A Decision-Support System for Quote Generation

AAAI 2002

TL;DR

This paper introduces a prototype decision-support system designed to help suppliers generate competitive quotes for business-to-business (B2B) requests for quote (RFQs). By integrating inventory, production capacity, and external supply data, the system suggests optimal ways to fulfill RFQs, considering tradeoffs in cost, quality, and delivery, ultimately aiming to maximize expected profit.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the growing challenge faced by businesses in the B2B e-commerce landscape: managing a deluge of RFQs. Traditionally, responding to RFQs involves complex negotiation and manual analysis of numerous factors like production schedules, inventory levels, and customer preferences. This process is time-consuming and labor-intensive, especially when dealing with a high volume of requests. Furthermore, the decision of whether to bid on an RFQ, and at what price, is often influenced by other outstanding bids and potential future opportunities, creating a complex, interdependent decision-making problem. The authors aim to automate and optimize this process, allowing suppliers to focus on strategic aspects like pricing and customer relationships rather than getting bogged down in operational details.

Methods

The core of the system is an agent-based architecture that operates in three stages:

  • Demand Filtering: Agents retrieve and filter RFQs, identifying those relevant to the supplier's capabilities.
  • Supply Search: Search agents (both generic and domain-aware) query internal and external sources (e-marketplaces, inventory systems) to find potential supply items that can fulfill the RFQ requirements. Domain-aware agents are crucial here, as they understand how to relax search constraints and identify transformable or substitutable items.
  • Matching and Evaluation: A decision support engine employs a team of agents to generate and evaluate a set of non-dominated solutions. These solutions represent different ways to fulfill RFQs, considering factors like cost, quality, delivery date, and manufacturing disruptions. The system uses techniques that can approximate problems like the knapsack problem and integer programming, employing iterative improvement heuristics.

The system is built using Java and leverages emerging web services standards (UDDI, WSDL, SOAP) for integration with external e-marketplaces.

Datasets

The paper describes an example using data from a fictional paper converter. The "datasets" in this context are the RFQs themselves (represented by demand items D1 and D2) and the available resources:

  • Inventory: Existing stock of paper rolls (items S1, S2, S3).
  • Production Capacity: Internal machines (M1, M2) with their respective capacities and availability dates.
  • Electronic Inventory: Paper rolls available from external e-marketplaces (items E1, E2, E3).

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but uses a realistic scenario to illustrate the system's functionality.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Interdependence of RFQs: A critical insight is that decisions about one RFQ cannot be made in isolation. Winning or losing one bid can significantly impact the ability to fulfill others, affecting production schedules, resource allocation, and overall profitability. The system explicitly models these interdependencies.
  • Tradeoffs are Key: The system excels at presenting decision-makers with clear tradeoffs between competing objectives (cost, quality, delivery, disruptions). This allows for informed decisions, rather than just a single "best" solution.
  • Domain Knowledge is Crucial: The distinction between generic and domain-aware search agents highlights the importance of incorporating specific industry knowledge (e.g., how paper rolls can be trimmed or combined) to find more flexible and cost-effective solutions.
  • Web Services Enable Integration: The reliance on web services demonstrates a practical approach to integrating diverse data sources (internal systems, external e-marketplaces) in a standardized way.

Key Results

The paper presents a detailed example with 22 possible solutions for two RFQs (D1 and D2). The system successfully identifies non-dominated solutions, illustrating various tradeoffs. For instance:

  • Solution 1 (producing D1 independently) is dominated by Solution 4, which offers a lower cost with similar evaluations.
  • Solutions 7 and 12 show the tradeoff between disruptions and cost for producing D2.
  • Solutions 13-22 demonstrate the benefits of combining RFQs, showing how integrated production can reduce waste and improve efficiency compared to handling RFQs individually.

The system's ability to present these options and their evaluations allows the decision-maker to make more strategic choices.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Probabilistic Reasoning: The current prototype does not fully incorporate probabilistic reasoning. Future work aims to enable the system to create conditional plans that maximize expected utility, considering the decision-maker's risk preferences.
  • Data Mining for Preferences: The authors plan to use data mining to infer customer preferences and estimate the probability of winning an order with a given quote. This will help in suggesting quotes that maximize customer satisfaction and seller profit.
  • Pilot Deployment: The system is currently a prototype. The next step is pilot deployment with potential customers to gather real-world feedback.
  • Dynamic Bidding Strategies: While the system suggests quotes, future work will focus on developing more dynamic bidding strategies that adapt to changing market conditions and auction outcomes.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{2002decision,
  title = {{A Decision-Support System for Quote Generation}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2002},
}
Figure