A Framework for Inferring Causality from Multi-Relational Observational Data using Conditional Independence

Sudeepa Roy, Babak SalimiarXiv 2017 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for causal inference on data spread across multiple relational databases. It tackles the challenge of inferring causal relationships when controlled experiments are infeasible, extending traditional methods to complex, multi-relational datasets by leveraging conditional independence properties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many real-world scenarios, understanding the causal impact of an intervention (like a new drug or policy) is crucial for making informed decisions. The gold standard for this is controlled experiments, but these are often impossible due to ethical or practical constraints. This leads to the use of observational data – data collected without direct intervention.

The "Neyman-Rubin potential outcome model" is a cornerstone of causal inference from observational data. A key assumption for this model to work is "strong ignorability," which essentially means that the treatment assignment and potential outcomes are independent of each other, given a set of observed covariates. The challenge is that in observational studies, this assumption is often hard to satisfy, and researchers try to include as many relevant covariates as possible.

This paper addresses a critical gap: most existing causal inference methods assume data is in a single table. However, real-world data is frequently distributed across multiple, interconnected relational databases (e.g., student enrollment, course information, and professor details). Joining these tables to create a single dataset can introduce new complexities and potentially violate assumptions. The authors aim to develop a framework that can perform sound causal analysis directly on these multi-relational datasets, understanding how causal relationships (specifically, conditional independences) propagate or change during joins.

Methods

The core of the paper is a formal framework for causal analysis on multi-relational observational data. The authors build upon the Neyman-Rubin potential outcome model and introduce concepts from database theory and graphical models.

Key techniques include:

  • Leveraging Conditional Independence (CI): The framework focuses on understanding how conditional independences, known to hold in individual base relations, propagate to the joined relation. This is crucial for satisfying the strong ignorability assumption.
  • Graphical Models: The paper utilizes undirected graphical models (like P-maps and I-maps) to represent conditional independences. The structure of these graphs on base relations is used to infer properties of the joined relation.
  • Database Operations: Concepts like natural joins are central to how data is combined. The authors analyze how different types of joins (e.g., foreign key joins, one-one joins) affect the propagation of CIs.
  • Graphoid Axioms: These logical rules for manipulating conditional independences are used to derive new CIs in the joined relation from those in the base relations.

The novelty lies in extending these statistical and graphical methods to the relational database context, specifically addressing the challenges posed by joins and multi-table data structures.

Datasets

The paper does not present specific empirical evaluations on real-world datasets. Instead, it uses illustrative examples and hypothetical relation instances to demonstrate its theoretical framework and theorems. For instance, Example 3.2 discusses a hypothetical "Students" dataset, and Example 3.4 uses hypothetical relations for "Professor," "Student," and "Teaches."

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Joins Can Break or Create Causal Relationships: A key insight is that simply joining tables doesn't guarantee that conditional independences observed in individual tables will hold in the combined dataset. This means causal assumptions need careful re-evaluation after joins.
  • Graphical Models are Powerful for Multi-Relational CIs: The paper shows how graphical models (P-maps and I-maps) on base relations can be used to infer conditional independences in the joined relation, offering a more structured approach than just statistical testing.
  • Join Attributes Matter: The role of join attributes is critical. If join attributes are part of the conditioning set for a CI, it can significantly influence whether that CI propagates to the joined relation.
  • Avoiding Joins Can Be Beneficial: In some cases, the framework suggests that it might be possible to perform causal analysis without materializing the full joined table, by focusing on specific relations and avoiding complex joins, which can improve efficiency and reduce variance.
  • Causality is More Than Correlation, Especially in Databases: The paper reiterates that correlation doesn't imply causation, a point that becomes even more nuanced when dealing with complex relational data where spurious correlations can easily arise from data integration.

Key Results

The paper presents several theoretical results:

  • Conditions for CI Propagation: Theorems and lemmas establish conditions under which conditional independences from base relations propagate to the joined relation, particularly for binary joins and specific types of joins (foreign key, one-one).
  • I-map Construction: For connected P-maps of base relations, the union graph is shown to be an I-map for the joined relation, providing a way to infer independences.
  • Negative Results: The paper also highlights cases where conditioning on join variables, while satisfying strong ignorability, is not useful for estimating causal effects (leading to an estimated ATE of zero).
  • Framework for Multi-Relational Causal Analysis: The overarching result is the proposed framework itself, which integrates database concepts with causal inference and graphical models to enable sound causal analysis on multi-relational data.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Undecidability of CI Testing: In general, testing conditional independence is undecidable, meaning the framework relies on inferring CIs rather than directly testing them from data.
  • Graph-Isomorphism Assumption: Some results rely on base relations being "graph-isomorph" (having a perfect map), which is a strong assumption. Future work could explore weaker conditions.
  • Directed Graphical Models: The paper primarily uses undirected graphs. Extending the framework to directed graphical models (Bayesian networks) for inferring CIs is a significant research direction.
  • Potential Outcomes and Missing Data: The challenge of dealing with potential outcomes (Y(0), Y(1)) which are inherently missing in observational data, and how this interacts with multi-relational joins, needs further investigation.
  • Satisfying SUTVA for Arbitrary Joins: The Stable Unit Treatment Value Assumption (SUTVA) can be violated by complex joins (many-to-many). Developing methods to obtain valid units from such joins is a key area for future work.
  • Weaker Notions of Independence: Exploring alternative notions of independence, like embedded multi-valued dependencies (EMVDs), might be more suitable for multi-relational data.
  • Complex Queries: Extending the framework beyond simple joins to more complex database queries (e.g., involving unions, aggregations) is a challenging but important future direction.
  • Empirical Validation: While the paper is theoretical, future work would involve validating the framework with real-world datasets.

Summary updated

Abstract

The study of causality or causal inference - how much a given treatment causally affects a given outcome in a population - goes way beyond correlation or association analysis of variables, and is critical in making sound data driven decisions and policies in a multitude of applications. The gold standard in causal inference is performing "controlled experiments", which often is not possible due to logistical or ethical reasons. As an alternative, inferring causality on "observational data" based on the "Neyman-Rubin potential outcome model" has been extensively used in statistics, economics, and social sciences over several decades. In this paper, we present a formal framework for sound causal analysis on observational datasets that are given as multiple relations and where the population under study is obtained by joining these base relations. We study a crucial condition for inferring causality from observational data, called the "strong ignorability assumption" (the treatment and outcome variables should be independent in the joined relation given the observed covariates), using known conditional independences that hold in the base relations. We also discuss how the structure of the conditional independences in base relations given as graphical models help infer new conditional independences in the joined relation. The proposed framework combines concepts from databases, statistics, and graphical models, and aims to initiate new research directions spanning these fields to facilitate powerful data-driven decisions in today's big data world.
BibTeX
@misc{roy2017framework,
  author = {Sudeepa Roy and Babak Salimi},
  title = {{A Framework for Inferring Causality from Multi-Relational Observational Data using Conditional Independence}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1708.02536},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1708.02536},
}
Figure