TL;DR
This study explores the use of 3D-printed hydrogel and silica gel boluses for photon radiotherapy, demonstrating their superior dosimetric performance and patient fit compared to traditional commercial boluses. These novel boluses offer a promising alternative for improving treatment accuracy and patient comfort in head and neck radiotherapy.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In radiotherapy, particularly for superficial tumors like those in the skin, nose, ear, or parotid gland, a "bolus" is often used to compensate for the dose deficit that occurs near the skin surface due to the build-up effect of high-energy X-rays. Traditional commercial boluses, while functional, often struggle to achieve a perfect fit on irregularly shaped patient anatomy. This imperfect contact can lead to air gaps, compromising the accuracy of the delivered dose and potentially reducing treatment efficacy. While 3D printing offers the potential for patient-specific boluses, the dosimetric benefits of using hydrogel and silica gel materials in this context for photon therapy have not been extensively studied. This paper aims to fill that gap by comparing the dosimetric performance of 3D-printed hydrogel and silica gel boluses against commercial boluses and a bolus-free scenario in simulated head phantoms.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-step approach to create and evaluate their 3D-printed boluses.
- Bolus Fabrication:
- 3D Printing: They used 3D printing technology to create shells for the boluses. These shells were then filled with either silica gel or hydrogel.
- Material Preparation: Silica gel was synthesized using α,ω-dihydroxypolysiloxane, ethyl polysilicate, and chloroplatinic acid. Hydrogel was prepared from methacrylic acid via ultrasonic polymerization.
- Customization: For patient-specific applications, CT scans of head phantoms were used to design virtual bolus structures. These designs were then converted into STL files for 3D printing using a MakerBot Replicator II printer. The printed shells were filled with the respective materials and allowed to cure.
- Physical Property Verification:
- Density and Depth of Maximum Dose (dmax): The mean density and dmax were measured for both silica gel and hydrogel boluses using a standard solid water phantom.
- Percentage Depth Dose (PDD) Curves: PDD curves were measured and compared to treatment planning system (TPS) calculations for both materials to assess their physical characteristics.
- Dosimetric Evaluation:
- Phantom Setup: Head phantoms were used to simulate radiotherapy for the nose, ear, and parotid gland. Four scenarios were evaluated: no bolus, commercial bolus, silica gel bolus, and hydrogel bolus.
- Treatment Planning: Intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) plans were created using the Pinnacle treatment planning system. All plans were normalized to the same prescription dose.
- Dosimetric Parameters: The following parameters were analyzed and compared across the different bolus conditions:
- Maximum dose (Dmax)
* Mean dose (Dmean)
* Dose to 2%, 50%, and 98% of the target volume (D2%, D50%, D98%)
* Homogeneity Index (HI): Calculated as (D2% - D98%) / D50%
* Conformity Index (CI): Calculated as (TV95% * TV95%) / (Target Volume * V95%)
* Volume of the target receiving at least 95% of the prescription dose (V95%)
- Dose Volume Histograms (DVHs): DVH curves were generated to visually compare the dose distributions for each scenario.
Datasets
The study utilized CT scans of head phantoms to create virtual bolus structures and simulate radiotherapy scenarios for the nose, ear, and parotid gland. These CT scans served as the basis for the treatment planning and dosimetric evaluation. No specific publicly available datasets were mentioned; the data was generated from phantom studies.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Superior Fit and Comfort: 3D-printed boluses, due to their patient-specific design, achieved a significantly better fit with the phantom surface, resulting in smaller air gaps compared to commercial boluses. This improved fit is expected to translate to better patient comfort and repeatability in clinical practice.
- Dosimetric Advantages: The study revealed that both silica gel and hydrogel boluses led to improved dosimetric parameters, including better homogeneity and conformity of the dose distribution within the target volume. This suggests that these custom-fit boluses can help achieve more precise and effective radiation delivery.
- Material Properties Matter: While both 3D-printed materials performed well, there were subtle differences. The hydrogel bolus showed slightly better uniformity in the nose treatment, potentially due to its density being closer to human tissue. However, in the ear treatment, the silica gel bolus performed better, possibly due to the hydrogel's tendency to deform under gravity in certain positions, leading to larger air gaps.
- Potential for Clinical Replacement: The findings strongly suggest that 3D-printed silica gel and hydrogel boluses are viable alternatives to current commercial boluses, offering enhanced dosimetric accuracy and patient-specific customization.
Key Results
- Reduced Air Gaps: 3D-printed boluses (silica gel and hydrogel) exhibited significantly smaller air gaps (maximum of 2 mm) compared to commercial boluses (maximum of 1 cm) when placed on irregular surfaces.
- Improved Target Coverage (V95%): For nose radiotherapy, V95% was significantly higher for silica gel (99.86%) and hydrogel (99.95%) boluses compared to the commercial bolus (98.39%) and the bolus-free scenario (87.52%). Similar improvements were observed for ear and parotid plans.
- Enhanced Dose Uniformity (HI): The homogeneity index (HI) was considerably lower for silica gel (0.06) and hydrogel (0.058) boluses in nose plans, indicating better dose uniformity within the target, compared to the commercial bolus (0.094).
- Improved Dose Conformity (CI): The conformity index (CI) was also better for the 3D-printed boluses (e.g., 0.79 for silica gel, 0.80 for hydrogel in nose plans) compared to the commercial bolus (0.72).
- Overall Superiority: Across nose, ear, and parotid radiotherapy simulations, the 3D-printed boluses consistently demonstrated better HI, CI, and V95% values than commercial boluses or the absence of a bolus.
Limitations and Future Work
- Hydrogel Deformation: The study noted that hydrogel can deform under gravity, particularly in the ear region, leading to larger air gaps and slightly inferior dosimetric results in that specific scenario. This suggests that the mechanical properties and stability of hydrogels need further improvement.
- Hydrogel Brittleness: The paper mentions that hydrogels can be friable and have poor mechanical strength compared to silica gel or silicone rubber.
- Long-term Use of Hydrogels: Traditional polymer hydrogels are often formed by chemical cross-linking, which can lead to uneven networks and fragility, limiting their long-term clinical application.
- Future Directions:
- Improving Hydrogel Properties: The authors suggest covering hydrogel surfaces with a polyol polyurethane membrane to prevent dehydration and exploring methods to increase their strength, such as nanocomposite or double-network hydrogels.
- Enhancing Biological Function: Further research is needed to improve the biological function of hydrogels, especially their affinity with cells or biological tissues.
- Direct 3D Printing of Bolus Materials: The ideal scenario would be to directly 3D print materials that meet all bolus requirements, simplifying the production process and promoting commercialization. The authors mention polycaprolactone (PCL) as a potential material for direct printing.
- Clinical Translation: While this study was conducted on phantoms, the next logical step would be to translate these findings to clinical applications.
Summary updated