A Deep Learning Approach to the Screening of Oncogenic Gene Fusions in Humans

Marta Lovino, Gianvito Urgese, Enrico Macii, Santa Di Cataldo, Elisa FicarraInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel deep learning approach using Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) to predict the oncogenic potential of gene fusions directly from their amino acid sequences. This method offers a more flexible and adaptable alternative to existing tools that rely on protein domain analysis, achieving a high-confidence accuracy of 86% in classifying oncogenic gene fusions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gene fusions, where parts of two different genes are joined, are significant contributors to cancer development. However, not all gene fusions lead to cancer; distinguishing between "driver" oncogenic fusions and benign ones is a critical but challenging task. Current methods often rely on analyzing protein domains, which is labor-intensive and difficult to update with new information. This paper addresses the need for a more flexible and automated approach to predict the oncogenic potential of gene fusions, aiming to reduce false positives and improve the efficiency of cancer research.

Methods

The core of this work is a deep learning model based on Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs). Unlike traditional methods that analyze protein domains, this approach takes raw amino acid sequences of gene fusions as input. The authors employ a one-hot encoding strategy to transform these sequences into numerical matrices suitable for CNN input. The CNN architecture consists of convolutional and pooling layers for feature extraction, followed by dense layers for classification. A key aspect of their methodology is its inherent flexibility; the model can be easily retrained on new data, allowing it to adapt to different cancer types or newly discovered information without extensive re-engineering.

Datasets

The study utilized two distinct datasets for training and testing:

  • Onco class: Gene fusions identified from the COSMIC (Catalogue of Somatic Mutations in Cancer) database, specifically focusing on those from solid tumors.
  • NotOnco class: Gene fusions identified from recurrent chimeric fusion RNAs in non-cancer tissues and cells, as reported in a previous study.

To address class imbalance, the larger NotOnco class was down-sampled. The combined dataset comprised 2318 reconstructed fusion sequences, which were then split into a training set (1854 samples) and a test set (464 samples). Crucially, the gene pairs in the test set were entirely distinct from those in the training set to ensure complete independence and robust evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Amino acid sequence is sufficient: The paper demonstrates that raw amino acid sequences, without explicit protein domain information, can be effectively used to predict oncogenic potential. This simplifies the input requirements and bypasses the complexities of domain prediction.
  • CNNs excel at pattern recognition: The use of CNNs allows the model to automatically learn complex spatial patterns within the amino acid sequences that are indicative of oncogenic activity. This eliminates the need for handcrafted feature engineering.
  • Flexibility is paramount: The inherent adaptability of the CNN model, allowing for easy retraining on new data, is a significant advantage over existing, less flexible methods. This is crucial in the rapidly evolving field of cancer genomics.
  • Confidence scores matter: The model not only provides a binary classification (oncogenic/non-oncogenic) but also an oncogenic probability score. This score is vital for assessing the confidence of the prediction, allowing researchers to prioritize fusions with high confidence.

Key Results

The proposed CNN model achieved a promising overall binary classification accuracy of 71.55% on the test set. However, the most compelling results emerged when considering the confidence of the predictions. By focusing on instances classified with high confidence (those with an oncogenic probability score above 0.8 or below 0.2), the accuracy rose significantly to 86% for the Onco class and 80% for the NotOnco class. This means that over 65% of the test samples were classified with a confidence higher than 80%, indicating a reliable prediction. When compared to existing tools like Oncofuse and Pegasus, the proposed CNN model showed a more balanced output and a higher proportion of correct classifications in the high-confidence regions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the model's performance is currently limited by the scarcity of training data. Future work will focus on two main directions:

  • Expanding the dataset: Significantly enlarging the training set is crucial for further improving the predictive model and reducing false positive rates.
  • Interpreting learned features: Investigating the biological patterns automatically extracted by the CNN model could provide deeper insights into the specific mechanisms that influence the oncogenic potential of gene fusions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Gene fusions have a very important role in the study of cancer development. In this regard, predicting the probability of protein fusion transcripts of developing into a cancer is a very challenging and yet not fully explored research problem. To this date, all the available approaches in literature try to explain the oncogenic potential of gene fusions based on protein domain analysis, that is cancer-specific and not easy to adapt to newly developed information. In our work, we choose the raw protein sequences as the input baseline, and propose the use of deep learning, and more specifically Convolutional Neural Networks, to infer the oncogenity probability score of gene fusion transcripts and to group them into a number of categories (e.g., oncogenic/not oncogenic). This is an inherently flexible methodology that, unlike previous approaches, can be re-trained with very less efforts on newly available data (for example, from a different cancer). Based on experimental results on a large dataset of pre-annotated gene fusions, our method is able to predict the oncogenity potential of gene fusion transcripts with accuracy of about 72%, which increases to 86% if we consider the only instances that are classified with a high confidence level.
BibTeX
@article{lovino2019deep,
  author = {Marta Lovino and Gianvito Urgese and Enrico Macii and Santa Di Cataldo and Elisa Ficarra},
  title = {{A Deep Learning Approach to the Screening of Oncogenic Gene Fusions in Humans}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms20071645},
}
Figure