A Fast and Practical Method to Estimate Volumes of Convex Polytopes

Cunjing Ge, Feifei Ma, Jian ZhangarXiv 2013 · OpenReview

Abstract

The volume is an important attribute of a convex body. In general, it is quite difficult to calculate the exact volume. But in many cases, it suffices to have an approximate value. Volume estimation methods for convex bodies have been extensively studied in theory, however, there is still a lack of practical implementations of such methods. In this paper, we present an efficient method which is based on the Multiphase Monte-Carlo algorithm to estimate volumes of convex polytopes. It uses the coordinate directions hit-and-run method, and employs a technique of reutilizing sample points. The experiments show that our method can efficiently handle instances with dozens of dimensions with high accuracy.

Introduction

Calculating the volume of a convex polytope—a shape defined by flat faces in $n$-dimensional space—is a fundamental problem with broad applications in economics, statistics, and linear modeling. However, exact volume computation is #P-hard, making it computationally prohibitive as dimensions increase. Current exact algorithms typically fail beyond 10 dimensions. While theoretical randomized algorithms have existed for decades, they often suffer from large hidden constants that hinder practical implementation. This paper introduces PolyVest, a tool designed to bridge the gap between theoretical complexity and practical utility by making high-dimensional volume estimation feasible.

Methodology

PolyVest builds upon the Multiphase Monte-Carlo framework, which estimates volume by decomposing a polytope into a sequence of nested bodies. The authors introduce several key innovations to enhance efficiency and accuracy:

  1. Coordinate Directions Hit-and-Run: Instead of standard hypersphere directions, PolyVest moves along coordinate axes during random walks. This reduces computational overhead by simplifying intersection calculations between the random walk line and the polytope faces.
  2. Point Reutilization: By sampling from the "outside in," PolyVest can recycle points generated for outer layers that fall within inner layers. This "outside-in" approach significantly reduces the number of new samples required.
  3. Rounding with Ellipsoids: To handle skewed or "thin" polytopes, the Shallow-$\beta$-Cut Ellipsoid Method is used to transform the polytope into a more "rounded" version, improving sampling efficiency.
  4. Split-and-Sum Verification: To verify accuracy in high dimensions where exact volumes are unknown, the authors split polytopes with random hyperplanes and compare the sum of the parts to the whole.
Comparison of volume estimation accuracy between simplified (rounded) and original polytopes.

As shown in the experimental data, the rounding (simplification) process significantly improves the accuracy of the volume estimation and reduces the standard deviation compared to the original, unrounded polytopes.

Experimental Evaluation

The authors evaluated PolyVest against synthetic benchmarks, including hypercubes ($2^n$ volume), sheared polytopes, and random polytopes. The performance was compared against VINCI, a standard package for exact volume computation.

Key Results

PolyVest demonstrates remarkable scalability. It successfully estimated the volume of a 40-dimensional cube in approximately 73 seconds. In contrast, VINCI's exact methods were unable to process cubes larger than 20 dimensions within a reasonable timeframe.

Comparison of PolyVest and VINCI performance across various polytope instances.

The "outside-in" sampling approach proved highly effective, sometimes requiring less than 10% of the sample points compared to non-reutilizing methods. Furthermore, the split-and-sum tests consistently showed error margins below 1%, with results falling within the 95% confidence interval in nearly every trial.

Conclusion

PolyVest provides a practical and efficient solution for high-dimensional volume estimation. By combining coordinate-based sampling with point recycling and ellipsoid rounding, it achieves a practical complexity of $O^*(mn^3)$. Future work will focus on optimizing the rounding overhead for extremely thin polytopes and extending the framework to other convex bodies with efficient membership checks.

Summary updated

Abstract

The volume is an important attribute of a convex body. In general, it is quite difficult to calculate the exact volume. But in many cases, it suffices to have an approximate value. Volume estimation methods for convex bodies have been extensively studied in theory, however, there is still a lack of practical implementations of such methods. In this paper, we present an efficient method which is based on the Multiphase Monte-Carlo algorithm to estimate volumes of convex polytopes. It uses the coordinate directions hit-and-run method, and employs a technique of reutilizing sample points. The experiments show that our method can efficiently handle instances with dozens of dimensions with high accuracy.
BibTeX
@misc{ge2013fast,
  author = {Cunjing Ge and Feifei Ma and Jian Zhang},
  title = {{A Fast and Practical Method to Estimate Volumes of Convex Polytopes}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1401.0120},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1401.0120},
}
Figure