A diuranium carbide cluster stabilized inside a C80 fullerene cage

Xingxing Zhang, Wan‐Lu Li, Lai Feng, Xin Chen, Andreas Hansen, Stefan Grimme, Skye Fortier, Dumitru‐Claudiu Sergentu, Thomas J. Duignan, Jochen Autschbach, Shuao Wang, Yaofeng Wang, Georgios Velkos, Alexey A. Popov, Nabi Aghdassi, Steffen Duhm, Xiaohong Li, Jun Li, Luís Echegoyen, W. H. Eugen Schwarz, Ning ChenNature Communications 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have successfully synthesized and characterized a novel diuranium carbide cluster, U=C=U, encapsulated within a C80 fullerene cage. This breakthrough provides the first structural evidence of unsupported uranium-carbon double bonds, offering crucial insights into actinide chemistry and the potential for stabilizing highly reactive species.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Actinide chemistry, particularly the nature of metal-ligand multiple bonding involving uranium, remains a significant challenge due to the element's complex electronic structure. While metal-carbon double bonds (carbenes) are well-established in transition metal chemistry, unsupported uranium-carbon double bonds have been elusive synthetic targets. Previous attempts to synthesize such bonds have relied on ancillary ligands for stabilization, or have only been observed in low-temperature matrix isolation experiments, indicating their inherent reactivity. The authors sought to overcome this by using the internal cavity of a fullerene molecule as a "nanocontainer" to trap and stabilize a highly reactive uranium carbide cluster, specifically aiming to create and characterize unsupported U=C bonds. This research is also relevant to the development of advanced uranium carbide ceramics for nuclear fuel applications.

Methods

The synthesis of the endohedral fullerene UCU@I<sub>h</sub>(7)-C<sub>80</sub> was achieved using the Krätschmer-Huffman arc discharge method. This involves vaporizing graphite rods containing finely dispersed U<sub>3</sub>O<sub>8</sub> in an arc chamber under a helium atmosphere. The resulting soot was then purified using a multistage high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) protocol.

To obtain single crystals for structural analysis, the purified UCU@I<sub>h</sub>(7)-C<sub>80</sub> was co-crystallized with nickel(II) octaethylporphyrin (Ni<sup>II</sup>-OEP) through slow diffusion. The molecular structure was then determined using single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis.

To further validate the findings and understand the electronic structure, a suite of quantum-chemical calculations was employed, including quasi-relativistic density-functional (DF) approximations and ab-initio CASSCF(10e,120)-PT2 approaches.

Various spectroscopic techniques were also utilized for characterization:

  • High-resolution matrix-assisted laser desorption-ionization time-of-flight positive-ion-mode mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF/MS) to confirm the molecular composition.
  • Energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) to determine the elemental composition.
  • Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) to confirm the phase purity.
  • Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopy (specifically <sup>13</sup>C NMR) to probe the electronic environment.
  • Fourier transform infrared absorption (FTIR), Raman emission, and photoluminescence (PL) spectroscopies to investigate vibrational modes and electronic transitions.
  • Cyclic voltammetry to study the redox properties.
  • X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) to analyze core-level electronic states.
  • Magnetic susceptibility measurements to understand magnetic behavior.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fullerenes as Nanocontainers for Reactive Clusters: The study demonstrates the remarkable ability of fullerene cages, specifically I<sub>h</sub>(7)-C<sub>80</sub>, to encapsulate and stabilize highly reactive, unsupported uranium carbide clusters. This opens up new avenues for synthesizing and studying otherwise inaccessible species.
  • First Structural Evidence of Unsupported U=C Bonds: The paper presents the first crystallographically characterized example of unsupported uranium-carbon double bonds, existing as a bent U=C=U cluster within the fullerene. This is a significant achievement in actinide chemistry.
  • Unexpectedly Short U-C Bonds and Covalent Character: The X-ray diffraction analysis revealed unusually short uranium-carbon distances (around 2.03 Å), strongly indicative of covalent U=C double-bond character, challenging previous assumptions about uranium bonding.
  • Formal +5 Oxidation State for Uranium: Quantum-chemical calculations suggest that both uranium atoms in the UCU unit possess a formal oxidation state of +5. This is a relatively high oxidation state for uranium in such a bonding environment.
  • Bent U=C=U Geometry: The U=C=U cluster adopts a bent geometry (142.8°) rather than a linear one, which is unusual for such species and is attributed to the electronic interactions within the fullerene cage.
  • Unique Electronic and Redox Properties: The encapsulated UCU cluster significantly influences the electronic and redox properties of the fullerene, resulting in a much smaller electrochemical gap compared to other endohedral metallofullerenes. This suggests a strong interaction between the uranium cluster and the fullerene cage.

