A Direct Brain-to-Brain Interface in Humans

Rajesh P. N. Rao, Andrea Stocco, Matthew Bryan, Devapratim Sarma, Tiffany M. Youngquist, Joseph Wu, Chantel S. PratPLoS 2014 · DOI

Abstract

We describe the first direct brain-to-brain interface (BBI) in humans and present results from experiments involving six different subjects. Our non-invasive interface combines electroencephalography (EEG) for recording brain signals with transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) for delivering information to the brain. We illustrate our method using a visuomotor task in which two humans must cooperate through direct brain-to-brain communication to achieve a desired goal in a computer game. The BBI detects motor imagery in EEG signals recorded from one subject (the "sender") and transmits this information over the internet to the motor cortex region of a second subject (the "receiver"). This allows the sender to cause a desired motor response in the receiver (a press on a touchpad) via TMS. Our results provide evidence for a rudimentary form of direct information transmission from one human brain to another using non-invasive means.

Introduction

Human communication has historically been limited by the "translation" problem: the need to convert complex internal states into language or symbols, a process that is inherently slow and lossy. While Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCIs) have bridged the gap between humans and machines, direct human-to-human neural communication has remained largely in the realm of science fiction or invasive animal studies. This research presents a non-invasive human-to-human BBI that allows for real-time cooperation, bypassing traditional sensory channels.

System Architecture and Methodology

The researchers developed a closed-loop system linking two participants—a Sender and a Receiver—located in separate buildings.

  1. The Sender (EEG): The Sender wears an EEG cap and watches a video game. To initiate an action, they engage in motor imagery (imagining moving their right hand). This suppresses "mu" wave activity (8–12 Hz), which the system decodes as a "Fire" command.
  2. Transmission: This command is transmitted via standard HTTP protocol over the internet to the Receiver’s location.
  3. The Receiver (TMS): The Receiver wears a TMS coil positioned over the motor cortex. Upon receiving the signal, the coil delivers a pulse that triggers an involuntary jerk in the Receiver's right hand, causing them to strike a touchpad and execute the action in the game.
System architecture of the BBI linking Sender (EEG) to Receiver (TMS) via the internet.

The Cooperative Visuomotor Task

The interface was tested using a game where participants had to defend a city from incoming rockets. The Sender could see the game state but had no physical way to interact with it. The Receiver had their hand on the firing mechanism but could not see the game screen. Success required the Sender to accurately time their motor imagery and the system to successfully trigger the Receiver's physical response.

The computer game interface used for the cooperative visuomotor task, showing the city, cannon, and incoming rocket.

Key Results and Insights

The study involved three dyads (six participants total). Performance was evaluated based on accuracy and information transfer rates:

  • Accuracy: Success rates varied significantly between pairs. Pair 1 achieved a high success rate, destroying 83.3% of rockets. Pairs 2 and 3 saw lower success (25% and 37.5%), primarily due to the Senders' difficulty in consistently modulating their EEG signals. This suggests that BBI operation is a skill that requires learning and practice.
  • Information Transfer: The system successfully transferred between 4 and 13 bits of information per experimental block.
  • Control Proof: To ensure the results were not due to chance or external cues (like the sound of the TMS coil), control blocks were conducted where the coil was misaligned. In these trials, the hit rate was 0%, confirming the communication was purely neural.
  • Latency and Consciousness: The transmission from the Sender's brain to the Receiver's physical action took approximately 650 milliseconds. Notably, the Receiver’s hand often moved before they were consciously aware of the intent to move, demonstrating the interface's ability to bypass conscious processing.

Discussion and Future Outlook

While this rudimentary link is currently limited to a single binary bit (Fire/Don't Fire), it proves the feasibility of non-invasive human-to-human neural communication. Future work aims to increase bandwidth and explore more precise stimulation methods, such as Focused Ultrasound (FUS), to target deeper brain regions. The researchers also envision scaling the system to "one-to-many" or "many-to-one" configurations, potentially allowing for collective neural decision-making and collaboration.

Summary updated

Abstract

We describe the first direct brain-to-brain interface in humans and present results from experiments involving six different subjects. Our non-invasive interface, demonstrated originally in August 2013, combines electroencephalography (EEG) for recording brain signals with transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) for delivering information to the brain. We illustrate our method using a visuomotor task in which two humans must cooperate through direct brain-to-brain communication to achieve a desired goal in a computer game. The brain-to-brain interface detects motor imagery in EEG signals recorded from one subject (the "sender") and transmits this information over the internet to the motor cortex region of a second subject (the "receiver"). This allows the sender to cause a desired motor response in the receiver (a press on a touchpad) via TMS. We quantify the performance of the brain-to-brain interface in terms of the amount of information transmitted as well as the accuracies attained in (1) decoding the sender's signals, (2) generating a motor response from the receiver upon stimulation, and (3) achieving the overall goal in the cooperative visuomotor task. Our results provide evidence for a rudimentary form of direct information transmission from one human brain to another using non-invasive means.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rao2014direct,
  author = {Rajesh P. N. Rao and Andrea Stocco and Matthew Bryan and Devapratim Sarma and Tiffany M. Youngquist and Joseph Wu and Chantel S. Prat},
  title = {{A Direct Brain-to-Brain Interface in Humans}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0111332},
}
Figure