A Economia Política da Política Ambiental: Uma Abordagem de Escolha Pública aos Instrumentos de Mercado

Cláudia SoaresRevCEDOUA 2000 · DOI

Introduction

In environmental economics, market-based instruments (MBIs) such as carbon taxes and tradable permits are widely regarded as the most efficient tools for achieving ecological goals at the lowest social cost. However, a persistent "efficiency gap" exists: governments worldwide continue to favor "command-and-control" administrative regulations. Bouwe R. Dijkstra’s work, The Political Economy of Environmental Policy: A Public Choice Approach to Market Instruments, investigates this disconnect by applying Public Choice theory to the decision-making processes of environmental policy.

The Efficiency Gap and Political Reality

The central puzzle Dijkstra addresses is why political practice deviates so sharply from economic theory. While economists focus on aggregate social welfare, political actors are driven by structural incentives that prioritize certainty, control, and the specific distribution of costs. Dijkstra argues that the rejection of MBIs is not a result of political ignorance, but rather a rational outcome of the competing interests of various stakeholders.

A Public Choice Framework

The research utilizes a Public Choice framework, treating political decision-making as a marketplace where interest groups compete to influence policy outcomes. Dijkstra identifies four key groups whose preferences shape the final policy:

  • Shareholders and Industry: Often prefer administrative rules that may act as barriers to entry or provide more predictable compliance costs.
  • Workers and Labor Unions: Primarily concerned with the employment effects and job security impacts of policy shifts.
  • Environmentalists: Historically favored direct regulation for its perceived moral clarity and "certainty" of outcome, though preferences have evolved toward technocratic cooperation.
  • Bureaucrats: May prefer complex administrative systems that require larger departments and more oversight authority.

The Two-Stage Decision Process

A significant contribution of Dijkstra’s model is the division of the policy process into two distinct phases: the selection of the instrument and the subsequent decision on revenue allocation. This distinction highlights that the political viability of a market instrument often hinges entirely on how the resulting revenue (e.g., from a tax) is redistributed among these competing groups.

Key Insights: Distribution over Efficiency

Dijkstra’s analysis, grounded in empirical data from the Netherlands, reveals several critical insights into the political economy of environmental regulation:

  1. Distributional Effects: Political actors care more about "who gets which slice" of the economic pie than the total size of the pie. Inefficient regulations are often preferred if they protect established players or obscure the true costs of compliance from the public.
  2. The Value of Certainty: Administrative measures offer higher perceived "controllability." Market instruments introduce price volatility, which can be politically damaging for regulators and costly for the regulated.
  3. Revenue as a Dealbreaker: The adoption of MBIs is rarely a standalone decision. Success depends on the simultaneous negotiation of revenue recycling or redistribution schemes. The complexity of this debate often leads back to simpler administrative defaults.
  4. Shifting Influence: The 1990s saw a shift toward more technocratic and cooperative approaches as industry influence grew, often leading to "pro-market" rhetoric that still favored administrative tweaks over fundamental market shifts.

Conclusion

By framing "inefficient" policy choices as rational equilibria within a political system, Dijkstra provides a robust explanation for the persistence of command-and-control regulations. The work suggests that for market-based instruments to gain wider acceptance, policy designers must move beyond simple efficiency metrics and address the complex distributional and institutional incentives that drive political decision-making.

This summary is based on the review by Claudia Soares (Catholic University of Porto) published in the journal CEDOUA (Year 2, 2000).

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{soares2000economia,
  author = {Cláudia Soares},
  title = {{A Economia Política da Política Ambiental: Uma Abordagem de Escolha Pública aos Instrumentos de Mercado}},
  booktitle = {RevCEDOUA},
  year = {2000},
  doi = {10.14195/2182-2387\_6\_8},
}
Figure