A direct link between active matter and sheared granular systems

Peter K. Morse, Sudeshna Roy, Elisabeth Agoritsas, Ethan Stanifer, Eric I. Corwin, M. Lisa ManningProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper establishes a direct, quantitative link between the mechanical behavior of dense active matter and sheared granular systems. By developing a mean-field theory and testing it with novel simulations, the authors show that these seemingly different systems exhibit equivalent critical behavior, suggesting a universal framework for understanding flow and failure in disordered materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Dense active matter, where individual particles generate their own motion, and sheared granular systems, where external forces are applied globally, have shown striking similarities in their mechanical responses, particularly near jamming or yielding transitions. However, a rigorous theoretical framework explaining this connection has been missing. Previous work has noted similarities in phenomena like giant number fluctuations, aging, and effective temperatures, but the underlying mechanism and the precise relationship between the forcing mechanisms (internal activity vs. external shear) remained unclear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a unified theory that explains how these different driving forces lead to similar critical behaviors.

Methods

The authors introduce a novel numerical protocol called Athermal Quasi-Static Random Displacements (AQRD). This method simulates the behavior of active particles by displacing them along random directions, mimicking the "self-propelled" nature of active matter. They contrast this with the standard Athermal Quasi-Static Shear (AQS) method, which applies controlled shear strain to granular systems.

A key aspect of their approach is the use of mean-field theory in infinite dimensions. This theoretical framework allows for exact solutions and provides a benchmark for understanding the behavior of complex systems. They derive predictions for how the correlation length of the applied forces (whether from shear or random displacements) influences the system's response.

To test these predictions, they perform 2D simulations of soft Hertzian spheres. They systematically vary the correlation length of the random displacement fields in AQRD, comparing the results to AQS simulations. They also introduce Athermal Quasi-Static Random Forcing (AQRF) as a stress-controlled analogue to AQRD, which is more directly comparable to active matter simulations with zero rotational noise.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations of model systems.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shear as a Special Case of Random Forcing: The most significant insight is that simple shear, a highly correlated displacement field, can be viewed as a specific instance of a broader class of random displacement fields. This fundamentally reframes our understanding of how external forces drive disordered materials.
  • Universal Scaling Behavior: The critical behavior of both active matter (simulated via AQRD/AQRF) and sheared granular systems (via AQS) is shown to follow the same scaling laws, particularly in their avalanche statistics. This suggests that the underlying energy landscape and the mechanisms of failure are similar, regardless of the driving force.
  • Correlation Length is Key: The correlation length of the applied force field (whether shear or random displacements) is identified as the crucial parameter that dictates the prefactors of the scaling laws, such as the shear modulus. Shorter correlation lengths lead to stiffer materials, while longer correlation lengths (like shear) result in more "ductile" behavior.
  • Predictive Power of Mean-Field Theory: The mean-field theory in infinite dimensions provides remarkably accurate predictions for the behavior of these systems, even in lower dimensions. This highlights the power of theoretical frameworks in understanding complex emergent phenomena.

Key Results

  • Equivalence in Critical Behavior: AQRD and AQS simulations show identical scaling exponents for avalanche statistics (stress drops and strain intervals between rearrangements) and local moduli.
  • Prefactor Dependence on Correlation Length: The prefactors of these scaling laws, particularly the elastic modulus, exhibit a power-law dependence on the correlation length of the applied field, consistent with mean-field predictions.
  • AQRD as a Valid Proxy: AQRD and AQRF methods accurately capture the dynamics of dense active matter in the limit of zero rotational and self-propulsion velocity, respectively, validating their use for studying active systems.
  • Collapse of Simulation Data: By scaling the AQRD data with a factor derived from the correlation length and initial modulus ratio, the authors achieve a quantitative collapse of stress-strain curves and avalanche distributions onto those from AQS simulations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low-Dimensional Deviations: While mean-field predictions are surprisingly accurate in low dimensions, quantitative agreement is not always achieved, particularly for smaller correlation lengths. The authors suggest that in low dimensions, the rescaling cannot be solely attributed to the variance of local strains.
  • Finite Correlation Length Effects: The study acknowledges that for very large correlation lengths (approaching the system size), the behavior becomes more specialized, with simple shear being a specific case.
  • Future Work: The authors propose several avenues for future research:
  • Investigating the effect of small but finite particle velocities and rotational noise on the equivalence between active and sheared systems.
  • Exploring the spatial structure and nature of the yielding transition under AQRD, and whether it falls into universality classes like the Random Field Ising Model.
  • Quantifying the output displacement fields and their correlation lengths in response to input fields.
  • Studying the behavior of brittle vs. ductile glasses under AQRD and comparing it to AQS.
  • Developing actuated solids and predicting emergent phenomena in active matter systems using this unified framework.

Summary updated

Abstract

The similarity in mechanical properties of dense active matter and sheared amorphous solids has been noted in recent years without a rigorous examination of the underlying mechanism. We develop a mean-field model that predicts that their critical behavior-as measured by their avalanche statistics-should be equivalent in infinite dimensions up to a rescaling factor that depends on the correlation length of the applied field. We test these predictions in two dimensions using a numerical protocol, termed "athermal quasistatic random displacement," and find that these mean-field predictions are surprisingly accurate in low dimensions. We identify a general class of perturbations that smoothly interpolates between the uncorrelated localized forces that occur in the high-persistence limit of dense active matter and system-spanning correlated displacements that occur under applied shear. These results suggest a universal framework for predicting flow, deformation, and failure in active and sheared disordered materials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{morse2021direct,
  author = {Peter K. Morse and Sudeshna Roy and Elisabeth Agoritsas and Ethan Stanifer and Eric I. Corwin and M. Lisa Manning},
  title = {{A direct link between active matter and sheared granular systems}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2019909118},
}
Figure