A fluid-structure interaction model accounting arterial vessels as a key part of the blood-flow engine for the analysis of cardiovascular diseases

Heming Cheng, Gen Li, Jifeng Dai, Ke Zhang, Tianrui Xu, Liuchuang Wei, Xue Zhang, Dongfang Ding, Jie Hou, Jianyun Li, Jiangping Zhuang, Kaijun Tan, Ran GuoFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper challenges the classical "Windkessel" model by demonstrating that elastic arteries act as a secondary power source, not just passive buffers. By developing a new fluid-structure interaction (FSI) model, the researchers quantify how strain energy stored in arterial walls actively propels blood, providing a mechanical explanation for the "J-curve" in cardiovascular mortality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, the medical community has relied on the Windkessel model, which views the heart as the sole pump and the arterial system as an elastic reservoir that merely smooths out pressure fluctuations. However, the math doesn't always add up: the heart’s power output (roughly 1–2 Watts) seems remarkably low to move blood through the entire human body.

Furthermore, clinical data often shows a "J-curve" relationship—where both excessively high and excessively low blood pressure increase the risk of cardiovascular events. Standard models struggle to explain the mechanical "why" behind this. The authors sought to bridge the gap between biomechanics and clinical practice by creating a model that accounts for the active role of arterial strain energy in organ blood supply.

Methods

The researchers combined experimental benchwork with mathematical modeling:

  • Ex Vivo Testing: They performed expansion and biaxial tensile tests on ten porcine aortic segments (ascending, proximal, and distal) to map the relationship between pressure, diameter, and stress-strain.
  • Simulation Platform: They built a custom "cardiovascular system experimental simulation platform" using a peristaltic pump and extensible elastic tubes to prove that stretching an elastic "vessel" directly increases cumulative flow.
  • Mathematical Modeling: They developed a formula for Strain Energy Density Increment (SEDI)—the energy stored in the vessel wall between the heart's contraction (systole) and relaxation (diastole).
  • FSI Coupling: Using Hamilton’s principle, they derived a new equation for average blood flow ($Q$) that integrates functional parameters (blood pressure, heart rate) with structural parameters (arterial stiffness, wall thickness, and diameter).

Datasets

  • Primary Data: Original experimental data derived from ten porcine (pig) aortas. Porcine vessels are standard proxies for human aortas due to similar mechanical properties.
  • Validation Data: The model was validated against established clinical statistical studies of healthy and hypertensive humans (e.g., Schutte et al., 2005; Lu et al., 2017).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Arterial Engine: The aorta isn't just a pipe; it’s a part of the "blood-flow engine." The heart provides the initial kinetic energy, but the strain energy stored in the deformed aorta is what pushes blood toward distal organs during the diastolic phase.
  • The SEDI Bridge: The Strain Energy Density Increment (SEDI) is the "missing link" that connects a person's physical artery structure (stiffness/thickness) to their functional health (blood pressure).
  • Mechanical Logic of the J-Curve:
    • If Diastolic Blood Pressure (DBP) is too low, the artery doesn't stretch enough to store sufficient strain energy.
  • If DBP is too high, the artery becomes over-stretched and stiff, losing its ability to store additional energy.
  • In both cases, the "second engine" fails, leading to poor organ perfusion.
  • Stiffness vs. Supply: Increased arterial stiffness (common in aging or atherosclerosis) directly reduces the contribution of strain energy to blood flow, forcing the heart to work harder or leaving organs under-supplied.

Key Results

  • Flow Prediction: The model’s calculated average blood flow for a healthy adult at rest (approx. 5.23 L/min) aligns closely with standard clinical measurements.
  • Hypertension Accuracy: When applied to hypertensive patients, the model's predictions deviated by only 3.6% from clinical data, suggesting high reliability.
  • Energy Storage: The ascending aorta was found to store the most strain energy and exhibit the highest elasticity compared to distal segments, confirming its role as the primary energy "booster" for the circulatory system.
  • Linear Approximation: The authors found that a linear approximation of the stress-strain curve is accurate within 3.8% for the physiological pressure range, simplifying the math for future clinical applications.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Laminar Flow Assumption: The model assumes laminar blood flow (Reynolds number ~1500). While generally true, it doesn't account for turbulence near diseased valves or stenotic (narrowed) vessels.
  • Linear Elasticity: While the linear approximation works for healthy ranges, it may lose accuracy in extreme pathological states where the non-linear behavior of collagen fibers becomes dominant.
  • Axial Deformation: The study focused on circumferential stretch and ignored axial (lengthwise) deformation, which may play a minor role in energy storage.
  • Clinical Translation: While the porcine data is a strong start, the authors acknowledge that further human clinical verification is needed to turn this model into a diagnostic tool for specific cardio-cerebrovascular diseases (CCVD).

Summary updated

Abstract

According to the classical Windkessel model, the heart is the only power source for blood flow, while the arterial system is assumed to be an elastic chamber that acts as a channel and buffer for blood circulation. In this paper we show that in addition to the power provided by the heart for blood circulation, strain energy stored in deformed arterial vessels <i>in vivo</i> can be transformed into mechanical work to propel blood flow. A quantitative relationship between the strain energy increment and functional (systolic, diastolic, mean and pulse blood pressure) and structural (stiffness, diameter and wall thickness) parameters of the aorta is described. In addition, details of blood flow across the aorta remain unclear due to changes in functional and other physiological parameters. Based on the arterial strain energy and fluid-structure interaction theory, the relationship between physiological parameters and blood supply to organs was studied, and a corresponding mathematical model was developed. The findings provided a new understanding about blood-flow circulation, that is, cardiac output allows blood to enter the aorta at an initial rate, and then strain energy stored in the elastic arteries pushes blood toward distal organs and tissues. Organ blood supply is a key factor in cardio-cerebrovascular diseases (CCVD), which are caused by changes in blood supply in combination with multiple physiological parameters. Also, some physiological parameters are affected by changes in blood supply, and vice versa. The model can explain the pathophysiological mechanisms of chronic diseases such as CCVD and hypertension among others, and the results are in good agreement with epidemiological studies of CCVD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cheng2022fluid,
  author = {Heming Cheng and Gen Li and Jifeng Dai and Ke Zhang and Tianrui Xu and Liuchuang Wei and Xue Zhang and Dongfang Ding and Jie Hou and Jianyun Li and Jiangping Zhuang and Kaijun Tan and Ran Guo},
  title = {{A fluid-structure interaction model accounting arterial vessels as a key part of the blood-flow engine for the analysis of cardiovascular diseases}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fbioe.2022.981187},
}
Figure