A Flexible Pipeline for Prediction of Tropical Cyclone Paths

Niccolò Dalmasso, Robin Dunn, Benjamin LeRoy, Chad SchaferarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Hurricanes and, more generally, tropical cyclones (TCs) are rare, complex natural phenomena of both scientific and public interest. The importance of understanding TCs in a changing climate has increased as recent TCs have had devastating impacts on human lives and communities. Moreover, good prediction and understanding about the complex nature of TCs can mitigate some of these human and property losses. Though TCs have been studied from many different angles, more work is needed from a statistical approach of providing prediction regions. The current state-of-the-art in TC prediction bands comes from the National Hurricane Center of the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), whose proprietary model provides "cones of uncertainty" for TCs through an analysis of historical forecast errors. The contribution of this paper is twofold. We introduce a new pipeline that encourages transparent and adaptable prediction band development by streamlining cyclone track simulation and prediction band generation. We also provide updates to existing models and novel statistical methodologies in both areas of the pipeline, respectively.

Introduction

Tropical cyclones (TCs) are among the most destructive natural phenomena on Earth. While the National Hurricane Center (NOAA) provides well-known "cones of uncertainty," their underlying models are proprietary and based on historical forecast errors. This lack of transparency makes it difficult for the broader research community to iterate on these models or adapt them to new data.

Furthermore, as climate change alters TC behavior, there is a pressing need for statistical tools that are "model-agnostic"—meaning they can work with various simulation techniques—to provide reliable, reproducible prediction regions for where a storm might travel. This research introduces a modular pipeline designed to decouple track simulation from prediction band generation, fostering transparency and adaptability.

The Prediction Pipeline

The proposed framework consists of two interchangeable stages:

  1. Track Simulation: Starting with the first 6–12 hours of a storm's life, the system uses generative models to simulate hundreds of potential future paths. The authors employ Autoregressive (AR) models to predict changes in bearing and speed, and Lysis models (logistic regression or kernel density estimation) to predict when and where a storm will dissipate.
  2. Prediction Band Generation: This stage takes the ensemble of simulated paths and creates a geometric "envelope" that should contain the true path with a specific confidence level (e.g., 90%).
The modular pipeline decouples track simulation from prediction band generation.

A key innovation in this pipeline is the distinction between pointwise and uniform coverage. While standard methods often focus on where a storm will be at a specific time (pointwise), this paper emphasizes uniform coverage—ensuring the entire trajectory remains within the predicted band. To achieve this, the authors introduce the $\delta$-ball method, which constructs a band by connecting a series of balls centered on the most "central" simulated paths, identified using statistical depth metrics.

Data and Experimental Setup

The study utilizes the HURDAT2 database from NOAA’s Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory. The dataset includes 1,008 tropical cyclones in the North Atlantic between June 1851 and November 2016. For the experiments, 702 TCs were used to train the bearing, speed, and lysis models, while 306 TCs were held out for testing and evaluation.

Results and Discussion

The $\delta$-ball method paired with AR simulation emerged as the top performer. While the goal was 90% coverage, the models fell slightly short in real-world testing, suggesting that the generative simulation models still have room for improvement in capturing the full variance of real storms.

Comparison of prediction band types shows the $\delta$-Ball method consistently outperforming pointwise alternatives in capturing storm trajectories.

Key performance metrics for the $\delta$-ball method included:

  • Pointwise Performance: The method captured a median of 88% of true test TC points.
  • Uniform Performance: The same method captured the entire path of the storm for 44% of the test cases.

As demonstrated in the performance analysis, pointwise methods like the "Spherical" approach (similar to NOAA's current style) performed significantly worse at capturing the full path compared to the uniform $\delta$-ball approach. This highlights that pointwise bands are intrinsically poorly suited for capturing the entire TC track compared to uniform methods.

Conclusion

This modular pipeline provides a foundation for more transparent and adaptable tropical cyclone forecasting. By separating simulation from band creation, it invites the integration of more sophisticated generative techniques, such as Deep Learning or Bayesian Gaussian processes. Future iterations of the pipeline could include additional data inputs like satellite imagery and sea surface temperatures, as well as global expansion to other oceanic basins where TC behavior differs from the Atlantic.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hurricanes and, more generally, tropical cyclones (TCs) are rare, complex natural phenomena of both scientific and public interest. The importance of understanding TCs in a changing climate has increased as recent TCs have had devastating impacts on human lives and communities. Moreover, good prediction and understanding about the complex nature of TCs can mitigate some of these human and property losses. Though TCs have been studied from many different angles, more work is needed from a statistical approach of providing prediction regions. The current state-of-the-art in TC prediction bands comes from the National Hurricane Center of the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), whose proprietary model provides "cones of uncertainty" for TCs through an analysis of historical forecast errors. The contribution of this paper is twofold. We introduce a new pipeline that encourages transparent and adaptable prediction band development by streamlining cyclone track simulation and prediction band generation. We also provide updates to existing models and novel statistical methodologies in both areas of the pipeline, respectively.
BibTeX
@misc{dalmasso2019flexible,
  author = {Niccolò Dalmasso and Robin Dunn and Benjamin LeRoy and Chad Schafer},
  title = {{A Flexible Pipeline for Prediction of Tropical Cyclone Paths}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1906.08832},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1906.08832},
}
Figure