Abstract
This paper presents a distributed framework for robotic reference resolution in open-world environments. By utilizing a consultant-based architecture and the DIST-POWER algorithm, the system efficiently resolves linguistic references across heterogeneous knowledge bases. Experimental results demonstrate up to a threefold increase in processing speed compared to centralized approaches, while maintaining the ability to posit unknown entities.
Introduction: The Challenge of Distributed Knowledge
When a human instructs a robot to "Pick up the red ball in the kitchen," the robot must synthesize data from multiple sources. Traditionally, this has involved centralizing all knowledge into a single database. However, this approach faces two significant hurdles:
- Computational Bottlenecks: A central database becomes a single point of failure and a performance stress point.
- Data Heterogeneity: Different systems (vision vs. spatial mapping) use fundamentally different data formats (pixels vs. topological graphs). Forcing these into a unified schema is often inefficient and lossy.
Furthermore, robots must operate in an "open world" where they may encounter references to objects they have not yet perceived. A robust system must be able to "posit" or hypothesize the existence of these new entities based on descriptions.
Methodology: Consultant-Based Resolution
The proposed framework decentralizes knowledge across multiple Knowledge Bases (KBs), each managed by a specialized Consultant. These consultants act as interfaces, "advertising" their capabilities (e.g., a Spatial Consultant might advertise its ability to verify "in(X, Y)").
The DIST-POWER Algorithm
At the heart of the framework is the DIST-POWER algorithm, which treats reference resolution as a probabilistic best-first search. Instead of exhaustive calculation, the system uses lazy evaluation, only querying consultants for expensive spatial or visual checks when necessary to refine the search.
If a match cannot be found for a specific description, the system performs Open-World Positing, creating a placeholder entity in memory. This allows the robot to maintain a coherent internal model even when faced with incomplete sensory data.
Evaluation and Results
The framework was evaluated using synthetic benchmarks consisting of 40 pairs of KBs with sizes ranging from 20 to 160 entities, as well as a simulated robot trace in a complex environment.
Efficiency Gains
The primary advantage of the distributed approach is scalability. As the size of the knowledge base grows, the DIST-POWER algorithm maintains a significant performance lead over centralized alternatives.
In quantitative tests, the distributed mechanism achieved up to a 3x speedup. The system also demonstrated the ability to resolve highly nested references, such as "the ball that is in the room across from the kitchen," by efficiently coordinating queries between different consultants.
Discussion and Future Work
While the framework offers substantial improvements, the search process remains computationally intensive. Future work will focus on:
- Short-Term Memory: Limiting the search space to recently perceived objects to mitigate exponential complexity.
- Uncertainty Modeling: Incorporating Dempster-Shafer theory to better distinguish between ignorance ("I don't know") and negative certainty ("I am sure it is not").
- Cost-Based Heuristics: Prioritizing "cheap" constraints (like color) over "expensive" ones (like complex spatial relations) to further optimize the search order.
Summary updated