A discourse analysis of trainee teacher identity in online discussion forums

Brian Irwin, Alison HramiakTechnology 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses discourse analysis to examine how trainee teachers construct their identities in online discussion forums. It reveals that while trainees are comfortable with teaching concepts, they don't fully identify as teachers until later in their training, highlighting the need for pedagogical support in this identity transition.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Teacher education is fundamentally about transforming individuals from students into practicing teachers. This process involves a significant identity shift. However, understanding how this identity transformation occurs, particularly in the context of modern educational environments, remains an area needing deeper exploration. This paper addresses the challenge of understanding the situated identities of trainee teachers and how these identities are presented and developed within an online learning community, specifically through their communication on discussion boards during their placements. It aims to shed light on the linguistic and cultural markers that signify this evolving identity and the role of the tutor in facilitating this crucial transition.

Methods

The researchers employed discourse analysis as their primary methodology. This involved examining the language used in online discussion board messages to understand how meaning is created and how identities are constructed. Specifically, they focused on:

  • Lexis analysis: Analyzing the vocabulary, phrasing, and abbreviations used by trainees to identify patterns indicative of either "teacher discourse" or "student discourse."
  • Pronoun analysis: Investigating the use of pronouns like "we," "us," "they," and "them" to understand how trainees defined their community boundaries and who they considered "insiders" versus "outsiders."
  • Community boundaries: Examining how language use (particularly pronouns) demarcated the trainee community from other groups, such as qualified teachers and pupils.
  • Community culture: Analyzing the types of messages and interactions that were considered acceptable within the online forum, revealing the group's shared norms and values.
  • Critical discourse analysis: Looking at the tutor's role and influence on the trainees' identity development, including how the tutor's language and actions shaped the online environment and expectations.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 985 discussion board messages from 202 threads posted by 17 trainee teachers and one tutor on an Applied ICT Postgraduate Certificate of Education (PGCE) course. The messages were collected during placement periods and also from outside these periods, as long as they pertained to the community sense of identity. A subset of 49 messages from 17 threads was selected for detailed analysis to ensure representation across different forums, genres, and the inclusion of the tutor's voice.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual Identity: Trainees experience a dual identity, feeling comfortable with teaching concepts but not fully identifying as teachers until later in their training. This suggests a gap between knowing how to teach and being a teacher.
  • Community Boundaries: Pronoun usage ("us" vs. "them") clearly demarcated the trainee community, strongly distinguishing them from pupils and, to a lesser extent, from qualified teachers. This highlights a conscious effort to establish a unique group identity.
  • Emergent Teacher Lexis: Trainees gradually adopted teacher-specific vocabulary and abbreviations, indicating an absorption of professional language through taught sessions and school experiences. This lexis often merged with student lexis, creating a distinct "trainee teacher" discourse.
  • Supportive Online Culture: The online community fostered a culture of sharing and support, with a focus on mutual assistance and resource sharing, rather than conflict or critique. This served as a social glue, reinforcing community bonds.
  • Tutor's Subconscious Influence: The tutor wielded significant, often subconscious, power in shaping the community's lexis, genres, and culture. While generally encouraging, the tutor's language could inadvertently send mixed signals about trainee identity.

Key Results

  • Trainees primarily used the discussion boards for emotional support and information sharing, with a notable reliance on the forum for emotional support, which Swales' (1990) definition of a discourse community did not fully anticipate.
  • The trainees' language demonstrated a clear distinction between themselves and pupils (referred to as "them" and "they"), and to a lesser extent, qualified teachers.
  • The adoption of teacher lexis, such as "class control" and "behaviour management strategy," occurred later in the course, suggesting these concepts are more complex and learned over time.
  • The tutor's interventions, such as setting forum names and posting initial messages, helped establish expectations for message types and formality, influencing the development of specific genres like "Status Reports."
  • The study found that while the tutor's power was significant, it did not appear to negatively impact participation, suggesting a balance between setting discourse rules and allowing student contributions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sampling Limitations: The authors acknowledge that selecting a subset of messages, while necessary for manageability, means the analysis cannot be fully representative of all discussion board content.
  • Contextual Nuance: The analysis primarily focused on language, and while the authors acknowledge the importance of context, the online environment lacks non-verbal cues, making it challenging to fully capture contextual relevance. They suggest a balance between objectivity and context, potentially through multi-researcher analysis.
  • Generalizability: It is difficult to make broad generalizations about all trainee teacher discussion boards due to varying purposes and contexts. Further research could explore different cohorts and platforms.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest:
  • Corpus analysis to analyze larger datasets across different institutions and mediums for broader findings.
  • Genre analysis to more deeply understand the communicative conventions used by trainees.
  • Investigating trainee perceptions of technology's impact on their identity construction, as this was not directly discussed by the trainees.
  • Research into trainees who do not have access to online communication technologies to understand the role of technology in identity formation.
  • Exploring the dual role of schools as mentors and assessors and its impact on trainee identity.
  • Ensuring authentic assessments that mirror real teacher tasks towards the end of the course to solidify teacher identity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Teacher education involves an identity transformation for trainees from being a student to being a teacher. This discourse analysis examined the online discussion board communications of a cohort of trainee teachers to better understand the situated identities of the trainees and how they were presented online. Their discussion board posts were the primary method of communication during placement periods and, as such, provided insight into how the trainees situated their identities in terms of being a student or being a teacher. During the analysis, the community boundaries, language and culture were explored along with the tutor’s power and role in the identity transformation process. This involved looking at the lexis used by the students, the use of pronouns to refer to themselves and others such as teachers and pupils, the types of messages allowed in the community and the effect of the tutor’s messages on their communication. The research found that the trainees felt comfortable with teaching but did not feel like teachers during the course. Tutors and school teachers need to develop an awareness of the dual nature of trainees’ identities and help promote the transition from student to teacher. In the beginning of the course, trainees should be familiarised with teacher vocabulary and practical concepts in addition to pedagogical theory. Towards the end of the course, trainee identity as teachers could be promoted through the use of authentic assessments that mirror real teacher tasks and requirements.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{irwin2010discourse,
  author = {Brian Irwin and Alison Hramiak},
  title = {{A discourse analysis of trainee teacher identity in online discussion forums}},
  booktitle = {Technology},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1080/1475939x.2010.513767},
}
Figure