TL;DR
This paper delves into the diverse roles of "core users" in online co-creation communities, moving beyond simple activity metrics to identify distinct user types and their specific contributions to sustainable innovation. By analyzing user behavior and content in a Huawei co-creation community, the study reveals that different core user types have varying impacts on innovation and community dynamics, offering valuable insights for companies aiming to foster more effective co-creation.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper addresses a gap in understanding the nuanced contributions of active participants ("core users") within company-hosted online co-creation communities (COCCs), particularly concerning sustainable innovation (SI). While prior research often categorizes users broadly as "core" or "peripheral" based on posting frequency, this study argues that a deeper, more granular understanding of core user types and their specific contributions is crucial for maximizing the potential of co-creation for SI. The authors highlight that existing research has not sufficiently explored how different types of core users contribute to social concerns within a COCC context, nor how their distinct behaviors influence other community members' engagement in SI.
Methods
The researchers employed a three-phase methodological approach:
- Two-step Cluster Analysis: To identify core members, they used a two-step cluster analysis combining hierarchical and non-hierarchical methods. This analysis was based on seven variables reflecting individual members' activities, including original posts, comments made, received likes and comments, influence density, reaction density, manager-oriented comments, and self-oriented comments.
- Content Analysis based on Uses and Gratifications Theory (UGT): To categorize the contributions of identified core members, a content analysis was performed on their posts and comments. This analysis was guided by UGT, focusing on cognitive and social integrative benefits, and identifying 12 coding themes related to contribution types and associated motivations.
- Social Network Analysis and Practice Theory: To understand the influence of different core member types on others, social network analysis was used to calculate centrality measures (in-degree, out-degree, betweenness degree, authority, hub scores). Practice Theory provided a framework to interpret how these network structures and activities influence co-creation behavior.
Datasets
The study utilized data collected from the Huafen online community (https://club.huawei.com/), Huawei's official co-creation community. Specifically, data was gathered from the Huawei Mate20 smartphone series sub-community between February 3rd and March 3rd, 2019. This dataset included 20,256 original posts, 4,124 likes, and 256,910 comments from 13,248 non-manager community members.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond Activity: The Nuance of Core Users: The most significant insight is that simply being "active" doesn't capture the full picture of a core user's role. Different types of core users contribute in distinct ways, impacting the community and SI differently.
- Innovation Leaders Drive SI: "Innovation Leaders" emerged as a critical group, actively contributing new ideas, product suggestions, and competitor analysis, directly fueling sustainable innovation. Their high indegree and outdegree suggest they are central figures in the community's knowledge flow.
- Product Comparers Bridge External Knowledge: The "Product Comparers" role, unique to this study, highlights the value of users who actively compare Huawei products with competitors. This provides crucial external market intelligence for the company.
- Socializers Foster Community Cohesion: While not directly innovation-focused, "Socializers" and "Product-in-life members" play vital roles in building community cohesion and improving social sustainability through their interactions and personal content sharing.
- Context Matters for User Roles: The study emphasizes that user roles can be context-specific. Some identified types, like "Product Comparers," may not be found in other types of online communities, underscoring the unique dynamics of COCCs focused on SI.
Key Results
- Eight Core User Types Identified: Through their analysis, the authors identified eight distinct types of core members: Innovation Leaders, Brand Propagators, Product-in-life members, Product Comparers, Socializers, Community Ambassadors, Product Critics, and Brand Learners.
- Innovation Leaders' Dominance: Innovation Leaders showed the highest indegree and outdegree, indicating they were most followed and influential in the network. They also received significantly more comments than Product Critics and Product Comparers.
- Innovation-Driven Contributors: Innovation Leaders, Product Comparers, and Product Critics (approximately 41% of core members) were identified as the primary contributors to SI, focusing on product-related issues.
- Impact Varies: The study found that different core member types have varying levels of influence. Innovation Leaders and Community Ambassadors appeared to have the largest impact on other members' behaviors in the co-creation process.
- Quantitative Differences: For example, Innovation Leaders received an average of 419.69 comments, significantly more than Product Comparers (225.57) and Product Critics (209.00).
Limitations and Future Work
- Single Community Focus: The study's data was collected from a single Chinese online co-creation community. Future research should validate these findings across different environments and cultures, as cultural backgrounds can influence user behavior.
- Limited Scope of SI: The research focused on sustainable user innovation in social aspects. Future work could integrate other factors like platform construction and knowledge diffusion to build a more holistic SI business model.
- Platform Regulation: The influence of platform regulations and freedom of expression in the host country was not deeply explored and could be a subject for future investigation.
- Generalizability of Roles: While the study identified unique roles like "Product Comparers," further research could explore the generalizability of these roles across different types of online communities.
Summary updated