A dissolution-precipitation mechanism is at the origin of concrete creep in moist environments

Isabella Pignatelli, Aditya Kumar, Rouhollah Alizadeh, Yann Le Pape, Mathieu Bauchy, Gaurav SantThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2016 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Long-term creep (i.e., deformation under sustained load) is a significant material response that needs to be accounted for in concrete structural design. However, the nature and origin of concrete creep remain poorly understood and controversial. Here, we propose that concrete creep at relative humidity ≥ 50%, but fixed moisture content (i.e., basic creep), arises from a dissolution-precipitation mechanism, active at nanoscale grain contacts, as has been extensively observed in a geological context, e.g., when rocks are exposed to sustained loads, in liquid-bearing environments. Based on micro-indentation and vertical scanning interferometry data and molecular dynamics simulations carried out on calcium-silicate-hydrate (C-S-H), the major binding phase in concrete, of different compositions, we show that creep rates are correlated with dissolution rates—an observation which suggests a dissolution-precipitation mechanism as being at the origin of concrete creep. C-S-H compositions featuring high resistance to dissolution, and, hence, creep are identified. Analyses of the atomic networks of such C-S-H compositions using topological constraint theory indicate that these compositions present limited relaxation modes on account of their optimally connected (i.e., constrained) atomic networks.

Introduction

Concrete is the most widely used man-made material on Earth, yet predicting its long-term "basic creep"—the progressive deformation under constant moisture—remains a challenge for structural engineering. Traditional models have attributed this phenomenon to water movement (seepage) or the sliding of layers within calcium-silicate-hydrate (C-S-H), the primary binding phase or "glue" of concrete. However, these models often fail to align with experimental observations. This study investigates an alternative hypothesis: that creep is driven by a dissolution-precipitation mechanism at the nanoscale, where stress at grain contacts increases solubility, leading to material redistribution and subsequent deformation.

A fundamental insight of this research is the strong correlation between the chemical dissolution rate of C-S-H and its mechanical creep rate. Using Vertical Scanning Interferometry (VSI), the researchers measured the dissolution of C-S-H surfaces with sub-nanometer resolution. The data revealed that compositions most prone to chemical dissolution also exhibited the highest rates of creep. This suggests that the "flow" of concrete over time is effectively a chemical process mediated by stress-induced solubility.

Figure 1: (a) Vertical Scanning Interferometry (VSI) height maps illustrating the dissolution of a C-S-H grain over 70 minutes. (b) Dissolution rate as a function of the Ca/Si molar ratio across different pH levels, showing a distinct minimum near a ratio of 1.5.

Compositional Optimization and Atomic Topology

The study identified a "Goldilocks" composition at a Calcium-to-Silicon (Ca/Si) molar ratio of approximately 1.5. At this specific chemistry, C-S-H exhibits maximum resistance to both dissolution and creep. To explain this, the authors applied Topological Constraint Theory (TCT), which treats the atomic network as a mechanical truss.

  • Flexible Networks (Ca/Si > 1.5): These possess too few atomic constraints, resulting in "floppy modes" that allow for easy structural reorganization and high creep.
  • Stressed-Rigid Networks (Ca/Si < 1.5): These are over-constrained, leading to internal "eigenstresses" that destabilize atoms and increase dissolution rates.
  • Isostatic Networks (Ca/Si ≈ 1.5): These are optimally constrained—rigid enough to resist deformation but free of the internal stresses that drive dissolution.
Figure 2: (a) Shear strain accumulation over stress cycles for various loads. (b) Creep modulus (C) as a function of the Ca/Si molar ratio, demonstrating that resistance to creep is maximized at the isostatic composition (~1.5).

Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-scale approach to validate their findings:

  1. Micro-indentation: Measured the creep modulus of synthesized C-S-H samples.
  2. Vertical Scanning Interferometry (VSI): Quantified true dissolution rates at the nanoscale.
  3. Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: Used an accelerated relaxation technique to simulate long-term deformation, successfully reproducing experimental benchmarks.
  4. Topological Constraint Theory (TCT): Provided the theoretical framework to link atomic connectivity to macroscopic mechanical behavior.

Conclusion

By establishing that concrete creep is rooted in a dissolution-precipitation mechanism, this work provides a physical basis for long-term structural predictions. The identification of the isostatic Ca/Si ratio of 1.5 as an optimal state for durability offers a clear pathway for the development of next-generation, low-creep cement binders. Future work will explore how these findings translate to the complex environment of drying concrete, potentially solving the long-standing mystery of the Pickett effect.

Summary updated

Abstract

Long-term creep (i.e., deformation under sustained load) is a significant material response that needs to be accounted for in concrete structural design. However, the nature and origin of concrete creep remain poorly understood and controversial. Here, we propose that concrete creep at relative humidity ≥ 50%, but fixed moisture content (i.e., basic creep), arises from a dissolution-precipitation mechanism, active at nanoscale grain contacts, as has been extensively observed in a geological context, e.g., when rocks are exposed to sustained loads, in liquid-bearing environments. Based on micro-indentation and vertical scanning interferometry data and molecular dynamics simulations carried out on calcium-silicate-hydrate (C-S-H), the major binding phase in concrete, of different compositions, we show that creep rates are correlated with dissolution rates-an observation which suggests a dissolution-precipitation mechanism as being at the origin of concrete creep. C-S-H compositions featuring high resistance to dissolution, and, hence, creep are identified. Analyses of the atomic networks of such C-S-H compositions using topological constraint theory indicate that these compositions present limited relaxation modes on account of their optimally connected (i.e., constrained) atomic networks.
BibTeX
@article{pignatelli2016dissolution,
  author = {Isabella Pignatelli and Aditya Kumar and Rouhollah Alizadeh and Yann Le Pape and Mathieu Bauchy and Gaurav Sant},
  title = {{A dissolution-precipitation mechanism is at the origin of concrete creep in moist environments}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1063/1.4955429},
}
Figure