Key Results

  • Successful Synthesis and Crystallization: The researchers successfully synthesized and isolated UCU@I<sub>h</sub>(7)-C<sub>80</sub> and obtained single crystals of its co-crystal with Ni<sup>II</sup>-OEP.
  • Structural Characterization: X-ray diffraction revealed a bent U=C=U cluster with U-C bond lengths of 2.033(5) Å and 2.028(5) Å, and a U-C-U angle of 142.8(3)°.
  • Computational Support: Quantum-chemical calculations confirmed the structural parameters and suggested a formal +5 oxidation state for uranium.
  • Spectroscopic Confirmation: NMR, FTIR, Raman, XPS, and magnetic susceptibility measurements provided further evidence for the proposed structure and electronic properties, including the presence of unpaired f-electrons on uranium.
  • Redox Properties: Cyclic voltammetry showed a surprisingly small electrochemical gap of 0.83 eV for UCU@I<sub>h</sub>(7)-C<sub>80</sub>, significantly smaller than typical endohedral metallofullerenes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • EPR Spectroscopy Limitations: Attempts to resolve the electronic structure using EPR spectroscopy were unsuccessful, likely due to near-degenerate electronic states, cage shielding effects, and a large temperature-independent paramagnetism (TIP). Further studies are needed to fully elucidate the electronic properties.
  • Paramagnetic Broadening in NMR: The bridging carbon atom of the UCU cluster did not yield a detectable signal in the <sup>13</sup>C NMR spectrum, likely due to paramagnetic broadening effects from the unpaired 5f<sup>1</sup> electrons on uranium.
  • Further Investigation of Magnetic Properties: The "high temperature" magnetic data exhibited a large, temperature-independent paramagnetism (TIP) of unknown origin, which the authors suggest may be related to cooperative coupling within the solid and the low band-gap. Further research is needed to understand this phenomenon.
  • Exploration of Other Fullerenes and Clusters: The success with C80 suggests potential for encapsulating and stabilizing other reactive actinide clusters within different fullerene cages or other nanocontainers.
  • Understanding Bonding Mechanisms: While the study provides strong evidence for covalent U=C bonding, further theoretical and experimental work could delve deeper into the nuances of the bonding interactions, including the role of f-orbitals and the polarization effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Unsupported non-bridged uranium-carbon double bonds have long been sought after in actinide chemistry as fundamental synthetic targets in the study of actinide-ligand multiple bonding. Here we report that, utilizing I<sub>h</sub>(7)-C<sub>80</sub> fullerenes as nanocontainers, a diuranium carbide cluster, U=C=U, has been encapsulated and stabilized in the form of UCU@I<sub>h</sub>(7)-C<sub>80</sub>. This endohedral fullerene was prepared utilizing the Krätschmer-Huffman arc discharge method, and was then co-crystallized with nickel(II) octaethylporphyrin (Ni<sup>II</sup>-OEP) to produce UCU@I<sub>h</sub>(7)-C<sub>80</sub>·[Ni<sup>II</sup>-OEP] as single crystals. X-ray diffraction analysis reveals a cage-stabilized, carbide-bridged, bent UCU cluster with unexpectedly short uranium-carbon distances (2.03 Å) indicative of covalent U=C double-bond character. The quantum-chemical results suggest that both U atoms in the UCU unit have formal oxidation state of +5. The structural features of UCU@I<sub>h</sub>(7)-C<sub>80</sub> and the covalent nature of the U(f<sup>1</sup>)=C double bonds were further affirmed through various spectroscopic and theoretical analyses.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018diuranium,
  author = {Xingxing Zhang and Wan‐Lu Li and Lai Feng and Xin Chen and Andreas Hansen and Stefan Grimme and Skye Fortier and Dumitru‐Claudiu Sergentu and Thomas J. Duignan and Jochen Autschbach and Shuao Wang and Yaofeng Wang and Georgios Velkos and Alexey A. Popov and Nabi Aghdassi and Steffen Duhm and Xiaohong Li and Jun Li and Luís Echegoyen and W. H. Eugen Schwarz and Ning Chen},
  title = {{A diuranium carbide cluster stabilized inside a C80 fullerene cage}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-018-05210-8},
}
Figure