A forum on batteries: from lithium-ion to the next generation

Weijie ZhaoNational 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This forum brings together leading battery experts to discuss the current state and future of lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) and emerging next-generation battery technologies. While LIBs are approaching theoretical performance limits, significant room for improvement remains, alongside the development of promising alternatives like sodium-ion, lithium-sulfur, and solid-state batteries, driven by both academic research and industrial demands.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the evolving landscape of battery technology, acknowledging the immense success of lithium-ion batteries (LIBs), recognized by the 2019 Nobel Prize in Chemistry. However, LIBs are showing signs of slowing progress and nearing their theoretical performance limits. This raises critical questions about their future viability and the need for alternative energy storage solutions. The forum aims to explore these challenges, discuss the ongoing development and applications of next-generation batteries, and assess the current status of battery research and industry in China.

Methods

This paper is a transcript of a panel discussion, not a traditional research paper with experimental methods. The "methods" employed are those of expert discourse and knowledge sharing. The participants, leading battery researchers and industry professionals, engage in a moderated discussion to:

  • Evaluate current LIB performance: Analyzing gravimetric and volumetric energy density, cyclability, charge-discharge rates, temperature adaptability, and safety.
  • Identify challenges and opportunities: Discussing limitations of existing materials (e.g., Si anode expansion, high-Ni cathode safety) and exploring avenues for improvement.
  • Explore next-generation battery technologies: Examining the potential of sodium-ion, lithium-sulfur, lithium-air, solid-state batteries, and fuel cells.
  • Assess the industrial landscape: Discussing the gap between lab results and factory production, manufacturing challenges, cost considerations, and the importance of PLM (product lifecycle management).
  • Debate research directions: Highlighting the need for fundamental scientific understanding, application-oriented research, and fostering innovation in China.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LIBs aren't "done" yet: Despite approaching theoretical limits in some aspects, significant improvements in energy density, safety, and cost are still achievable for LIBs, particularly with materials like LiCoO2 and Li(NiCoMn)O2.
  • The "radar map" of performance: Industrial evaluation of batteries is holistic, not based on a single metric. A "radar map" of various performance indices (energy density, safety, cost, lifespan, etc.) is crucial for assessing a battery's suitability.
  • Bridging the lab-to-fab gap: A significant challenge is translating promising lab-scale results into reliable, cost-effective, and scalable industrial production. Consistency and quality control are key areas for improvement.
  • Beyond electrochemistry: The concept of "live batteries" or dynamic open energy-storage systems, inspired by biological organisms, offers a radical departure from traditional electrochemical storage, potentially overcoming energy density limits.
  • China's battery industry strengths and weaknesses: China boasts a strong industrial chain and large production scales for materials, but lags in intellectual property and advanced research methodologies like high-throughput calculation and in-situ characterization.
  • The importance of fundamental research: True innovation requires a focus on basic scientific problems, even if it means delaying publication, to foster "Innovated in China" discoveries.

Key Results

This forum does not present quantitative experimental results. Instead, it offers qualitative insights and expert opinions on the state of battery technology:

  • LIBs: Theoretical limits for LiCoO2 and Li(NiCoMn)O2 are ~274 mAh/g, with current records around ~205-210 mAh/g. Li-rich cathode materials have reached ~400 mAh/g in labs, far from their ~480 mAh/g theoretical limit. Si anodes have a theoretical capacity of ~4200 mAh/g but face volumetric expansion challenges.
  • Next-generation batteries: Sodium-ion and aqueous batteries are promising for large-scale storage. Solidification is a key direction for EV batteries. Lithium-sulfur batteries are viable for applications where gravimetric energy density is paramount.
  • Industrial demands: High performance (electrochemical, safety, mechanical, thermal), ease of manufacture (cost-effective, compatible with existing techniques), and PLM-oriented design (echelon utilization, recycling) are critical for new battery products.
  • China's position: While China leads in production scale for materials like LiFePO4 and separators, it faces challenges in patent ownership and product consistency for high-Ni cathodes and electrolytes.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Publication-oriented evaluation: The current academic system in China can incentivize publishing over deep, long-term fundamental research.
  • Focus on electrode materials: Auxiliary materials and the overall battery system design often receive less attention than electrode materials.
  • Gap in advanced research methods: China relies heavily on foreign-developed advanced research methods for battery science.
  • Industrialization challenges: Reproducing lab results at scale remains a significant hurdle.

Future Work:

  • Continued LIB improvement: Focus on developing high-Ni, low-Co or Co-free Li(NiCoMn)O2, and addressing Si anode expansion.
  • Development of next-generation batteries: Further research into sodium-ion, lithium-sulfur, lithium-air, solid-state batteries, and fuel cells, with a focus on overcoming their specific challenges (e.g., conductivity, energy density, safety, cost).
  • Interdisciplinary collaboration: Strengthening the connection between universities and industry, and fostering interdisciplinary communication through initiatives like new university majors in Energy Storage Technology.
  • Fundamental scientific understanding: Deepening the understanding of battery mechanisms through mathematical and physical models.
  • Application-oriented research: Focusing research efforts on solving specific, real-world challenges and application demands.
  • Innovative energy storage: Exploring entirely new forms of energy storage beyond traditional electrochemistry, such as "live batteries."
  • Intellectual property development: Increasing the generation of valuable patents and original innovations in China.

Summary updated

Abstract

The 2019 Nobel Prize in Chemistry was awarded to three pioneers of lithium-ion batteries (LIBs)-Prof. John B. Goodenough at the University of Texas, Prof. M. Stanley Whittingham at the State University of New York and Mr. Akira Yoshino at the Asahi Corporation of Japan, which is a great encouragement to the whole field. LIBs have been developed for several decades with the progress slowing down and their performances approaching some theoretical limits. On the other hand, new types of batteries or power systems, including solid-state batteries, sodium-ion batteries, lithium-sulfur batteries and fuel cells, are being steadily developed, offering new choices for divergent applications. In this panel discussion chaired by <i>NSR</i> editorial board member Huiming Cheng, battery experts gather to discuss the challenges and trends of LIBs, the developments and applications of next-generation batteries, as well as the status quo of the battery research and industry in China. Jun Chen Professor of the College of Chemistry, Nankai University, Tianjin, China Yunhui Huang Professor of the School of Materials Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China Hong Li Professor of the Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China Shigang Sun Professor of the College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Xiamen University, Xiamen, China Hongli Zhang Director of the R&D Institute of Battery, Gotion High-Tech Power Energy Co., Ltd., Hefei, China Huiming Cheng (Chair) Professor of the Shenzhen Geim Graphene Center, Tsinghua-Berkeley Shenzhen Institute, Tsinghua University, Shenzhen, China; Shenyang National Laboratory for Materials Science, Institute of Metal Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Shenyang, China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2020forum,
  author = {Weijie Zhao},
  title = {{A forum on batteries: from lithium-ion to the next generation}},
  booktitle = {National},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1093/nsr/nwaa068},
}
Figure