A dual-reporter system for investigating and optimizing protein translation and folding in E. coli

Ariane Zutz, Louise Hamborg, Lasse Ebdrup Pedersen, Maher M. Kassem, Elena Papaleo, Anna Koza, Markus J. Herrgård, Kaare Teilum, Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen, Alex Toftgaard NielsenbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel dual-reporter system in E. coli that simultaneously monitors protein translation and folding in real-time within single cells. This system enables high-throughput screening of protein variants for improved expression and stability, paving the way for more efficient protein engineering and structural biology studies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Producing functional proteins, especially heterologous ones, is crucial for biotechnology and pharmaceuticals. However, expressing these proteins in organisms like E. coli often leads to misfolding, aggregation, and degradation, significantly hindering their yield and utility. Current methods for assessing protein expression and folding are often time-consuming, require cell lysis, and are not amenable to high-throughput single-cell analysis. This gap makes it challenging to efficiently screen large libraries of protein variants for optimal expression and folding characteristics.

Methods

The authors developed a dual-reporter system consisting of two main components:

  • Translation Sensor: This system uses a translation coupling cassette. A strong secondary mRNA structure (hexa-histidine tag) is placed upstream of a stop codon for the gene of interest, followed by a ribosome binding site (RBS) for a downstream fluorescent reporter, mCherry. If the gene of interest is correctly translated, the secondary structure is unfolded, allowing mCherry transcription and resulting in a red fluorescent signal. Incomplete translation prevents mCherry expression. This system allows for one-to-one monitoring of target protein translation.
  • Protein Folding Sensor: This component leverages E. coli's natural heat shock response. Misfolded proteins trigger the heat shock factor RpoH, which in turn activates the IbpA promoter. This promoter drives the expression of an unstable GFP variant (GFP-ASV), leading to a green fluorescent signal. The intensity of the GFP signal is proportional to the amount of misfolded protein.

The system was implemented in modified plasmids and tested using flow cytometry for single-cell analysis. They also employed next-generation sequencing (NGS) for deep mutational scanning and computational tools (FoldX) for stability predictions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Simultaneous, Single-Cell Monitoring: The core innovation is the ability to track both translation and folding simultaneously and at the single-cell level. This bypasses the limitations of bulk assays and provides a much richer dataset for screening.
  • Correlation Between Translation and Folding: The system demonstrated a strong correlation between translation levels (measured by mCherry) and protein folding/solubility (measured by GFP). This allows researchers to identify variants that are both well-translated and properly folded.
  • Deep Mutational Scanning Power: The dual-reporter system proved highly effective for deep mutational scanning, enabling the identification of mutations that impact protein folding and stability, even those not predicted by computational methods.
  • Decoy Detection for Structure Prediction: The mutational data generated by the system can be used to score structural decoys, potentially aiding in protein structure prediction by identifying more native-like conformations.
  • Flexibility and Applicability: The folding sensor, based on the heat shock response, is generally applicable to various proteins without requiring a specific functional assay.

Key Results

  • The dual-reporter system was validated on five different proteins, showing excellent correlation between reporter signals and actual protein expression and solubility.
  • The system successfully identified protein variants with altered stability and folding properties through deep mutational scanning.
  • NGS analysis of mutant libraries showed good correlation with computationally predicted protein stabilities, but also highlighted mutations missed by computational tools.
  • The system demonstrated its utility in identifying mutations that either stabilize or destabilize protein folding.
  • The authors showed that the mutational data could be used to score structural decoys, correlating mutational tolerance with residue depth in protein structures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • GFP Comparability Across Proteins: The authors note that GFP fluorescence might not be directly comparable when investigating unrelated proteins due to potential differences in DnaK/DnaJ binding sites. However, for variants of the same protein, GFP output serves as a direct measure of stability.
  • Computational Prediction Gaps: While computational tools like FoldX showed some correlation, they did not always capture experimentally identified destabilizing mutations, suggesting the experimental system can identify novel insights.
  • Future Work: The authors envision the system being used for further improving computational stability predictions and for structure determination protocols by selecting stable protein variants. They also suggest that for enzymes, a downstream activity assay would be needed to ensure functional activity alongside improved stability. The potential to combine this system with directed evolution and deep mutational scanning for identifying variants with high expression and improved stability is highlighted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Strategies for investigating and optimising the expression and folding of proteins for biotechnological and pharmaceutical purposes are in high demand. Here, we describe a dual-reporter biosensor system that simultaneously assesses in vivo protein translation and protein folding, thereby enabling rapid screening of mutant libraries. We have validated the dual-reporter system on five different proteins and find an excellent correlation between reporter intensity signals and the levels of protein expression and solubility of the proteins. We further demonstrate the applicability of the dual-reporter system as a screening assay for deep mutational scanning experiments. The system enables high throughput selection of protein variants with high expression levels and altered protein stability. Next generation sequencing analysis of the resulting libraries of protein variants show a good correlation between computationally predicted and experimentally determined protein stabilities. We furthermore show that the mutational experimental data obtained using this system may be useful for protein structure calculations.
BibTeX
@misc{zutz2020dual,
  author = {Ariane Zutz and Louise Hamborg and Lasse Ebdrup Pedersen and Maher M. Kassem and Elena Papaleo and Anna Koza and Markus J. Herrgård and Kaare Teilum and Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen and Alex Toftgaard Nielsen},
  title = {{A dual-reporter system for investigating and optimizing protein translation and folding in <i>E. coli</i>}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.09.18.303453},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure