TL;DR
This paper presents a novel dual-band frequency synthesizer for China's CMMB mobile TV standard, achieving low phase noise across both the U-band (474-858 MHz) and S-band (2.6 GHz). The design cleverly reuses voltage-controlled oscillators (VCOs) for both bands and introduces a hybrid multi-modulus divider (MMD) for improved speed and power efficiency, crucial for handheld devices.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The China Mobile Multimedia Broadcasting (CMMB) standard requires a frequency synthesizer capable of operating across two distinct and widely separated frequency bands: the U-band (474-858 MHz) for terrestrial broadcasting and the S-band (around 2.6 GHz) for satellite reception. Designing a single, on-chip frequency synthesizer that efficiently covers this wide range while maintaining low phase noise and minimizing power consumption and silicon area is a significant challenge. Traditional approaches often require separate circuits for each band or complex frequency planning, leading to increased complexity and resource usage. This paper aims to address this by proposing a unified, low-phase-noise synthesizer that is compatible with CMMB requirements and suitable for power-constrained mobile devices.
Methods
The core of the design is a phase-locked loop (PLL) architecture that employs three voltage-controlled oscillators (VCOs) with selectable sub-bands. To cover the target frequency range, a clever frequency plan is devised: the U-band frequencies are handled by dividing the VCO output by four, while the S-band frequencies utilize a polyphase filter. This approach allows for the reuse of VCOs across both bands, reducing chip area and power consumption.
Key innovations include:
- Frequency Plan: The U-band VCO is designed to operate in a range (1896-3432 MHz) that encompasses the S-band frequency, enabling the same VCO to be used for both. For the U-band, a divide-by-4 operation is used, which also benefits phase noise performance. For the S-band, a polyphase filter is employed instead of division, which is more power-efficient for higher frequencies.
- Hybrid Multi-Modulus Divider (MMD): To achieve the necessary division ratios while balancing speed and power, a hybrid MMD is developed. It combines current-mode logic (CML) for high-speed operation and CMOS logic for lower power consumption. A novel D-latch with integrated AND function is introduced to overcome headroom limitations in the 2.8V supply voltage.
- Low Phase Noise Techniques: The paper addresses phase noise requirements by using both integer-N and fractional-N techniques. A third-order sigma-delta (ΣΔ) modulator is used, but a single-stage multiple feed-forward (SSMF) structure is chosen over MASH to mitigate out-of-band quantization noise and improve Vtune stability. A fast reset phase frequency detector (PFD) and charge pump (CP) are also implemented to minimize in-band phase noise and reference spurious signals.
- VCO Design: A digital split-tuned LC-VCO architecture is used, employing a bank of switched capacitors for coarse tuning and varactors for fine tuning. A novel switch design for the capacitor array is presented to isolate parasitic coupling and improve tuning range.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is based on measurement results from the fabricated chip.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Frequency Reuse for Dual-Band Operation: The most significant insight is the elegant solution of reusing the same VCO core for both the U-band and S-band by employing different output signal processing techniques (division vs. polyphase filtering). This is a crucial step towards miniaturization and power efficiency in multi-band RFICs.
- Hybrid MMD for Performance Trade-offs: The development of a hybrid MMD that leverages the strengths of both CML and CMOS logic demonstrates a practical approach to overcoming the inherent speed-power trade-offs in digital circuit design for high-frequency applications.
- Careful ΣΔ Modulator Selection: The choice of an SSMF structure for the ΣΔ modulator over MASH highlights a nuanced understanding of the trade-offs between in-band and out-of-band noise performance, which is critical for meeting stringent phase noise requirements.
- Switching Technique for VCOs: The novel switch design for the VCO capacitor array is a key enabler for achieving a wider tuning range and better isolation, directly impacting the synthesizer's overall performance.
Key Results
The fabricated dual-band frequency synthesizer, implemented in 0.35 µm SiGe BiCMOS technology, achieved the following:
- Frequency Tuning Range: 474-858 MHz (U-band) and 2.6 GHz (S-band).
- RMS Phase Error: Less than 1° integrated from 100 Hz to 10 MHz.
- Reference Spur: Less than -60 dBc.
- Power Consumption: 20 mA from a 2.8 V supply.
- Silicon Area: 1.17 mm² (excluding pads).
- Phase Noise: The paper shows that the phase noise specifications (e.g., -86 dBc/Hz @ 100 kHz and -106 dBc/Hz @ 1 MHz) are met in both integer-N and fractional-N modes.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations: The paper mentions that fractional-N techniques, while beneficial for in-band phase noise, suffer from quantization noise out of the loop bandwidth. This leads to integer-N mode being preferable for low frequencies with small division ratios. The performance comparison in Table 1 shows that while the phase noise is competitive, some other synthesizers achieve lower RMS phase error or smaller die areas.
- Future Work: The paper concludes by stating that the proposed frequency synthesizer has been applied to a CMMB receiver. Further work could explore optimizing the trade-offs between phase noise, power consumption, and silicon area for even more advanced mobile broadcasting applications, potentially by exploring newer process technologies or more sophisticated PLL architectures.
Summary updated