Abstract
Many successful approaches to semantic parsing build on top of the syntactic analysis of text, and make use of distributional representations or statistical models to match parses to ontology-specific queries. This paper presents a novel deep learning architecture which provides a semantic parsing system through the union of two neural models of language semantics. It allows for the generation of ontology-specific queries from natural language statements and questions without the need for parsing, which makes it especially suitable to grammatically malformed or syntactically atypical text, such as tweets, as well as permitting the development of semantic parsers for resource-poor languages.
Introduction
Semantic parsing—the task of translating natural language into formal, machine-readable representations like SQL or lambda calculus—has traditionally relied on complex syntactic pipelines. These systems typically decompose a sentence into its grammatical constituents before mapping them to a target ontology. However, this dependency on syntactic parsing introduces two significant challenges:
- Brittleness: Rule-based syntactic parsers often fail when encountering "noisy" input, such as social media posts or informal speech, where grammar is non-standard.
- Resource Scarcity: High-quality syntactic parsers require extensive annotated corpora, which are unavailable for many low-resource languages.
This work proposes a shift toward distributed representations, using vector-based neural architectures to bypass the need for explicit syntactic rules.
Methodology: A Union of Neural Models
The proposed architecture integrates two distinct neural components to map natural language directly to formal queries.
1. Bilingual Compositional Sentence Model (BiCVM)
The BiCVM is employed to learn a shared latent space between natural language questions and formal database queries. By treating the problem as a cross-lingual task, the model learns to project both inputs into a unified vector space.
As shown in the figure, word embeddings from two "languages" (e.g., English and a query language) are composed into sentence-level embeddings using functions $g$ and $h$. The model is trained using contrastive estimation to ensure that semantically equivalent pairs are close in the latent space.
2. Conditional Neural Language Model (CNLM)
The CNLM serves as the generative component. It takes the latent vector produced by the BiCVM and generates the formal query string symbol-by-symbol. The generation is "conditional" because each subsequent symbol's probability depends on both the previously generated symbols and the original question's latent representation.
The Workflow
The system operates in two main phases:
- Training: The BiCVM is first trained on parallel pairs of questions and queries. Subsequently, the CNLM is trained to decode these latent vectors back into the target query format.
- Inference: A new natural language question is encoded into a vector, which then guides the CNLM to produce the corresponding formal query.
Key Insights
- Parsing without a Parser: By treating semantic parsing as a translation task (Natural Language → Logic), the model learns semantic patterns directly from data, ignoring traditional grammatical labels like "subject" or "verb."
- Robustness to Noise: Distributed representations are inherently more robust to typos and slang than rigid rule-based systems, as small variations in input result in small shifts in the vector space rather than total system failure.
- Language Agnosticism: The architecture is fundamentally language-independent, requiring only parallel (Question, Query) pairs for training, making it viable for resource-poor languages.
Datasets and Evaluation
The authors identify the lack of large-scale training data as a primary bottleneck for neural semantic parsing. They highlight two benchmark datasets:
- GeoQuery: A collection of US geography questions.
- Freebase-related data: Large-scale knowledge base queries.
As a "short paper" focused on architectural proposal, this work does not provide quantitative results. Instead, it establishes the theoretical framework for a generative semantic parser, with the intent to validate it against these benchmarks in future experiments.
Limitations and Future Work
The transition to neural architectures brings new challenges. Neural models are "data-hungry," necessitating the use of bootstrapping techniques to expand small, high-quality datasets. Furthermore, while the current model uses simple composition, more complex, nested database queries may require advanced structures like convolutional neural networks. Future work will focus on extending the model to generate diverse formal expressions, including lambda calculus.
Summary updated