A Design of Resistance Optimization System for Unmanned Submersible Vehicle Based on Response Surface Method

Zifan Wei, Mengyun Wang, Qiang Yu, Songlin YangAdvances 2014 · DOI

Abstract

Estimating the sailing resistance of Unmanned Submersible Vehicles (USVs) is a critical step in hull profile design. Since USVs operate entirely submerged, they experience no wave resistance; instead, drag is dominated by friction and viscous pressure resistance. This paper presents a resistance optimization system that replaces computationally intensive Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations with surrogate models developed using the Response Surface Method (RSM). By evaluating five polynomial function forms, the study identifies that second-order (quadratic) response surfaces with cross-terms provide the optimal balance of accuracy and computational efficiency.

Introduction

The design of efficient underwater vehicles necessitates precise modeling of hull resistance. For USVs, the primary components of drag are friction resistance and viscous pressure resistance, influenced by parameters such as bow length, stern length, middle body length, molded breadth, depth, and rudder aspect ratio. Traditionally, optimizing these parameters requires iterative CFD simulations, which are resource-heavy and time-consuming.

To overcome this bottleneck, the authors propose a mathematical "surrogate model" capable of predicting resistance values nearly instantaneously. This approach decouples complex fluid analysis from the optimization process, allowing for rapid exploration of the design space.

Methodology

The core of the proposed system is the Response Surface Method (RSM), an approximation technique that maps the relationship between design variables and objective functions based on a limited set of data points.

Flowchart of the AUV resistance optimization system.

The researchers utilized a dataset generated for the AUTOSUB AUV, consisting of 16 distinct geometric models. CFD simulations were performed on these models to establish a baseline for resistance. Five polynomial forms were tested to determine the best fit for the physics of the hull:

  1. Linear equations
  2. Quadratic equations without cross-terms
  3. Quadratic equations with cross-terms
  4. Cubic equations without cross-terms
  5. Cubic equations with cross-terms

The optimization framework uses the Admiralty coefficient as the primary objective function, subject to constraints like buoyancy and hydrodynamic torque.

Results and Discussion

The study revealed significant differences in the predictive accuracy of the various RSM models. A key finding was the "Goldilocks" complexity of the mathematical models: higher-order equations did not necessarily yield better results.

Comparison of R² values across different response surface models.

As shown in the performance metrics, the quadratic equation with cross-terms emerged as the top performer. It achieved the highest correlation coefficient ($R^2$) and the lowest Root Mean Square Error (RMSE). Interestingly, cubic equations without cross-terms exhibited the lowest fitting accuracy, highlighting that the interdependencies between variables (e.g., how bow length interacts with molded breadth) are essential for accurate modeling.

Furthermore, the response surface for the hull's "wet area"—a primary driver of friction—showed exceptionally high fitting accuracy across all models, suggesting that geometric properties are more easily approximated than complex fluid behaviors.

Conclusion

The application of the polynomial response surface method effectively streamlines the USV resistance optimization process. By identifying the second-order response surface as the most accurate surrogate, this research provides a foundation for more complex multi-disciplinary optimization. Future work may involve expanding the dataset beyond 16 points to further refine higher-order models and testing the framework on unconventional hull geometries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Estimating the sailing resistance of unmanned submersible vehicle when navigating in the water is an important part for designing the hull profile. As there is no wave resistance when the unmanned submersible vehicle navigating in the water, so the main hull resistance mainly includes friction resistance and viscous pressure resistance. There are a lot factors affecting the resistance of the hull, including the length of bow,the length of stern, the length of middle body, the molded breadth, the molded depth, the design speed and the aspect ratio of rudder. The above factors have been selected as design variables of the resistance optimization system and the regression relationship between design variables and the frictional resistance viscous pressure resistance has been established by the response surface method, which can obtain the approximate function formula between the objective function, constraints and the design variables, providing a basis for the establishing of resistance optimization system. The design can be expanded to an overall situation by this method, then this complex disciplinary analysis can be separated from the optimization process, which can reduce the amount of calculation and optimization time. The application of polynomial response surface method in resistance optimization system has been studied in this paper and the accuracy of five polynomial response surface functions also have been studied, which reflected that the accuracy of second-order response surface is better than that of the first-order and third-order response surface. The response surface of wet area of the hull have a high fitting accuracy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wei2014design,
  author = {Zifan Wei and Mengyun Wang and Qiang Yu and Songlin Yang},
  title = {{A Design of Resistance Optimization System for Unmanned Submersible Vehicle Based on Response Surface Method}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.2991/icmce-14.2014.23},
}

Loading related content...

Figure