A different mechanism of C-type inactivation in the Kv-like KcsA mutant E71V

Ahmed Rohaim, Bram J. A. Vermeulen, Jing Li, Felix Kümmerer, Federico Napoli, Lydia Blachowicz, João Medeiros‐Silva, Benoı̂t Roux, Markus WeingarthbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that a key mutation (E71V) in the KcsA potassium channel, mimicking a common feature in human Kv channels, alters the mechanism of C-type inactivation. Instead of the typical filter constriction seen in wild-type KcsA, the E71V mutant exhibits a narrowed and rigidified filter, suggesting that the surrounding molecular environment dictates distinct inactivation pathways.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Voltage-gated potassium (Kv) channels are crucial for electrical signaling in neurons and heart cells, and their function is regulated by a process called C-type inactivation. This inactivation involves the channel's selectivity filter adopting a non-conductive conformation, which is vital for controlling the flow of potassium ions. While the bacterial KcsA channel has served as a model for understanding this process, its selectivity filter constricts and is stabilized by water molecules under inactivating conditions. However, Kv channels have a different molecular environment around the filter, particularly a nonpolar valine at position 71 (instead of glutamic acid in KcsA), which is conserved across many Kv channels. This raises a fundamental question: does this structural difference lead to a different mechanism of C-type inactivation in Kv channels compared to KcsA? Understanding this is critical for human health, as C-type inactivation defects are linked to neurological disorders.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to investigate the E71V KcsA mutant:

  • X-ray Crystallography: They determined the high-resolution structures of the E71V mutant in both closed and open gate states, providing snapshots of the channel's conformation.
  • Solid-State Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (ssNMR): This technique allowed them to study the channel's structure and dynamics in a more biologically relevant membrane environment, under various conditions (conductive and inactivated).
  • Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: These simulations were used to explore the conformational landscape accessible to the E71V mutant, including the possibility of the canonical constricted state and the influence of different ions.
  • Barium Binding Studies: Barium ions were used as probes to further differentiate the binding sites and conformational states of the E71V mutant compared to wild-type KcsA.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • E71V Mutation Alters Inactivation Mechanism: The most striking finding is that the E71V mutation prevents the formation of the characteristic constricted selectivity filter seen in wild-type KcsA under inactivating conditions.
  • Narrowing and Rigidification, Not Constriction: Instead of constriction, the E71V mutant's filter adopts a conformation that is slightly narrowed and rigidified along its entire length.
  • Absence of Inactivating Water: Crucially, the E71V mutant lacks the structural water molecules that stabilize the constricted state in wild-type KcsA.
  • MD Simulations Suggest Canonical State is Accessible: Despite experimental evidence to the contrary, MD simulations indicate that the familiar constricted conformation can be achieved by the E71V mutant, suggesting it might be a transient or less stable state.
  • W67-D80 Interaction Dynamics: The interaction between W67 and D80, known to be critical for inactivation in Kv channels, breaks in the E71V mutant upon gate opening, highlighting the allosteric coupling between the gates.
  • Two Inactivated Conformations: ssNMR data reveal that the E71V selectivity filter can adopt two distinct conformations under inactivating conditions, neither of which is the canonical constricted state.
  • Barium Binding Differences: Barium ions, which bind to the S4 site in wild-type KcsA, bind to the S3 site in the E71V mutant, further underscoring altered selectivity and gating.

Key Results

  • X-ray Structures: Revealed a narrowed, but not constricted, selectivity filter in the E71V mutant under inactivating conditions.
  • ssNMR Data: Confirmed the absence of the constricted filter and inactivating water in E71V. It also showed the presence of two distinct, non-constricted inactivated conformations.
  • MD Simulations: Demonstrated that the constricted conformation is energetically accessible to the E71V mutant, though less stable than in WT.
  • Barium Studies: Showed that Ba²⁺ binds to the S3 site in E71V, unlike the S4 site in WT KcsA.
  • Dynamics Measurements: Indicated that the E71V mutation increases the overall dynamics of the channel in the conductive state and leads to rigidification of the S2-S3 sites upon inactivation, contrasting with WT KcsA.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental vs. Simulated Conformations: A key limitation is the discrepancy between experimental observations (no constriction in E71V) and MD simulations (constriction is possible). The authors suggest that the experimental conditions (e.g., presence of Fab fragments in crystallography) might have hindered the sampling of the constricted state.
  • Functional Relevance of Non-Constricted State: While the E71V mutant shows reduced inactivation compared to WT, the precise functional consequence of the non-constricted but narrowed and rigidified filter remains to be fully elucidated.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest further investigation into the role of sidechains behind the selectivity filter and how the voltage sensor might influence filter packing. They also propose that the observed narrowed-rigid state could represent a pre-inactivated functional state that can interconvert into the long-lived constricted state. The heterogeneity of the inactivated E71V filter, potentially due to the absence of water and the W67-D80 interaction rupture, warrants further exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT A large class of K + channels display a time-dependent phenomenon called C-type inactivation whereby prolonged activation by an external stimulus leads to a non-conductive conformation of the selectivity filter. C-type inactivation is of great physiological importance particularly in voltage-activated K + channels (Kv), affecting the firing patterns of neurons and shaping cardiac action potentials. While understanding the molecular basis of inactivation has a direct impact on human health, its structural basis remains unresolved. Knowledge about C-type inactivation has been largely deduced from the pH-activated bacterial K + channel KcsA, whose selectivity filter under inactivating conditions adopts a constricted conformation at the level of the central glycine (TTV G YGD) that is stabilized by tightly bound water molecules. However, C-type inactivation is highly sensitive to the molecular environment surrounding the selectivity filter in the pore domain, which is different in Kv channels than in the model KcsA. In particular, a glutamic acid residue at position 71 along the pore helix in KcsA is consistently substituted by a nonpolar valine in most Kv channels, suggesting that this side chain is an important molecular determinant of function. Here, a combination of X-ray crystallography, solid-state NMR and molecular dynamics simulations of the E71V mutant of KcsA is undertaken to explore the features associated with this Kv-like construct. In both X-ray and ssNMR data, it is observed that the filter of the Kv-like KcsA mutant does not adopt the familiar constricted conformation under inactivating conditions. Rather, the filter appears to adopt a conformation that is slightly narrowed and rigidified over its entire length. No structural inactivation water molecules are present. On the other hand, molecular dynamics simulations indicate that the familiar constricted conformation can nonetheless be stably established in the mutant channel. Together, these findings suggest that the Kv-like E71V mutation in the KcsA channel may be associated with different modes of C-type inactivation, showing that distinct selectivity filter environments entail distinct C-type inactivation mechanisms.
BibTeX
@misc{rohaim2021different,
  author = {Ahmed Rohaim and Bram J. A. Vermeulen and Jing Li and Felix Kümmerer and Federico Napoli and Lydia Blachowicz and João Medeiros‐Silva and Benoı̂t Roux and Markus Weingarth},
  title = {{A different mechanism of C-type inactivation in the Kv-like KcsA mutant E71V}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.09.22.461404},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure