A diverse virome in kidney transplant patients contains multiple viral subtypes with distinct polymorphisms

Asha Rani, Ravi Ranjan, Halvor S. McGee, Ahmed A. Metwally, Zahraa Hajjiri, Daniel C. Brennan, Patricia W. Finn, David L. PerkinsScientific 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Recent studies have established that the human urine contains a complex microbiome, including a virome about which little is known. Following immunosuppression in kidney transplant patients, BK polyomavirus (BKV) has been shown to induce nephropathy (BKVN), decreasing graft survival. In this study we investigated the urine virome profile of BKV+ and BKV- kidney transplant recipients. Virus-like particles were stained to confirm the presence of VLP in the urine samples. Metagenomic DNA was purified, and the virome profile was analyzed using metagenomic shotgun sequencing. While the BK virus was predominant in the BKV+ group, it was also found in the BKV- group patients. Additional viruses were also detected in all patients, notably including JC virus (JCV) and Torque teno virus (TTV) and interestingly, we detected multiple subtypes of the BKV, JCV and TTV. Analysis of the BKV subtypes showed that nucleotide polymorphisms were detected in the VP1, VP2 and Large T Antigen proteins, suggesting potential functional effects for enhanced pathogenicity. Our results demonstrate a complex urinary virome in kidney transplant patients with multiple viruses with several distinct subtypes warranting further analysis of virus subtypes in immunosuppressed hosts.

Introduction

Kidney transplant recipients must take lifelong immunosuppressants to prevent organ rejection. However, this "muted" immune system creates an opening for viruses—specifically the BK polyomavirus (BKV)—to reactivate and cause nephropathy, which often leads to the loss of the transplanted kidney.

The current clinical gold standard (PCR and cytology) is binary: it identifies if a virus is present but cannot distinguish between different subtypes or identify co-infecting viruses. This study addresses the gap in our understanding of the urinary virome: the total collection of viruses in the urinary tract, their genetic diversity, and how specific mutations might influence patient outcomes.

Methods: Beyond Targeted Approaches

Researchers moved beyond traditional targeted approaches by using metagenomic shotgun sequencing on urine samples from 22 patients.

  1. Sample Preparation: Virus-like particles (VLPs) were isolated via ultracentrifugation, and metagenomic DNA was purified.
  2. Sequencing: Samples were sequenced on the Illumina HiSeq 2000 platform.
  3. Structural Modeling: A key highlight of this study was the use of I-TASSER to create 3D models of viral proteins (VP1, VP2, and Large T Antigen). This allowed researchers to determine if genetic polymorphisms (mutations) physically altered the virus's "docking machinery."

The "Viral Swarm" and Virome Competition

The study revealed that patients weren't just infected with one type of BK virus; many carried a "swarm" of multiple subtypes simultaneously. One patient (B5) harbored 11 different BKV subtypes at once. Across the cohort, researchers identified 58 BKV, 31 JCV, and 108 TTV subtypes.

There appears to be a "turf war" in the urinary tract. In patients with high BKV loads, the Polyomaviridae family dominated. In patients without active BKV infection, the Anelloviridae family (specifically TTV) was more prevalent, suggesting these viral families might compete for the same cellular niches.

Relative abundance of viral families across BKV+ and BKV- patient samples, illustrating the dominance of Polyomaviridae in the BKV+ group.

Diversity vs. Dominance

Interestingly, BKV-negative patients actually exhibited higher viral diversity. When BKV reactivates, it seems to "crowd out" other viruses, leading to a less diverse but more dangerous virome. This was statistically confirmed through Shannon and Simpson diversity indices, which showed significantly higher values in the BKV- group.

Alpha diversity indices (Shannon, Simpson, and Evenness) comparing BKV+ and BKV- groups, showing significantly higher diversity in patients without active BKV infection.

Functional Mutations and Structural Impact

The researchers identified "non-conservative" amino acid substitutions in the VP1 protein. Because VP1 is the protein the virus uses to attach to host cells, these mutations likely change how infectious or aggressive a specific viral subtype is. Structural modeling of the Large T Antigen (a protein regulating viral replication) showed critical changes like a Leu > Pro substitution at position 1352, which could alter the protein's function during infection.

Limitations and Future Work

While the depth of sequencing was high, the study's small sample size (22 patients) means a larger cohort is needed to correlate specific viral "swarms" with long-term clinical graft survival. Additionally, as the methods focused on DNA, some RNA viruses were likely missed.

It remains unclear if these diverse subtypes are transferred from the donor kidney or represent a pre-existing "quasispecies" in the recipient that blooms under immunosuppression. The authors suggest that future clinical diagnostics should move toward sequencing-based approaches to identify high-risk viral subtypes before they cause irreversible kidney damage.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent studies have established that the human urine contains a complex microbiome, including a virome about which little is known. Following immunosuppression in kidney transplant patients, BK polyomavirus (BKV) has been shown to induce nephropathy (BKVN), decreasing graft survival. In this study we investigated the urine virome profile of BKV+ and BKV- kidney transplant recipients. Virus-like particles were stained to confirm the presence of VLP in the urine samples. Metagenomic DNA was purified, and the virome profile was analyzed using metagenomic shotgun sequencing. While the BK virus was predominant in the BKV+ group, it was also found in the BKV- group patients. Additional viruses were also detected in all patients, notably including JC virus (JCV) and Torque teno virus (TTV) and interestingly, we detected multiple subtypes of the BKV, JCV and TTV. Analysis of the BKV subtypes showed that nucleotide polymorphisms were detected in the VP1, VP2 and Large T Antigen proteins, suggesting potential functional effects for enhanced pathogenicity. Our results demonstrate a complex urinary virome in kidney transplant patients with multiple viruses with several distinct subtypes warranting further analysis of virus subtypes in immunosuppressed hosts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rani2016diverse,
  author = {Asha Rani and Ravi Ranjan and Halvor S. McGee and Ahmed A. Metwally and Zahraa Hajjiri and Daniel C. Brennan and Patricia W. Finn and David L. Perkins},
  title = {{A diverse virome in kidney transplant patients contains multiple viral subtypes with distinct polymorphisms}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1038/srep33327},
}
Figure