performs poorly on "Soccer," validating the necessity of domain-specific weights.
- Efficiency of Ratings: Ratings provide a more robust training signal than binary labels, effectively bridging the gap between different annotator preferences.
Conclusion
This framework provides a robust path toward context-aware video summarization. While the current reliance on manual rating annotations for new domains presents a scaling challenge, future work in transfer learning and the integration of modern spatio-temporal features (like Video Transformers) could further automate and enhance the system's capabilities.
Summary updated